
In 1985 American shops wanted nothing to do with game consoles. The crash of 1983 had burned them, so Nintendo put a robot in the box. R.O.B. came with the Deluxe Set and helped the NES look like something new. Five years later Nintendo had the opposite problem. It took 1.5 million pre-orders for the Super Famicom, the Japanese SNES, the yakuza noticed, and the consoles were shipped at night to avoid robbery.
Plenty of kids grew up with both. The big brother kept his NES, the little sister asked for the new one at Christmas, and the two controllers on the living room floor started a family argument over NES vs SNES.
The NES sold 61.91 million consoles and the SNES sold 49.1 million. SNES fans wave that away, because the NES barely had a rival and the SNES had Sega. In this article we will find out who really won.
The NES saved console games

The NES wins this one, and the SNES can never take it back. Home video game revenue peaked at around $3.2 billion in 1983 and fell to around $100 million in 1985, a drop of almost 97%. That was the market the NES walked into.
By the end of 1986 it had sold over a million units in the United States, nearly ten times the amount sold by both its competitors. Nintendo used the 10NES lock-out chip to keep unlicensed games off the console, so shops could trust the shelf again.
Players still credit Nintendo with bringing console games back. A few will tell you computer games were doing fine the whole time, and they are right, but nobody's mom was buying a Commodore for Super Mario Bros.
The SNES won a real war against Sega

The NES never had a fight like this one. The Genesis had a two-year lead and a lower price, and it still held only an estimated 60% of the American 16-bit market in June 1992. Super Mario World came in the box with the SNES, and Nintendo landed the first console version of Street Fighter II, which took more than a year to reach the Genesis.
The SNES outsold the Genesis in the U.S. by 1.5 million units and finished as the best selling home console of its generation. That is the win NES fans can't claim. Their console beat Atari's leftovers. The SNES beat Sonic.
The SNES looks like a different planet

This is the easiest round in the article. The SNES was a 16-bit machine and the NES was 8-bit. The NES can show up to 25 colors at once out of 54. The SNES can show up to 256 from a palette of 32,768. Its CPU runs at 3.58 MHz against 1.79 MHz on the NES.
Then there is Mode 7, which lets a flat plane be rotated and scaled freely. F-Zero and Pilotwings both showed it off at launch, and no NES kid had seen a racetrack spin like that.
Players who go back say the gap has only grown. NES games look worse than they remember. SNES games look the way they remember, and their pixel art still works today.
Donkey Kong Country was paid for with NES money

The SNES kept getting better after people thought it was finished. The Super FX chip sat inside the cartridge and gave Star Fox its 3D polygons. Around 1992 Rare put its NES profit into Silicon Graphics workstations, and each one cost £80,000.
The result was Donkey Kong Country, with 3D models turned into SNES sprites. It sold 9.3 million copies and became the third-bestselling SNES game. So the NES paid for the best looking game on the console that replaced it, which is a very Nintendo way to save money.
The NES controller hurt and the SNES controller stuck around

The SNES wins by a mile. Players still complain about the square corners on the NES pad digging into their hands, and plenty call it uncomfortable after a long session. Nintendo seems to have agreed, because the late model NES came with a rounded dogbone controller.
The SNES pad added X and Y face buttons in a diamond and two shoulder buttons. Fighting games needed that. Players who made the move say it was a huge step up in comfort, and that the SNES pad aged much better than the old one. Your thumbs noticed before your eyes did.
The SNES was the RPG console

Dragon Quest and Final Fantasy both started on the NES, and that deserves respect. The fans who go back to those games say they are grindy and brutal, though, and that was normal for RPGs on that console.
The SNES is where the genre grew up. Players call it the king of RPGs and the golden age of the genre, and they will spend all night arguing Final Fantasy VI against Chrono Trigger. Chrono Trigger came on a 32-megabit cartridge with a battery for saved games, so you could stop for dinner and keep your party. EarthBound and Super Mario RPG are on the same console.
The NES wins if you like suffering

Players remember NES games as brutally difficult, and Ninja Gaiden still gets named as the toughest of the lot. Most games had no way to save. All-Stars, the SNES collection, offered saving that the original Mario games lack.
You stuck with these games anyway, because you got a new one on your birthday and it had to last. If you want a console that fights back, the NES wins. Battletoads has been waiting for you since the 90s, and it has not forgiven you.
SNES games aged better, apart from a few NES greats

