3DS vs PS Vita

3DS vs PS Vita

3DS vs PS Vita

Monster Hunter had kept the PSP alive in Japan, and Sony expected a lot from it on the next handheld. Capcom took the series to Nintendo instead. On December 10, 2011, Monster Hunter Tri G came out on the 3DS in Japan. The PS Vita went on sale there on December 17, one week later, with the series that had saved the PSP already sitting on the other console.

Handheld fans had to pick a side. You had a 3D slider and a Nintendo game in the cartridge slot, or you had two real sticks and a screen your friends wanted to borrow. By the next Christmas, whole friend groups were split over 3DS vs PS Vita.

The 3DS family sold 75.94 million consoles, about five times the estimated 15 to 16 million Vitas. Vita owners shrug at that number and hand you the console to look at. In this article we will settle which one was the better handheld.

The 3DS screen was never sharp enough

Gravity Rush
Gravity Rush.

The first Vita has a 5-inch OLED touchscreen at 960 × 544. The top screen on the original 3DS measures 3.53 inches and shows 400 × 240 per eye. Put them side by side and the 3DS looks like it came from a different decade.

Players who own both still pick on the low resolution of the 3DS, even when they love the console. Sony later swapped the OLED for a cheaper LCD, so the screen to hunt for is on the first model. The Vita takes this round without trying.

The Vita was a portable PS3

Uncharted: Golden Abyss
Uncharted: Golden Abyss.

The Vita has a quad-core ARM Cortex-A9 processor, 512 MB of system RAM and 128 MB of VRAM. The original 3DS has 128 MB of FCRAM and 6 MB of VRAM. Before launch, third-party studios showed tech demos built from their PlayStation 3 assets, including Metal Gear Solid 4.

Players agree the Vita was the far stronger machine. Uncharted: Golden Abyss was there on launch day in the West, one of 25 launch titles, and it looked like nothing the 3DS could run.

The Vita cost more before you bought a single game

Tearaway
Tearaway.

Nintendo announced a major price cut on July 28, 2011, taking nearly a third off the 3DS and bringing it down to $169.99. The Vita did not reach $199 in North America until August 2013. Players remember the 3DS cut as the moment the Vita started to look overpriced.

Then you had to buy storage. The Vita does not take SD cards, and the original 3DS came with a 2 GB SD card in the box. Sony's own cards were the sore spot for Vita owners, and Shuhei Yoshida, then head of Sony's game studios, later called them "incredibly expensive". He named them as a reason the Vita failed, along with a back touchpad that was not used by many games. The price went down in 2013, long after the 3DS had pulled away. The 3DS wins this one by a mile.

The 3DS had the games

Mario Kart 7
Mario Kart 7.

Most players who owned both give the same answer: the 3DS had the better library, and a much bigger one. Zelda and Pokémon lived there, and Monster Hunter moved in too.

The most successful game on the 3DS is Mario Kart 7, at 18.99 million copies worldwide. That one game sold more copies than Sony sold Vitas. Meanwhile, big third-party companies like Ubisoft and Activision started reducing or eliminating support for the Vita after 2012.

"The Vita has no games" was never true

Persona 4 Golden
Persona 4 Golden.

That line is the one Vita fans hate most, and they will happily walk you through their shelf to prove it wrong. When the big publishers left, the Vita got stronger support in JRPGs, visual novels and Western-developed indie games, and that kept going through 2017. Persona 4 Golden came out in 2012, and for plenty of people it was the reason to own a Vita at all.

Minecraft even sold over 1.2 million physical copies on the Vita in Japan. The 3DS still has the bigger library, but the Vita's is no joke if you like long RPGs and don't mind reading.

The 3D slider spent most of its life switched off

Super Mario 3D Land
Super Mario 3D Land.

The 3DS shows 3D with no special glasses, and a slider beside the screen lets you turn it down or off. Plenty of players did exactly that. They call it a gimmick, and many only ever turned it on for one or two games.

It has its defenders. Some players say the picture looks flat without it, and others who expected to hate it came away impressed. Sony's touchpad on the back of the Vita had a far worse life, because at least people tried the slider. Call this one a draw between two tricks most owners ignored.

