3DS vs Switch

3DS vs Switch

3DS vs Switch

Nintendo put the Switch on sale on March 3, 2017. Less than five months later, on July 28, it launched another handheld in North America and Europe, the New Nintendo 2DS XL. Nintendo avoided calling the Switch a direct successor to the 3DS, and it kept the 3DS line going until September 16, 2020.

For three and a half years the two sat in the same store. Kids with birthday money stood at the glass case and argued, and every car ride with a cousin turned into 3DS vs Switch.

The Switch has shipped close to 1.6 billion games. 3DS games sold 392.29 million, about one for every four. Ask anyone who still carries a 3DS and they will tell you that number means nothing, because a Switch can't fold shut in your pocket. In this article we will find out who really won.

The 3DS fits in your pocket and the Switch doesn't

Pokémon X
Pokémon X.

The 3DS kept the clamshell design of the DS. You close the lid and the game waits for you, which is how a Pokémon game gets played on a car trip. Owners of both consoles still call the 3DS the smaller and easier one to carry, and they say nobody ever designed the Switch for a pocket.

Even the small Switch didn't fix that. The Switch Lite measures 1.9 inches longer than a New 3DS XL, and that was the big model of the 3DS family. With nothing to fold over the screen, the Switch also wants a case for the trip. The 3DS takes this round and your jeans agree.

The Switch goes on your TV and the 3DS never could

The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild
The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild.

The name says it. Nintendo picked "Switch" for the console's ability to switch from handheld to home console modes. Drop it in the dock and the same save carries on at up to 1080p on your TV. Players call this the reason to own one, and they say a portable that doubles as a home console solved most of their problems.

Multiplayer gets the same treatment. The two Joy-Con can come off and be used unattached, and a single console supports up to eight of them. No 3DS ever gave a friend a controller. The Switch wins this one easily.

The Switch has the sharper screen

Super Mario 3D Land
Super Mario 3D Land.

The original Switch has a 6.2-inch 720p screen. The top screen on the first 3DS is 3.53 inches at 400 × 240 per eye, and the bottom one is 320 × 240. The 3DS XL grew the top screen to 4.88 inches and kept the same 400 × 240 for each eye.

Players feel it the moment they go back. They talk about how low the resolution is, and some 3DS XL owners call the picture blurry and dim. Super Mario 3D Land is a lovely game trapped behind that screen. The Switch wins here, and it isn't close.

Two screens gave the 3DS games the Switch can't copy

Etrian Odyssey IV: Legends of the Titan
Etrian Odyssey IV: Legends of the Titan.

Etrian Odyssey started on the DS with a small map on the touchscreen, and you fill it in yourself with the stylus. The 3DS games kept the idea. You look up at the dungeon and down at your own bad handwriting.

Fans say this is the real reason to keep a 3DS. They say the dual screen experience can't be recreated on other systems, and that many of these games will never come to the Switch for that reason. The 3DS takes the round.

Nothing else does what the 3D slider does

The Legend of Zelda: A Link Between Worlds
The Legend of Zelda: A Link Between Worlds.

The 3DS shows 3D pictures with no special glasses. Plenty of owners left the slider down, but the ones who loved it still do, and some New 3DS owners never turn it off. Players pick A Link Between Worlds as the best use of it.

The Switch has no answer, and neither does an emulator. Fans say you can't easily reproduce the effect anywhere else, so playing on the real console is the only way to see it. Nobody at the bus stop will be impressed, but you will.

The Switch had the bigger games

Mario Kart 8 Deluxe
Mario Kart 8 Deluxe.

Line up the biggest hits and the 3DS gets flattened. Mario Kart 8 Deluxe has reached 72.00 million copies, and Mario Kart 7 is the best-selling 3DS game at nearly 19 million. Animal Crossing: New Horizons sold 50.63 million, while all versions of Animal Crossing: New Leaf combined reached 13.07 million. Breath of the Wild sold 35.76 million by June 2026 and Super Mario Odyssey sold over 30.8 million.

The 3DS did get a fine Metroid in 2017 with Samus Returns, and Nintendo then gave its developer MercurySteam the job of making Metroid Dread for the Switch. Players who own both say the Switch is the one they reach for first, and for some it replaced the 3DS outright. The Switch wins the games.

