
On March 4, 2000, more than 10,000 people queued across Tokyo for the PlayStation 2, and some of them had started waiting four days earlier. All one million launch units sold out over the first weekend. Six years before, the first PlayStation had arrived in Japan to a relatively subdued launch.
Every kid with a gray PlayStation under the TV had the same talk with their parents that year. The new console cost a small fortune and the old one still had a shelf full of great games. Birthday lists were torn up over PS1 vs PS2.
The PS2 sold 160 million consoles to the PS1's 102.49 million. PS1 fans will tell you that number means nothing, because the PS1 did the hard part and the PS2 walked through the door it opened. In this article we will settle which one really won.
The PS1 made games grown up

Players who were there remember games being seen as something for kids until the PS1 changed that, and it brought adults back to consoles. The sales chart agrees. Its best seller was Gran Turismo, a car game with 10.85 million copies shipped.
The PS2 inherited that crowd and took most of the credit. This round belongs to the PS1, because it had to win those people over first.
The PS2 cost the same and came with a DVD player

Sony's Steve Race walked onto a conference stage, said "Two ninety-nine." and left, and that was the first PlayStation's price. The PS2 sold in North America for $299 too, and for that money you also got a DVD player.
At launch the PS2 was priced comparably to standalone DVD players, and in Japan the best-selling title of the launch period was a DVD of The Matrix. Players remember the DVD player being how the console got past their parents. The PS1 could play your music CDs. The PS2 played audio CDs and DVD films, and this round is the PS2's.
The jump from PS1 to PS2 was one of the biggest ever

The PS1 could draw 180,000 polygons per second. The PS2 has a real-world figure of 25 million polygons per second once lighting and textures are counted. The processor speed went from 33.8688 MHz to 294.912 MHz.
Players rank this among the largest leaps in console history, and some say nothing has matched it since. Characters stopped looking like folded paper. Put Metal Gear Solid next to its sequel and you will see why nobody argued about this one.
The PS1 wobble turned into a style

PS1 3D has a rough time today. Plenty of players say it has aged poorly, and they use ruder words than that. Those warping textures came from affine texture mapping, and they were a flaw at the time.
They are now iconic. Retro-styled games recreate them on purpose, and some players love the look, with indie horror games copying it to this day. The PS2 is better looking. The PS1 is the one people imitate, and we will give it the style points.
The PS2 played your whole PS1 shelf

The PS2 launched in Japan with eleven "underwhelming" titles and in North America with 29. That would have hurt any other console. This one is backward-compatible with almost all original PlayStation games, so a brand new machine had a huge library on day one.
Players call this one of the two big reasons the PS2 spread so far, next to the DVD player. You could sell a kid on an upgrade without asking them to give up Symphony of the Night. Your old memory cards came along as well, though they only work with PS1 games. Advantage PS2, and the PS1 helped it win.
The PS1 had the golden age of RPGs

Final Fantasy VII is credited with taking role-playing games to the mass market outside Japan, and the PS1 version had sold 9.8 million copies by the end of 2005. Final Fantasy VIII set a single-day sales record with 2.21 million copies.
Players still call those years the golden era of the genre. The PS2 had great RPGs too, with Persona among its top series, but the PS1 got there first and caught everyone by surprise. Most of us had never cried at a video game before. The PS1 takes this one.
Final Fantasy X finally got to talk

A CD held 650 MB and a DVD holds 4.7 GB, and the extra room changed how these games told stories. Final Fantasy X was the first in the series with voice acting and fully 3D areas. Its writer, Kazushige Nojima, said the voices let him express emotion more powerfully than before.
It shipped over 8.5 million units on PS2, close to what Final Fantasy VII managed. Cloud never said a word out loud. Tidus would not stop talking. Say what you like about that, the PS2 wins on room.
Grand Theft Auto III made the PS2 feel like the future

