
Four months after the PS3 came out, Sony put its next God of War on the old console. God of War II arrived on the PS2 on March 13, 2007, and sold 833,209 copies in North America by the end of the month, twice as many as the next best seller. IGN and GameSpot called it the swan song of the PS2 era, but the PS2 was still the best-selling console in 2008, ahead of the PS3.
Anyone with a PS2 and a shelf full of games had the same problem that year. The new console was shiny and expensive, and the old one was where the good games still came out. Every PlayStation family had the same fight over PS2 vs PS3.
The PS2 sold 160 million consoles to the PS3's 87.4 million, close to two to one. Ask anyone who played Uncharted 2 when it was new and they will tell you that number means nothing. In this article we will find out which one really won.
The PS2 was the one your parents could afford

The PS2 cost $299 when it started out in the United States. Sony cut that to $199 in 2002, and the Slimline followed in 2004 at $149. By then a PS2 was an easy Christmas present, and that October it got Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas, the best-selling game on the console at 17.33 million copies.
The PS3 launched at $499 for the 20 GB model and $599.99 for the 60 GB model, and Sony still sold it at a loss. The division lost ¥232 billion, about $1.91 billion, in the year after launch. Players still bring up that price tag as the moment Sony botched the launch. The PS2 takes this round without trying.
The PS3 launched with half as many games

The PS2 launched in North America with 29 games. The PS3 launched there with 14, and Resistance: Fall of Man was the top seller. It was a good shooter, and it had to carry a $599.99 console by itself.
For the first couple of years, the running joke was that the PS3 had no games. Early owners remember a thin shelf, and plenty of PS2 owners waited until the games they wanted turned up. PS2 again.
The PS2 refused to retire

Sony did not stop making the PS2 until January 4, 2013, more than six years after the PS3 arrived. Players remember it hanging around for ages and still selling well while the PS3 found its feet.
The games kept coming too. Persona 4 reached North America on December 9, 2008, on the PS2, two years into the PS3's life. FIFA 14 was the last PS2 game in North America, and Pro Evolution Soccer 2014 closed things out in the United Kingdom on November 8, 2013. Grand Theft Auto V had been out on the PS3 since that September. It is hard to sell a new console when the old one keeps getting Persona.
HD made the PS3 the bigger jump

The PS3 was the first console with an HDMI port and the first that could output games in 1080p. Players still call the step from PS2 to PS3 huge, and some call it the last really big jump consoles ever made.
It took a while to show. Early PS3 games looked a lot like late PS2 games with a cleaner picture, and owners of a $599.99 console noticed. By 2013 Rockstar knew the hardware well enough to push its graphics further than in its earlier games, and Grand Theft Auto V made $1 billion in three days. The PS2 has nothing to answer that with. The PS3 wins this round.
The PS2's DVD player mattered more than the PS3's Blu-ray

Shuhei Yoshida remembers that the best-selling title of the PS2's launch period in Japan was a DVD of The Matrix. Standalone players were still expensive, and players remember the PS2 as one of the cheapest DVD players you could buy. Plenty of them say that is why it ended up under so many TVs.
The PS3 tried the same trick and it mostly worked. It helped Blu-ray beat HD DVD, Toshiba gave up on February 19, 2008, and games got a lot more room. Metal Gear Solid 4 used a 50 GB disc. Players say the jump from DVD to Blu-ray just didn't feel as big, though, and streaming arrived soon after. Sony won a format war with the PS3, and the PS2 still takes this one.
The first PS3s played PS2 games and Sony took that away

The first PS3s had the PS2's Emotion Engine chip on the motherboard, so your old discs just worked. Sony even made a memory card adaptor for copying your PS2 saves across. Then the European 60 GB model dropped that chip for software emulation. The 40 GB model that followed lost the Graphics Synthesizer as well, and with it any way to play PS2 discs at all.
Players say it came down to money, and the numbers back them up. Phasing out the Emotion Engine helped cut what a PS3 cost to make. PS2 Classics on the PlayStation Store gave every PS3 a selection of old games, which meant paying again for ones you already owned. If your launch PS3 still runs, you win this round. Everyone else kept the PS2 plugged in.
The PS3 got the PS2's best games in HD

Sony found a way to sell you those games again. God of War and God of War II came to the PS3 in November 2009 as God of War Collection, which sold more than 2.4 million copies by June 2012. Ico and Shadow of the Colossus followed together in September 2011.
Players say the PS3 ended up with most of what made the PS2 great, often in cheap collections. Add in the PS2 Classics and the old console's strongest argument gets weaker. PS3 owners get this one, and they get it in a sharper picture.
The PS2 had the bigger and stranger library