Most players who have tried both say SNES games hold up better, and that a lot of the NES runs on nostalgia now. The kids who owned 200 NES carts will admit that a large part of the pile was garbage, and the games from LJN still get singled out.
The NES has a short list that nobody argues with. Mega Man 2 sold more than 1.51 million copies and remained the best selling Mega Man game until Mega Man 11. Mike Tyson's Punch-Out, Contra and Super Mario Bros. 3 get named again and again by the same people who say the rest of the console hasn't lasted.
The SNES also had the bigger shelf, with over 1,700 games, after Nintendo loosened its strict licensing rules to compete with Sega.
The SNES has the better sound chip and the NES has the tunes

On paper this is not close. The SNES has eight voices and 16-bit samples, on a sound chip designed by Ken Kutaragi and produced by Sony. That is the Sony that later built the PlayStation. Many players rate that chip above the Genesis, and Konami and Square got wonderful things out of it.
Fans still defend the NES. Composers had so little to work with that the music had to be built on melody, so NES tunes get stuck in your head for 30 years. The SNES wins on sound. Hum the Zelda theme in a room of NES kids and see who wins that.
Mario 3 or Super Mario World is a fight nobody wins

Super Mario Bros. 3 sold more than 17 million copies and is the third best-selling NES game. Super Mario World sold more than twenty million and is the best-selling SNES game, helped a lot by being in the box. Players split on this one, and some of them still prefer Mario 3 to the game that came after it.
The SNES found a sneaky way to settle it. Super Mario All-Stars came out in 1993 with the NES Mario games rebuilt in 16-bit, plus a save feature. Players who could never finish Mario 3 as kids finished it there, and many call it the best version. The SNES beat the NES with the NES's own games.
A Link to the Past and Super Metroid finished what the NES started

The NES came up with both ideas, and some fans will never leave the original Zelda. A Link to the Past sold 4.61 million copies on the SNES and gave you a better idea of where to go, which is why players say it holds up better.
Metroid is an easier call. Fans who grew up with the NES game admit it's hard to play now. Super Metroid is another story, and players call it decades ahead of its time and the best in the series. NES for the idea, SNES for the game you would hand a friend today.
The SNES fixed the blinking NES

Everyone who owned a front loader knows this ritual. The NES used a slot modeled after a videocassette recorder, and the lock-out chip added to its reliability problems. Kids blew into their carts, which sped up the tarnishing. Players will tell you the blowing did damage and they will tell you they would do it again.
Nintendo fixed it. The SNES was a top loader from the start, and the redesigned NES moved to the top with no lock-out chip. Those top loaders still work today, while the 72 pin connector in the old model is still a headache. The SNES wins, but it never gave you a reason to feel like a repairman in front of your friends.
The SNES couldn't play your NES games

A lot of people complained about this when the SNES came out. Your whole pile of carts stayed behind, and the new console cost US$199. If your parents had just paid for an NES, that was a hard sell.
Nintendo knew that, so it kept selling both. A new NES set came out in 1992 at US$89.99, and the console was not dropped until August 14, 1995. Round to the NES, which kept working for the families who stayed put.
The SNES was the better console to fight over

The NES had two players taking turns on Super Mario Bros. The SNES had two players trying to ruin each other. Super Mario Kart sold 8.76 million copies and became the fourth best-selling SNES game. Street Fighter II sold more than 6.3 million SNES cartridges, the highest for any third-party game on the console.
Ask anyone who played with a brother or sister and you will hear about Turtles in Time too. The SNES wins, and so does whoever got the good controller.
The SNES wins on resale at the top

Old Nintendo games hold their value, and players have been grumbling about the prices for years. Both consoles benefit. A loose cart of The Legend of Zelda typically sells for $32 and Mega Man 2 for $35. Those are better prices than Super Mario World at $18, which was in the box, so everyone already has one.
The SNES takes the top end. A Link to the Past goes for $40 and Super Metroid for $91. Chrono Trigger at $260 and EarthBound at $400 are silly money for the cartridge alone. The NES has one answer. Little Samson typically sells for $2,434, which is a lot of money for a game most kids never saw at the shop.
Which one wins?
The SNES takes most of the rounds in this article, and the NES takes the history books. It doesn't change a thing. The console in your house when you were small is yours for life, and no color count can argue with that. Nobody loves a machine for its sound chip. You love it for the rainy Saturdays and for the brother who unplugged your controller, and those memories were made on whichever one you had.