The first Grand Theft Auto came to the PS1 in December 1997, played from a top-down view. Grand Theft Auto III moved the series into a full 3D open world, became the best-selling game of 2001 and sold over 11.6 million copies on PS2.
Players remember that first drive as the moment the new generation arrived, and many say they could never go back to the old games. San Andreas went further and sold 17.33 million units, the best seller on the console. The PS1 had nothing like it. This is the easiest round in the article.
The PS2 had the wider library

The count is close to a tie, with more than 4,000 PlayStation games against over 4,000 on the PS2. The PS2 sold more of them, 1.54 billion against 962 million.
Players give the PS2 the crown for variety. God of War, Ratchet & Clank, Jak and Daxter, Sly Cooper, Katamari and Devil May Cry all started there, and you can't get a stranger mix than that. PS1 fans will still tell you theirs is the greatest library ever, and with Crash, Spyro and Tekken 3 on the shelf they have a case. It isn't enough. PS2 wins.
Silent Hill was born on the PS1 and peaked on the PS2

The fog in the first Silent Hill was a trick. Developers used distance fog and darkness to mitigate the limitations of the console hardware, and it gave the game its atmosphere. The worst part of the PS1 became the scariest part of the game.
The PS2 hardware allowed improved fog and shadow effects, and reviewers praised the claustrophobia of Silent Hill 2. The PS1 had the idea. The PS2 had the better version, and that's the one that gets this round.
The DualShock 2 is the same pad with smarter buttons

Sony kept what worked. The DualShock 2 maintained the overall layout and ergonomics of the original and turned it black. The big change was inside, with 255 levels of pressure on the face buttons, where the old pad only had digital input.
Players point to the Metal Gear games as the place this mattered, and an old PS1 pad will still plug into a PS2. A narrow win for the PS2 by the thickness of one button.
PS2 memory cards held more and you still ran out

A PS1 memory card held 128 KB. The standard PS2 card has 8 MB, and owners thought their troubles were over. They still ended up with a stack of cards, and for a while the cards were hard to find. Call it a draw. Both consoles taught a generation to delete things they loved.
The PS2 went online and most owners stayed off

Online play on the PS2 needed an adapter in the expansion bay at the back, and players remember it as an extra most people never bought. Of over 25 million PS2 units sold in North America, approximately 2.6 million were equipped for online play. Sony ran no subscription service, and you often needed a separate login for each game. It was a clumsy start, and it still gives the PS2 this round.
The PS1 runs on a cheap handheld and the PS2 doesn't

Playing today is where the PS1 gets its revenge. A little handheld for around $50 will run PS1 games well. Players say the demands jump a long way for PS2, one of the hardest consoles to emulate, and a device that handles most of its games costs more like $150.
If you want to pocket your whole childhood for the price of a pizza night, the PS1 is the one that lets you. PS1 wins.
Both consoles have a laser problem

Old PS1 owners all know the trick of turning the console upside down when it started failing to read. It sounds like a joke, and it worked. PS2 owners got the "disc read error" instead, because the drives on those wear out too. Buy either one today and you are buying an old laser. This round is a draw.
PS1 games hold more value, PS2 games save you money

Line up the famous games and the PS1 costs more. A loose Final Fantasy VII typically sells for $25 and Final Fantasy X for $7. Metal Gear Solid goes for $25 and San Andreas for $13. Symphony of the Night is $89, and Shadow of the Colossus is $10. Silent Hill is $150 and Silent Hill 2 is $100.
Players know how cheap the PS2's hits are, and that is the best thing about collecting for it. The top of the market flips, though. Kuon typically sells for $600 and Rule of Rose for $488, while the PS1's top game is The Misadventures of Tron Bonne at $235. Horror collectors on PS2 need a bigger wallet. Everyone else will find their money goes further there.
Which one wins?
On paper the PS2 wins, with more consoles, more games sold and almost thirteen years of production. None of that settles it. If a gray PS1 is the console you grew up with, it is yours for good, wobbly textures and all. You never kept it around for the polygon count. You kept it for the memories you made on the floor in front of it.