The PS2 had over 4,000 games and sold 1.54 billion copies of them. What players miss is the middle of that pile. They remember quirky mid-budget games and a huge shelf of niche stuff. Katamari Damacy cost less than $1 million to make and sold for about two-thirds of the price of a new game. You rolled a sticky ball around until it picked up cows. Nobody needed a focus group for that.
The PS3 has a great library of its own, but this fight goes to the PS2.
The PS2 was the RPG console and the PS3 ran dry

Final Fantasy X brought voice acting to the series on the PS2, and the console went on to get Final Fantasy XII and Persona 4 too. Players call the PS2 years a golden era for Japanese RPGs, and they are much harder on the PS3.
Final Fantasy XIII was the PS3's big one. It sold 1.7 million copies in Japan in 2009, and its linear design split critics. Demon's Souls came out of nowhere that same year and sold only 134,585 copies in Japan by December, and Atlus took a chance on it for North America. It is a great game. It doesn't make up for the rest of the gap, so the PS2 takes this round easily.
The PS3's best games were worth the wait

Ars Technica gave the PS3 a 6/10 at launch and a 9/10 in June 2008. That second score came just as Metal Gear Solid 4 arrived on June 12, 2008, and players who sat through the early years say that is about when the console clicked.
Then it kept going. Uncharted 2 scored 96 on Metacritic with 41 perfect reviews, and it sold more than six million copies. The Last of Us came out on June 14, 2013, sold 3.4 million copies in three weeks and is now counted among the greatest games ever made. No PS2 game looks like that. For big single player stories, the PS3 wins.
The PS3 was far easier to play online

Online on the PS2 was a mess. Sony left it to each game's publisher, so you often needed a separate login for every game. It worked, and that was about all.
The PlayStation Network was free and came with the console. Players still name free online as one of the best things about the PS3. Uncharted 2 owners got a new multiplayer map for nothing in November 2009. Sony did shut the whole network down on April 20, 2011, after an attack, which is the sort of outage a PS2 owner never had to think about. The PS3 still wins this round.
The PS2 never made you wait for an update

Put a disc in a PS2 and you were playing. Players remember the PS3 as the console where that stopped. You plugged it in, waited for a system update, waited for a game update and then hoped there was time left to play.
The installs were worse. Metal Gear Solid 4 had installs between acts until a patch let you put the whole game on the hard drive. Owners from that time still talk about how long they took. A round for the PS2.
The PS3 pad cut the wire and lost the rumble

Sony showed a boomerang-shaped controller for the PS3 at E3 in 2005, then went back to something close to the old pad. The Sixaxis was wireless, charged over USB and had no rumble. That was a strange thing to take away from the company that made the DualShock, and it came after a long patent fight with Immersion that Sony settled in March 2007. The PS3 reached Europe that same month with MotorStorm on the shelf and a pad that didn't shake.
The DualShock 3 fixed it in late 2007. It kept the pressure-sensitive buttons of the DualShock 2 and lost the cable. Once it arrived the PS3 had the better pad.
The fat PS3 is the one that breaks

A BBC program called Watchdog ran a report on the "yellow light of death" in September 2009. Sony said only about 0.5% of consoles came back with those symptoms. Ask players about buying an old fat PS3 today and they tell you to stay away from it, or to save money for the repair. Nothing ends a run of Drake's Fortune quite like a yellow light.
PS2s die too, and plenty of owners have the story. A dead PS2 is a smaller problem, because players say they are so cheap second-hand that you can just buy another. The PS2 wins on being easy to replace.
The PS3 is the better one to own today

Players who want old PlayStation games on one box point at the PS3. It plays PS1 discs and its own library, and custom firmware adds PS2 games. Players recommend custom firmware for exactly this.
Emulation goes the other way. PS2 games run well on cheap handhelds now, and PS3 emulation still needs a strong machine. If you want Demon's Souls as it was, an old PS3 is still your best bet. The PS3 takes this round, as long as the light stays green.
The PS2 wins on resale

Rare PS2 horror games sell for silly money. A loose copy of Kuon typically sells for $600, Rule of Rose for $488 and Haunting Ground for $419. The PS3's collectibles sit far lower, with BlazBlue: Central Fiction at $105 and 3D Dot Game Heroes at $85.
The famous games are the bargain on both sides. Final Fantasy X goes for $7, Final Fantasy XII for $6 and Shadow of the Colossus for $10. Demon's Souls is $19 and Metal Gear Solid 4 is $10. Players say PS3 games are the cheaper shelf to fill, but the big names are cheap on both consoles. Persona 4 at $25 is about as high as they go. For the games worth real money, the PS2 wins.
Which one wins?
On paper the PS2 takes it, with nearly twice the consoles sold and over 4,000 games. None of that settles anything. If you stayed up all night on a PS3 with Uncharted 2, that console is yours and no sales chart gets a vote. What made either one special was the memories you made with it.





