PS2 Fat vs PS2 Slim

PS2 Fat vs PS2 Slim

PS2 Fat vs PS2 Slim

The PS2 Slim's launch in Britain was held up by a Russian oil tanker. It got stuck in the Suez Canal and blocked a ship from China carrying PS2s to the Port of Felixstowe. British sales fell to 6,000 units in one week of November 2004, down from 70,000 a few weeks earlier. Sony hired Russian cargo planes to fly consoles in twice a week.

Anyone who got a Slim that Christmas couldn't believe how small it was. Anyone who already owned the big black box said theirs was the real one, and every group of friends had the PS2 Fat vs PS2 Slim argument.

The Fat weighs 2.2 kg and the Slim weighs 0.9 kg, with online play built in. Ask a Fat owner and they will tell you that number means nothing, because a Slim has nowhere to put a hard drive. In this article we will find out which one you should buy.

Buy a Fat for a hard drive and a Slim for everything else

Final Fantasy X
Final Fantasy X.

Both consoles play Final Fantasy X and the rest of the library, and both play DVDs and audio CDs. The big difference is the expansion bay on the back of the Fat.

Buy a Fat if you want your games on a hard drive. Players point to the SCPH-5000x, one of the last Fat models, as the one to look for. Buy a Slim if you want to drop a disc in and play on a small console.

Only the Fat has room for a hard drive

Final Fantasy XI Online
Final Fantasy XI Online.

The Fat's expansion bay has space for a 3.5" hard drive and a connector for the Network Adaptor. Sony's own drive held 40 GB. The Slim is too thin for the bay, so it can't run games that need the drive, and Final Fantasy XI is the famous one. The drive did more than that. Resident Evil Outbreak installs 1 GB to it for shorter loading.

Fans found a better use for it. Open PS2 Loader copies whole games to the drive and runs them with no disc. Players who did this say the loading got much shorter, and many say the hard drive alone makes the Fat the better buy.

A Slim owner has to use USB, and players say the PS2's USB ports are too slow for a lot of games.

The Slim has online built in

SOCOM II: U.S. Navy SEALs
SOCOM II: U.S. Navy SEALs.

If you wanted SOCOM II online on a Fat, you had to buy a Network Adaptor. The Slim has an Ethernet port on the back, and some early North American models added a dial-up modem. Reviewers praised it for that.

That port is still useful. Slim owners keep their games on a PC and send them to the console over a network cable. The Fat can do the same, but only after you buy the adaptor. Point to the Slim.

The Slim is tiny

Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas
Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas.

The Slim launched at $149 in 2004, the year San Andreas came out. The Fat had launched at $299. The Fat weighs 2.2 kg. The first Slims weighed 0.9 kg, and the SCPH-7900x got that down to 600 grams.

Players still call the Slim tiny, and it fits in a bag. One owner's brother slipped a replacement Slim into the back pocket of his baggy jeans. Reviewers liked the size as well. If you want it standing up, buy the stand, because it needs one to stay stable.

The Slim is quieter

Silent Hill 2
Silent Hill 2.

Sony's redesign came out smaller, thinner and quieter than the Fat. Players agree. On an early Fat, Silent Hill 2 comes with one extra monster in the room.

The Fat is safer for PS1 games

Metal Gear Solid
Metal Gear Solid.

Every PS2 is backward compatible with almost all PS1 games, and Sony built the first models around a PS1 chip to do it. The Fat and the first Slim, the SCPH-700xx, still have that chip. From the SCPH-7500x on, Sony replaced it with a new PowerPC part, and some PS1 games and some PS2 games stopped working properly. Later models fixed part of this, and Metal Gear Solid: VR Missions runs on most silver Slims.

Players who care about PS1 games say the original models and the first Slims are the best ones to get.

Early Slims can scratch your discs

Gran Turismo 4
Gran Turismo 4.

The Slim swapped the motorized tray for a top-loading lid. Players say the laser's ribbon cable can come loose on Slims and leave circular scratches on your discs. If a used Gran Turismo 4 has a neat ring cut into it, this is probably why.

Check the model number before you buy. Players say the SCPH-7900x is the Slim that doesn't do it.

Both of them have laser trouble

Dragon Quest VIII: Journey of the Cursed King
Dragon Quest VIII: Journey of the Cursed King.

This fight has no winner. Plenty of players say the old Fats stop reading discs, and plenty say Slim lasers fail sooner.

Try cleaning the lens with a cotton swab and isopropyl alcohol first. Players say that often brings a tired console back. Then test a disc before you pay, because no one wants to find this out 60 hours into Dragon Quest VIII.

The Fat keeps its power supply inside

Burnout 3: Takedown
Burnout 3: Takedown.

The Fat has its power supply inside and the Slim uses an external brick, like a GameCube. That brick had a bad start. Some made between August and December 2004 were defective and could overheat, so Sony recalled them. Reviewers also said the Slim overheats easily. Sony put the power supply back inside on the SCPH-9000x, the last model.

If you find a very early Slim, buy a new power brick for it before you sit down with Burnout 3.

Fat accessories don't always fit a Slim

TimeSplitters 2
TimeSplitters 2.

You need a Multitap for four players in TimeSplitters 2, and Sony made a different one for each shape of console: the SCPH-10090 for the Fat and the SCPH-70120 for the Slim. The vertical stands are different too.

The i.LINK port, which could link consoles together, stopped at the SCPH-3900x, so the later Fats and every Slim don't have it. The early Fats do lose one point here. They need a receiver in a controller port for the DVD remote, while the SCPH-5000x and every Slim have one built in.

The Fat is the better looking console

Devil May Cry
Devil May Cry.

The standard PS2 is matte black, and the big version looks like a small office tower. Players call it peak Sony design, and the ones who grew up with it still want one because it looks cool. Put it next to a CRT with Devil May Cry running and it fits right in. Point to the Fat.

Which one wins?

The spec sheet gives it to the Slim, which is smaller and quieter and came online out of the box. None of that counts for much. If the big black box sat under your TV first, that box is your PS2 and a smaller one will always feel like a copy. The kid who unwrapped a Slim feels the same way about theirs. You don't remember what it weighed. You remember the long weekends in San Andreas, and those stay yours on either model.

Related articles