GameCube vs Xbox

GameCube vs Xbox

GameCube vs Xbox

Microsoft once looked at buying Nintendo, and Nintendo declined. So on September 24, 2002, Microsoft bought Rare for $375 million. Rare was the studio behind GoldenEye 007 and Banjo-Kazooie, Nintendo owned 49% of it, and the sale came after a bidding war that Nintendo lost.

The kids who grew up on Rare's games took it personally. One friend had a purple box with a handle and a copy of Melee. The other had a huge black box and Halo. Every sleepover ended in the same fight over GameCube vs Xbox.

The Xbox sold 24 million consoles to the GameCube's 21.74 million. Nintendo fans laugh at that number, since Microsoft lost over $4 billion to get it. In this article we will find out who really won.

The GameCube cost $100 less

Luigi's Mansion
Luigi's Mansion.

The two consoles came out in the same week. The Xbox went on sale on November 15, 2001, and the GameCube followed three days later. Parents all over America got to hear about both at once.

Nintendo wins this one on price. The GameCube launched at $199 and the Xbox at $299. Nintendo sold $100 million worth of GameCube products in North America on its launch weekend, and Microsoft sold 1.5 million Xboxes before the end of 2001, so both of them had a good Christmas. Then Nintendo kept cutting. By Christmas 2003, a price of just under $100 had quadrupled its American sales.

The Xbox was the strongest console of its generation

Tom Clancy's Splinter Cell
Tom Clancy's Splinter Cell.

Microsoft built the Xbox like a PC, and it shows on the spec sheet. It had a 733 MHz Intel Pentium III against the GameCube's 486 MHz Gekko, and 64 MB of main memory against 24 MB. Players still rank that generation the same way: the Xbox on top, the GameCube second and the PS2 a long way back.

Splinter Cell is a good game to put on if you want to see what the extra power bought. The Xbox wins this round, and Nintendo fans can take some comfort in second place.

Halo was the reason to buy an Xbox

Halo: Combat Evolved
Halo: Combat Evolved.

Halo started as a computer game. Microsoft bought Bungie in June 2000 and turned Halo into an Xbox exclusive for launch day. Edge called it "the most important launch game for any console, ever". It sold one million copies in about five months, faster than any earlier game on the PS2, Xbox or GameCube, and more than six million by November 2005.

Players say Halo sold the console by itself, and the GameCube had nothing like it. Key first-person shooters skipped the Nintendo console altogether. Reaching Halo's 16-player limit took a LAN party, which was a first for a console game. Players still talk about hauling a TV and an Xbox to a friend's house. Your back may not miss it, but Microsoft takes this round.

Melee made the GameCube the party console

Super Smash Bros. Melee
Super Smash Bros. Melee.

Both consoles have four controller ports, so this fight comes down to the games. Super Smash Bros. Melee is the best-selling GameCube game at 7.09 million copies, and Mario Kart: Double Dash came second at 6.88 million.

Melee also never left. Players still call it the fastest and deepest Smash, and it still gets tournaments long after the console left the shops. The Xbox had Halo for four people on a couch, which is a great night. The GameCube had two of the best party games ever made, and you could hand either one to your little sister. Nintendo wins.

Xbox Live left the GameCube offline

Halo 2
Halo 2.

Microsoft put an Ethernet port in every Xbox and launched Xbox Live on November 15, 2002. The starter kit came with a headset and a subscription. Xbox Live reached 1 million online users in July 2004, and Halo 2 made over $125 million on its first day. Players call it the first big step into online console gaming.

The GameCube needed an adapter you bought separately. The only internet games released for it in the West were three Phantasy Star games. Phantasy Star Online came to the Xbox too, and that version had voice chat. Players still bring up the missing online play when they talk about why the GameCube fell behind. This round goes to the Xbox and it isn't close.

The hard drive let you bring your own music

Project Gotham Racing
Project Gotham Racing.

The Xbox was the first console with a built-in hard drive, and it had 8 GB. You could rip your CDs to it, and some games would play those songs as a custom soundtrack.

GameCube owners got memory cards. The smallest one held 512 KB, or 59 blocks, and you could fill it with a single busy weekend of saves. The Xbox wins this one, and every car in Project Gotham Racing could have your album on the stereo.

Full-size DVDs beat the GameCube's mini discs

Burnout 3: Takedown
Burnout 3: Takedown.

A GameCube disc held up to 1.5 GB. The Xbox used DVDs that held up to 8.5 GB. Players have blamed those little discs for years, and most of them will tell you that a game on both consoles was usually better on the Xbox. Burnout 3: Takedown came out on the PS2 and Xbox, and fans say it runs best on the Xbox.

Grand Theft Auto skipped the GameCube as well. If you only wanted the newest big games, the Xbox was the safer buy.

The GameCube controller beat the Duke

Super Mario Sunshine
Super Mario Sunshine.

The first Xbox controller was an accident. The circuit boards had already been made when the design work began, and Sony's supplier refused to build a folded version, so it ended up nearly three times the size of Sony's pad. People called it the Fatty and later the Duke. Players still say it was too big for their hands. Microsoft replaced it in the box with the smaller Controller S.

