
When the New 3DS reached North America on February 13, 2015, only the XL came over. Nintendo of America's Damon Baker said the company did not want to confuse consumers, and that face plates were not enough of a reason to bring the smaller model. Fans started a social media campaign, and the small one finally arrived on September 25, 2015, in an Animal Crossing bundle.
Nintendo was right to worry about the confusion. Ask your parents for a new 3DS and you could unwrap the old one, and every Christmas list turned into a fight over 3DS vs New 3DS.
Only four boxed games ever needed the New model, and almost everything else plays on the cheaper old one. Ask a New 3DS owner and they will tell you that number means nothing, because they have seen the 3D hold still. In this article we will find out which one you should buy.
Buy a New 3DS if you can afford it, buy an old 3DS if you can't

The old models are the 3DS, 3DS XL and 2DS. The New models are the New 3DS, New 3DS XL and New 2DS XL, which is the same 3DS family with better parts. Both groups play DS and 3DS games, so Super Mario 3D Land works on all of them.
Buy a New model if you want the 3D, Xenoblade Chronicles 3D or a modded handheld for emulators. Buy an old model if you want Pokémon and Zelda for the least money. Players who have tried both mostly say the New one is worth it, and owners still complain about the name.
The New 3DS fixed the 3D

On an old 3DS the 3D only works if you hold the console at the right angle, and players remember fighting to keep it there.
The New 3DS has Super Stable 3D. A sensor tracks your face, and one of the new processor cores adjusts the picture to the angle you are looking from. An IGN writer tried it on a morning train commute and said the swaying only very occasionally broke the effect. Players who gave up on the old 3D say the New models made it work.
This round only counts if you use the 3D. Plenty of owners keep the slider off on both models. If that is you, Majora's Mask 3D looks the same on either one. Everyone else, point to the New 3DS.
The C-Stick is tiny and it still beats no stick

The New models add a small pointing stick called the C-Stick, plus ZL and ZR shoulder buttons. An old 3DS needs the Circle Pad Pro add-on for those controls, and games made for that add-on work with the new ones. GameSpot found the stick surprisingly responsive. IGN compared it to the pointing stick on a ThinkPad laptop and said it would not work well for first-person shooters.
Players call it tiny and stiff. It is the size of a pencil eraser, and nobody is writing poems about it.
They use it anyway, because it gives you real camera control in games like Monster Hunter and Metal Gear Solid 3D. Super Smash Bros. uses it too. Point to the New 3DS.
Xenoblade Chronicles 3D only runs on a New 3DS

Xenoblade Chronicles 3D came out in North America on April 10, 2015, and won't start on an older console. Minecraft: New Nintendo 3DS Edition, Runbow Pocket and Fire Emblem Warriors are the other boxed games that need a New model. The Binding of Isaac is locked to the New models too.
Xenoblade is the one on that list players rave about, and it can eat 100 hours. There is one catch. It is on Switch now, and players who own a Switch say to play it there.
Monster Hunter and Smash run better on a New 3DS

The New models went from two processor cores to four and have 256 MB of RAM. Some 3DS games run better because of it. Players say Monster Hunter 4 Ultimate has a smoother frame rate on a New 3DS, and that it still plays fine on the old one.
Super Smash Bros. loads faster as well. Only some games get a boost, so don't expect your whole shelf to speed up.
Pokémon Sun is where the old 3DS shows its age

Pokémon Sun and Moon have more lag on the old models, and double battles are the worst of it. The New models run them better, but players say they still stutter in places. Game Freak asked a lot of this hardware. A totem Pokémon is less scary in slow motion. Point to the New 3DS.
The New 3DS is the one to mod

Nintendo started selling SNES games on Virtual Console for the New 3DS in March 2016, and players on an old 3DS never got them. The eShop closed on March 27, 2023, so nobody can buy Super Metroid there now.
That leaves custom firmware, a software mod for the console. Players say you need little more than a PC and an SD card, and it works on any 3DS. The New models get more out of it. Players say the old 3DS struggles with emulators and the New 3DS handles SNES games well.
Don't expect miracles. A modded New 3DS can reach PS1, but players say PS1 games are where it starts to run out of breath.
The old 3DS wins on the SD card

The New 3DS comes with a 4 GB microSD card, and it fills up fast once you add download games like The Binding of Isaac. Changing it is a pain. The old models use standard SD cards. The New models keep the microSD card next to the battery, behind a rear cover held on with screws. GameSpot complained about "stubborn screws and a panel that practically refuses to detach".
Owners agree, and some have stripped screws or cracked the back to prove it. Buy a small screwdriver and go slowly. You can also move files over wifi from a PC, which saves a lot of unscrewing. The old 3DS takes this round.
The small New 3DS is the prettiest and the hardest to find

Only the small New 3DS has swappable face plates. Japan got 38 designs at launch, and the XL got none. The North American Animal Crossing: Happy Home Designer bundle cost $219.99 and came with two plates. Players still love the colored buttons, which copy the Super Famicom.
Nintendo's numbers show why it is scarce: 2.49 million New 3DS consoles against 12.25 million New 3DS XLs. Players say the small one is rare and expensive now.
You get a sharper picture for the money, because the same resolution sits on a smaller screen. You also get a smaller console, and players with bigger hands say it cramps them.
The New 3DS is built better

Players rate the build quality of the New models above the old ones. The weak spot is the finish, and some glossy XLs have peeling paint, so look closely at the photos before you buy. You want a solid console if you plan to spend Monster Hunter Generations hours on it. Point to the New 3DS, as long as yours has kept its paint.
IPS screens are a lottery

Some New 3DS consoles have IPS panels, the kind with better viewing angles, on one or both screens. Most still have the old twisted nematic panels. There is no known link between model number or production date and panel type, and Nintendo has never talked about it. Players call an IPS console a lucky find, and dual IPS is the rarest of all. Star Fox 64 3D is fine on either panel, so don't pay extra for the hunt.
The New 3DS costs more and holds its value

For Black Friday 2016, Nintendo sold Mario-themed New 3DS consoles for $99.99. Used prices have climbed a long way since. Owners expect the New 3DS XL to keep getting more expensive, and an old 3DS is still much cheaper.
The games can be the cheap part. A loose copy of Xenoblade Chronicles 3D typically sells for $19.
The New 3DS takes the resale round. Check that a used one comes with a charger, because the New models had no AC adapter in the box in North America. A DSi charger fits.
Which one wins?
On paper the New 3DS wins, with 3D that works and a faster chip. That means very little if an old 3DS is the one you carried to school. It is yours, scratches and all. You remember the people you passed on StreetPass and the Pokémon team you raised under the covers, and those were just as good on a console with no New in its name.





