DS vs GBA

DS vs GBA

DS vs GBA

Nintendo did not sell the DS as the next Game Boy. When it went on sale in North America on November 21, 2004, it was marketed as an experimental "third pillar", a strange two-screen machine to sit next to the Game Boy Advance and the GameCube. Then the experiment sold so well that everyone started calling it the successor anyway.

Kids who had saved up for a GBA suddenly had a friend with two screens and a stylus. Half of them thought it was a gimmick, and every lunch table had the same fight over DS vs GBA.

The DS runs at 67 MHz and the GBA at 16.8 MHz, about four times the speed, and it plays GBA cartridges on top of that. Ask anyone who still carries a GBA and they will tell you those numbers mean nothing. In this article we will find out who really won.

The DS plays GBA games and the GBA can't touch a DS card

Metroid Fusion
Metroid Fusion.

The DS has two slots. DS cards go in the top and Game Boy Advance cartridges go in the bottom. Inside is the same ARM7TDMI chip the GBA uses, and that chip runs your old games. Players who bought a DS or DS Lite got two libraries in one console, and they still rate that as the best thing about it.

Nintendo took the slot away on the DSi and never brought it back on a DS. If you want both libraries on real cartridges, you need an original DS or a DS Lite.

The GBA still plays your Game Boy games

Mario Kart: Super Circuit
Mario Kart: Super Circuit.

The extra slot came with a price. The DS can't run Game Boy or Game Boy Color games at all, and the GBA takes both. If your shelf goes back to the first Game Boy, the GBA is the console that plays all of it.

Multiplayer is the other catch. The DS has no port for the Link Cable, so GBA games on a DS are single-player only. Linking up four people for Mario Kart: Super Circuit takes real GBAs, and the GBA wins this round.

A DS Lite is the best screen a GBA game ever had

Castlevania: Circle of the Moon
Castlevania: Circle of the Moon.

The original GBA has a reflective screen that is hard to see in dark conditions. Players still warn you to play the darker games on a DS or a backlit SP, and Castlevania: Circle of the Moon is the one they point to. The DS Lite has brighter displays, and players call it the best way to see a GBA game on original hardware.

Your hands may disagree. On a DS Lite the cartridge sticks out of the bottom of the console, and players who tried both find the GBA nicer to hold. The DS wins this round on looks alone.

The touchscreen made games the GBA could never run

WarioWare: Touched!
WarioWare: Touched!.

The bottom screen is the reason the DS exists. Nintendogs sold 23.96 million copies and Brain Age sold 19.01 million, and neither would make any sense with a d-pad. Players say the best touch games can't be moved anywhere else without losing what made them good.

Not every game earned it. Players remember plenty of early DS games using the stylus only because it was there. The good ones were good enough to make the DS the winner here by a long way.

GBA pixel art aged better than early DS 3D

Super Mario 64 DS
Super Mario 64 DS.

The GBA has hardware performance comparable to the Super Nintendo, and most GBA games stick to 2D. The DS went for 3D, with about 2,048 triangles per frame on one screen, and some games appear blocky because of how it filters textures.

Super Mario 64 DS put a Nintendo 64 game in your hands, which was thrilling at the time. Time has been kinder to the sprites. Players say early DS 3D looks ugly today, and they miss the pixel art the GBA had. A DS game in plain 2D looks lovely, but the GBA takes this one.

Pokémon moved to the DS and brought your team along

Pokémon Platinum Version
Pokémon Platinum Version.

Diamond and Pearl sold around 18 million copies, over 2 million more than Ruby and Sapphire on the GBA. The two slots gave them a trick no other console could do. Put a GBA Pokémon game in the bottom slot and you can move your Pokémon up to the DS games.

You need an original DS or a DS Lite for that too. It was the rare sequel that rewarded you for keeping your old console's games, and the DS gets the win.

Castlevania and Advance Wars split the difference

Castlevania: Dawn of Sorrow
Castlevania: Dawn of Sorrow.