Nintendo got it right the first time. Players call the GameCube pad one of the most comfortable ever made, and some call it the best controller of all time. The WaveBird made it wireless. Every Nintendo home console since has supported it, which is a long retirement party for one controller.

Nintendo's own games carried the GameCube

Metroid Prime
Metroid Prime.

Metroid Prime scored 97/100 on Metacritic and sold more than 2.8 million copies. Players still call it one of the best-looking games of its generation, and for some it is their favorite game of all time. Super Mario Sunshine sold 5.91 million copies and The Wind Waker sold 4.6 million.

Then there are the odd ones. Eternal Darkness faked errors on your TV and your GameCube when your sanity ran low, and players still rank that among the best fourth-wall tricks in any game. The Xbox had big hits of its own, with Halo 2 on top at 8.46 million. Nintendo still had the deeper shelf of games you can only play on its console, and that round goes to the GameCube.

Morrowind and Knights of the Old Republic went to the Xbox

Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic
Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic.

If you wanted a big western RPG on a console, you needed an Xbox. Morrowind reached it on June 7, 2002, and sold nearly a million units there by February 2006. The Xbox had so little memory for it that players say the game rebooted the whole console behind its loading screens.

Knights of the Old Republic came out on July 16, 2003, and sold 250,000 copies in four days, the fastest-selling Xbox game up to then. BioWare picked the Xbox because it could do what it wanted there with less effort than on the PS2 or GameCube. Xbox wins, reboots and all.

The GameCube never shook the kiddie label

The Legend of Zelda: The Wind Waker
The Legend of Zelda: The Wind Waker.

Players remember the GameCube's kiddie reputation, and the toy-like look of the console with its handle didn't help. Critics dubbed The Wind Waker "Celda" when Nintendo showed it. Meanwhile Grand Theft Auto and the big shooters that teenagers wanted were on the other consoles. In 2003, the Xbox was the one you wanted your friends to see under your TV.

Twenty years on, this round has flipped. Players say The Wind Waker still looks good and has aged better than its realistic rivals. The Xbox won at the time, and Nintendo won it back later.

Microsoft bought Rare and the magic stayed behind

Star Fox Adventures
Star Fox Adventures.

Star Fox Adventures was Rare's last Nintendo game before the sale. Its first Microsoft game was Grabbed by the Ghoulies in 2003, and Perfect Dark Zero and Kameo followed in 2005. Many fans and former employees have been critical of what Rare made under Microsoft. Nintendo lost the studio, and Retro Studios gave Nintendo Metroid Prime anyway. The GameCube side wins this one.

Nintendo made money and Microsoft lost billions

Pikmin
Pikmin.

Every Xbox cost $425 to make, so Microsoft lost about $125 on each one sold, and over $4 billion in all. The GameCube was profitable, and more profitable than the Xbox in the end. Nintendo also won Japan, where the Xbox sold poorly because of its large size and its American games. The GameCube sold 4.04 million there.

Microsoft can say the money bought it a seat at the table, and it did get an Xbox 360 out of it. As a business, though, this round goes to Nintendo.

A modded Xbox could do anything

Jet Set Radio Future
Jet Set Radio Future.

The same PC parts that cost Microsoft so much made the Xbox easy to hack. Players remember modding it, adding a large hard drive and loading their games from a menu, with XBMC playing their movies and music. Some of them still use one as an emulator box. The GameCube has nothing to match that, so tinkerers will take the Xbox.

The GameCube is the easier one to play today

Eternal Darkness
Eternal Darkness.

Most Wiis play GameCube discs and take GameCube controllers and memory cards, though the later Family Edition and Wii Mini dropped that. On a PC, players rate the Dolphin emulator very highly. Xbox emulation is a harder story, and players say it is still rough going.

The Xbox does have one answer. Some of its games, Knights of the Old Republic among them, run on newer Xbox consoles. It's a nice gesture, but the GameCube wins for anyone who just wants to play tonight. It also has a Game Boy Player, so one purple box runs your Game Boy Advance games on the TV too.

The GameCube wins on resale

Steel Battalion
Steel Battalion.

Nintendo wins on resale again. Players complain about how expensive GameCube games have become, and the sold prices back them up. A loose copy of Twilight Princess typically sells for $150 and Chibi-Robo for $145. The hits hold up too, with Mario Kart: Double Dash at $65, The Wind Waker at $60 and Melee at $50.

Xbox games are the bargain bin of the generation, and players are happy about it. Halo 2 is $7, Knights of the Old Republic is $9 and Fable is $6. The big exception is Steel Battalion, which goes for $332 with its giant controller and $73 without it. If you are starting a collection on a small budget, you know which black box to buy.

Which one wins?

On paper the Xbox takes it, with more consoles sold and a head start on online play. That doesn't change a thing if a GameCube was the box under your TV. It stays yours, and so does the Duke in the closet if you went the other way. What made either console special was never the spec sheet. It was the nights you spent with your friends in front of it, and GameCube owners get a small bonus: those nights are worth more on eBay.

Related articles