The 3DS plays your old shelf and the Switch starts from zero

Luigi's Mansion: Dark Moon
Luigi's Mansion: Dark Moon.

The 3DS runs all Nintendo DS and DSi software, apart from games that need the Game Boy Advance slot. That is two whole libraries in one console, and players still call a 3DS the best way to play them.

The Switch has no native backward compatibility with any earlier Nintendo console. A few 3DS games have crossed over. Luigi's Mansion: Dark Moon reached the Switch on June 27, 2024, eleven years after the 3DS version, and Bravely Default skipped the first Switch and landed on the Switch 2 in 2025. Switch owners do get their payback later, since the Switch 2 plays most Switch games. For now the 3DS wins this one.

StreetPass never made it to the Switch

Animal Crossing: New Leaf
Animal Crossing: New Leaf.

A 3DS in your bag swapped data with any other 3DS it passed, and the green light on the console told you it had happened. In Animal Crossing: New Leaf, the Happy Home Showcase let you look around the homes of the players you had walked past.

Fans still miss it. They wish it had come to the Switch, and they find it strange that the Switch has nothing like it. StreetPass works locally, so it is the one communication service still running on the 3DS. The hard part in 2026 is finding someone else with a 3DS in their bag.

Joy-Con drift gave the 3DS an easy round

Super Mario Odyssey
Super Mario Odyssey.

Stick drift is when a controller moves by itself, with nobody touching the stick. It hit the Joy-Con so often that a class action suit was filed in July 2019, and Nintendo told its North American support staff to fix drifting Joy-Con free of charge whatever the warranty said.

Players still gripe about it. Some say the fix never fully arrived, and some rate the 3DS Circle Pad as more precise for small moves. The Circle Pad is a little plastic disc from 2011. The Joy-Con lost to it anyway.

The 3DS shop is closed and the Switch shop is open

Metroid Dread
Metroid Dread.

The 3DS eShop closed on March 27, 2023, and the Virtual Console went with it. The online service ended on April 8, 2024, which took online play with it. Players are still sore about it, and they point out that you can no longer give Nintendo money for 3DS software.

The eShop lives on for the Switch and Switch 2. If you want Metroid Dread tonight, you can have it. Want a download-only 3DS game? Hope somebody kept theirs. The Switch wins, and the gap grows each year.

The Switch plays games from anywhere

Monster Hunter 4 Ultimate
Monster Hunter 4 Ultimate.

All 3DS consoles are region locked. A game bought in one region only plays on hardware from that region. Bring home a Japanese Monster Hunter 4 and your American 3DS won't start it, which is a rough way to find out.

The Switch has no region lockout. Import whatever you like and it runs. For anyone who collects Japanese games, this round is the Switch's.

The 3DS is the easy one to mod

Fire Emblem Awakening
Fire Emblem Awakening.

Modding means changing a console's software so it runs things Nintendo never approved. Players call the 3DS very easy to mod and say anyone who can follow directions can do it. A modded 3DS holds SNES, Game Boy and Genesis games next to its own, and your carts still work, so Fire Emblem Awakening goes right back in the slot.

The Switch is harder. An exploit found in 2018 could not be patched by a software update, and that covers the early consoles. Owners of the later ones talk about soldering in a modchip. For retro fans, the 3DS is the better toy.

The 3DS wins on resale

Yo-kai Watch 3
Yo-kai Watch 3.

Common games don't tell the story. Mario Kart 7 sells for $13 loose and Mario Kart 8 Deluxe for $32, more than double. Pokémon Ultra Sun goes for $40 against $30 for Pokémon Sword, and that is where the 3DS starts to pull ahead.

At the top end it isn't a contest. Yo-kai Watch 3 typically sells for $406 loose, and Radiant Historia: Perfect Chronology for $70. Players say the consoles have climbed too. They keep getting more expensive, and New 3DS models are going up in value because they are still the best way to play these games. Hang on to yours.

Which one wins?

On paper the Switch wins, with more games and a TV in the deal. It doesn't matter. If your console folded shut in a backpack, the Happy Home you walked past on the way to school is still yours, and no chart can touch it. If yours sat in a dock, so are the Mario Kart nights on the couch. The console you grew up with is the one that counts, and what made it special was the time you spent with it.

Related articles