
The first DSi design had two game card slots, because fans and Nintendo's own staff had asked for it. In October 2007, project leader Masato Kuwahara showed it to Nintendo's producers and asked who would want to own one. Three said yes and seven said no. Kuwahara called it "as bad as I had feared." Nintendo dropped the second slot, and it removed the Game Boy Advance slot too, to make the console easier to carry.
Every lunch table ended up with one kid taking blurry photos on a new DSi and another with Pokémon Emerald sticking out of a DS Lite, and they argued over DS Lite vs DSi until the bell.
DS Lites made up over 60 percent of all DS hardware shipped. The DSi and DSi XL together sold over 41 million. Ask a DSi owner and they will tell you that number means nothing, because they got the better screens. In this article we will find out which one you should buy.
Buy a DS Lite for cartridges, buy a DSi for an SD card

Both play Mario Kart DS and almost all of the DS library. All DS games work on a DSi except the ones that need the Game Boy Advance slot.
Buy a DS Lite if you own Game Boy Advance cartridges or want to collect them. Buy a DSi if you want the bigger screens and plan to load your games from an SD card. Most players give the same advice.
The DS Lite plays Game Boy Advance cartridges

The DS Lite has a slot on the bottom for Game Boy Advance cartridges, so Metroid: Zero Mission goes straight in. The DSi has an SD card slot instead of that second cartridge slot and can't play them.
A lot of players stay on the DS Lite for this slot alone. Point to the DS Lite.
Some DS games need that slot too

Guitar Hero: On Tour plugs its guitar grip into the Game Boy Advance slot, so it won't work on a DSi. The Rumble Pak needs the same slot.
Pokémon fans lose something too. On a DS Lite, Pokémon Diamond and Pearl have a Dual Slot mode: put a Game Boy Advance Pokémon game in the bottom slot and you can bring your old team across. You can't do that on a DSi.
The DSi has the better screens

The DSi has 3.25-inch screens and the DS Lite has 3-inch screens, both at 256 × 192 pixels. A quarter of an inch sounds small until you play The World Ends with You and watch both screens at once.
Players who own both say the DSi screens look better, and it's the first thing they bring up. If you want to go bigger, the DSi XL has 4.2-inch screens at the same resolution.
The DSi is the easier one to mod

A DSi can be modded without buying anything but an SD card, and then your games load straight from that card. A DS Lite has no SD card slot, so it needs a flash cart, a cartridge that holds your games. The DSi also has four times the RAM, and its ARM9 processor is twice as fast.
A modded DSi can run Game Boy Advance games, but only in software, and players report sound problems and crashes in some of them. Check a compatibility list before you plan on playing Castlevania: Aria of Sorrow that way.
The DSi plays games the DS Lite can't

The Nintendo DSi Shop sold DSiWare, download games and apps for the DSi. Shantae: Risky's Revenge was a downloadable DSiWare title, and Flipnote Studio was a free animation app. DSi-exclusive game cards won't run on older models either. The DSi also has two cameras, at 0.3 megapixels each, which was already a joke in 2009.
Nintendo shut down the shop on March 31, 2017. You can't buy any of it now, so this win counts for less than it did.
The DS Lite battery lasts longer

On the lowest brightness a DS Lite lasts 15 to 19 hours and a DSi lasts 9 to 14. The DS Lite has a 1000 mAh battery and the DSi has 840 mAh. Players still call the DS Lite battery legendary.
A flash cart eats into that lead, because flash carts drain the battery. Even so, the DS Lite gives you a very long Dragon Quest IX session.
The DS Lite hinge is the one that cracks

The DSi launched in the United States and Canada on April 5, 2009, alongside Rhythm Heaven, and players say it has held up better. The hinge is the DS Lite's weak spot, so check for cracks before you pay.
Most players also prefer the DSi's buttons, which are clickier than the soft ones on a DS Lite. Point to the DSi.
The DS Lite has no region lock

The DSi is Nintendo's first region-locked handheld. It stops you from using certain software from another region, and Pokémon Black and White are the games importers run into. On a DS Lite they run with no problem. Import fans get an easy pick here.
Both are cheap, and the games hold their value

Used DS Lite and DSi consoles are still cheap. The money is in the games, because Nintendo games hold their value. A copy of Pokémon Emerald is the kind of cartridge you keep, and only the DS Lite will play it. The DS Lite takes the resale round.
Which one wins?
On paper the DSi wins, with bigger screens and four times the memory. It doesn't matter. If a DS Lite went everywhere with you, no spec sheet will talk you out of it. The best part was never the hardware. It was the Mario Kart races at lunch and the Pokémon you traded before the bell, and you get to keep those on either one.