The Vita had the second stick the 3DS had to bolt on

Killzone: Mercenary
Killzone: Mercenary.

The Vita has two analog joysticks. The 3DS has one circle pad, and for a second one you had to buy the Circle Pad Pro. The New 3DS later added a small C-Stick. A shooter like Killzone: Mercenary simply makes more sense on a Vita.

Players also find the Vita easier on the hands over a long session. Most 3DS games never asked for a second stick, so this mattered less than it sounds, but the win goes to Sony.

StreetPass made you carry your 3DS everywhere

Animal Crossing: New Leaf
Animal Crossing: New Leaf.

StreetPass Mii Plaza comes pre-installed on every Nintendo 3DS, and it turned the console into something you took with you whether you were playing or not. Players still talk about it fondly, and some admit it was the thing they used most. In Japan, a trip on the subway could fill the plaza with strangers.

Walking past another 3DS owner felt like a small event. The Vita stayed in the bag. Nintendo takes this one easily.

Remote Play was the Vita's best trick

Bloodborne
Bloodborne.

Almost every PS4 game can be played on a Vita through Remote Play. In its later years Sony leaned on this hard, and for a lot of owners it became the main reason to keep the console charged. Bloodborne in bed, while someone else watches the TV, was a very good deal.

Nintendo had no answer on the 3DS. Sony's Yoshida said in 2014 that "it's not about individual Vita games any more", which was a strange thing to hear from the company selling them.

Nintendo stayed and Sony walked away

Monster Hunter 4 Ultimate
Monster Hunter 4 Ultimate.

Yoshida said Sony would be releasing fewer first party games, and Killzone: Mercenary and Tearaway in 2013 were close to the end of the big ones. Players still say Sony gave up on the Vita too soon. In 2018 Sony said there would be no successor, and production stopped on March 1, 2019.

Nintendo kept going. It released the New Nintendo 2DS XL on July 28, 2017, months after the Switch was already out, and the 3DS was not discontinued until September 16, 2020. Nobody ever had to wonder whether the 3DS would get another game next month.

The 3DS plays your old carts, and the Vita can't touch your UMDs

Pokémon HeartGold
Pokémon HeartGold.

The 3DS is backward compatible with all Nintendo DS and Nintendo DSi software. Pop in Pokémon HeartGold and it works. The Vita plays PSP games and most PS one Classics, but with no UMD drive you only get the ones released digitally, and a bag of UMDs gets you nothing.

The stores flip this one around a little. The 3DS eShop closed on March 27, 2023. The Vita's store is set to shut down in July 2027, and past purchases can still be downloaded after that. It still doesn't save the Vita here, because a DS cart needs no store at all.

Both are still the best way to play their own games

Luigi's Mansion: Dark Moon
Luigi's Mansion: Dark Moon.

Owners of modern emulation handhelds still keep these two around, and they say the real console is the best way to play 3DS and Vita games. Two screens and a 3D slider are hard to copy on a single flat display.

Both also get better once you hack them. A modified 3DS plays Game Boy, NES, SNES and DS games from one menu, and a modified Vita can use cheap micro SD cards through an adapter, which finally fixes Sony's memory card problem. This one is a draw, and owners of both are the happiest people in this article.

The 3DS wins on resale

Yo-Kai Watch 3
Yo-Kai Watch 3.

Nintendo's handheld holds its value better at the top. A loose copy of Yo-Kai Watch 3 typically sells for $406, Yo-Kai Watch 2: Psychic Specters for $220 and Rhythm Thief & the Emperor's Treasure for $115. Kirby's Extra Epic Yarn still goes for $75.

The Vita has rare games of its own. A Rose in the Twilight sells for $180 and Mary Skelter: Nightmares for $85. Its famous games stay cheap, with Persona 4 Golden at $24 and Uncharted: Golden Abyss at $25, which is good news if you are buying and bad news if you are selling.

Which one wins?

On paper the 3DS wins, with more consoles sold and more games to play on them. It doesn't matter. If your handheld was a Vita, the long nights with Persona 4 Golden are still yours, and no sales chart can reach them. Nobody loved either of these consoles for its spec sheet. You loved the one that went everywhere with you, and the memories you made with it. Vita owners do get one last win: theirs still has the prettier screen.

Related articles