Some series lived on both consoles, and fans refuse to choose. Ask about the GBA and DS Castlevania games and players talk about them as one great run. Aria of Sorrow is on the GBA. Its sequel, Dawn of Sorrow, is on the DS and asks you to draw a pattern with the stylus to defeat powerful enemies, and it swapped the old art for a distinctive anime look.

Advance Wars is easier to settle. Players put Dual Strike on the DS ahead of the two GBA games. Call this round a draw, with a small nod to the two-screen console.

The GBA had Metroid and the DS got a shooter

Metroid Prime Hunters
Metroid Prime Hunters.

Metroid Fusion is a Game Boy Advance game and one of the reasons to own one. The DS got Metroid Prime Hunters, a first-person shooter. Samus did not get another side-scroller until Metroid: Samus Returns on the 3DS in 2017. If you love Metroid, you want a GBA.

The DS library is the bigger one

New Super Mario Bros.
New Super Mario Bros..

The DS family sold 154 million consoles and the GBA family sold 81.51 million. New Super Mario Bros. sold nearly 31 million copies on the DS, and the GBA's best-seller, Pokémon Ruby and Sapphire, sold 16 million. With that many players, everyone wanted to make DS games.

Players rate the DS library as one of the best Nintendo ever had. GBA fans will tell you it was their favorite handheld and mean it, but on sheer depth the DS wins.

Mario Kart DS took the fight online

Mario Kart DS
Mario Kart DS.

The DS has Wi-Fi built in. Nintendo Wi-Fi Connection was a free online game service, and Mario Kart DS was the first Mario Kart you could play on it. The GBA had a Link Cable or a Wireless Adapter and whoever was sitting next to you. Nintendo has since shut the service down, so today both consoles are back to the people in the room.

The DS sounds better

Elite Beat Agents
Elite Beat Agents.

The GBA has one mono speaker. The DS has stereo speakers on either side of the upper display. Players still complain that GBA games sound tinny, even on headphones. Elite Beat Agents, a game built on music, would not have worked on the old console. The DS wins.

The GBA goes in your pocket and the first DS stays in your bag

Yoshi's Island: Super Mario Advance 3
Yoshi's Island: Super Mario Advance 3.

An original DS weighs 275 g and a GBA weighs 140 g, so you carry nearly twice the console. The DS Lite brings that down to 218 g, and at 133 mm wide it is the smaller of the three. An SP closes to 84 mm by 82 mm and beats everything else here for pockets.

The GBA runs up to 15 hours on 2 AA batteries, and the first DS lasts up to 10 hours. Hinges are the other problem. Parents remember kids breaking them on one DS after another, and a GBA has no hinge to break. Yoshi's Island doesn't care how rough your backpack is.

Cheap handhelds love the GBA and the DS still wants two screens

Golden Sun
Golden Sun.

The GBA screen is 240 by 160, a 3:2 shape, and players say many small emulation handhelds are a perfect fit for it. Golden Sun on one of those looks better than it ever did in 2001.

DS games ask for two screens and a touch panel. On one screen you get a stacked or sideways layout, and players find it awkward. If you want to play today, the GBA is the easy one, and a DS game is still best on a DS.

Both hold their value and the GBA has the top price

Pokémon Emerald Version
Pokémon Emerald Version.

Both are Nintendo handhelds, so neither is cheap. A loose Pokémon Emerald typically sells for $250 and a loose FireRed for $130. On the DS, HeartGold goes for $162 and Platinum for $130. The most expensive loose GBA game in our sold prices is Ninja Five-O at $322, and the DS tops out with Solatorobo: Red the Hunter at $200.

The GBA wins on resale, with a warning. Players say the market is full of fake GBA cartridges, Pokémon above all, so check before you pay.

Which one wins?

On paper the DS takes it. It has more power and nearly twice the sales, and it plays GBA games as well. None of that changes what you remember. If you tilted a GBA under every streetlight on the drive home to see Metroid Fusion, that console is yours. If you stayed up with a stylus and a puppy, so is that one. The hardware was only ever what you held while you made the memories.

Related articles