Nintendo 3DS vs Nintendo DS

Nintendo 3DS vs Nintendo DS

Nintendo 3DS vs Nintendo DS

The 3DS went on sale in North America on March 27, 2011, for $249.99. Less than six months later, Nintendo cut the price to $169.99 after disappointing launch sales. To make it up to the people who had paid full price, Nintendo gave them 20 free classic games through the Ambassador Program.

Kids who had spent their birthday money on day one got ten free Game Boy Advance games, and their friends who waited got a cheaper 3DS. Half the school bus was still playing on a DS Lite, and that is where the fight over 3DS vs DS started.

The DS sold 154.02 million consoles. The 3DS sold 75.94 million, about half. Ask anyone who had a 3DS and they will tell you that number means nothing, because their console played the DS games too. In this article we will find out which one really wins.

The 3DS plays almost every DS game

Pokémon HeartGold
Pokémon HeartGold.

The 3DS is backward compatible with all DS and DSi software. Put Pokémon HeartGold in the slot and it boots like it always did. Players count this as the 3DS's biggest win: buy one console and you get two libraries.

That made the upgrade easy. You could sell your DS, keep every cartridge and still have a 3DS for Mario Kart 7, which became its best seller at 18.99 million copies.

The DS Lite still plays Game Boy Advance cartridges

Guitar Hero: On Tour
Guitar Hero: On Tour.

The original DS and the DS Lite have a second slot on the bottom for Game Boy Advance cartridges. The DSi dropped it, and the 3DS never had it. A few DS games also plugged extra hardware into that slot.

Guitar Hero: On Tour is the one fans always bring up: its fret grip went into the Game Boy Advance slot, so it won't work on a 3DS. Point to the DS.

DS games look blurry on a 3DS

Castlevania: Dawn of Sorrow
Castlevania: Dawn of Sorrow.

The 3DS screens have a different resolution, so DS games get scaled and stretched to fit. Pixel art like Castlevania: Dawn of Sorrow turns soft and smeary. Hold START or SELECT while you launch a DS game and it runs at its real size, sharp but smaller, with black borders around it.

That's why so many 3DS owners keep a DS Lite or a DSi XL in the drawer. For DS games, players say the old hardware still looks best.

The DS library is bigger and stranger

Elite Beat Agents
Elite Beat Agents.

The DS sold twice as many consoles, and its library is the one players remember as huge and a lot weirder. This was the console where Brain Age sat next to Elite Beat Agents in the same shop.

The 3DS had a slow start. Early owners spent the first year playing DS games on it while they waited for 3DS games worth buying. It did get there, but the DS had the head start and never gave it back.

Most players turned the 3D off

Super Mario 3D Land
Super Mario 3D Land.

The 3D screen was the whole point of the 3DS, and a lot of owners say they barely used it. The effect gave some players eye fatigue, and the console came with a warning that it should not be used by children under six. Nintendo later sold cheaper 2DS models with the 3D screen removed.

Super Mario 3D Land is the best reason to push the slider up. If you missed it, your 3DS was a very nice DS with a dial on the side.

The DS doesn't care where your games came from

Fire Emblem Awakening
Fire Emblem Awakening.

Every 3DS is region locked. A Japanese copy of Fire Emblem Awakening won't run on an American 3DS. The DS had no lock at all, except for the iQue DS. Import fans pick the DS every time.

The 3DS is easy to hack

Animal Crossing: New Leaf
Animal Crossing: New Leaf.

Players agree the 3DS is one of the easiest consoles to mod, and once it's done it runs emulators for older consoles and DS games from the SD card. This round goes to the 3DS.

The DS Lite battery lasts longer

Mario Kart 7
Mario Kart 7.

The original 3DS was known for a weak battery, especially with the 3D on and StreetPass running in sleep mode, and a DS Lite goes much longer between charges. Bring a charger to the sleepover.

Both hold their value

The 3DS eShop closed on March 27, 2023. After that, physical copies of many 3DS games went up in price, and some DS games had already gone up. These are Nintendo handhelds, and Nintendo games hold their value. Whichever one you own, don't throw out the cartridges.

Which one wins?

On paper the 3DS wins, since it plays both libraries. It doesn't matter. If the DS was the one in your backpack, it's still yours, and no spec sheet can change that. What made it special was the Pokémon trades on the playground and the nights under the covers with the screen turned down. Those memories are yours on either console.

Related articles