PS2 vs Wii

PS2 vs Wii

PS2 vs Wii

By October 2002 the PS2 had sold 40 million consoles, and Nintendo needed a new plan. The next year its president, Satoru Iwata, sat down with Shigeru Miyamoto and Genyo Takeda and told Takeda to "go off the tech roadmap". The next console had to be easy for people who didn't play games, and Iwata named mothers in particular. Nintendo had even pictured selling it for around $100.

Three years later that console went on sale next to the PS2. The Wii reached North America on November 19, 2006, and Sony kept making the PS2 until January 4, 2013. Teenagers had their stack of PS2 games, Mom suddenly had a Wii, and every house with one TV ended up arguing over PS2 vs Wii.

The PS2 sold 160 million consoles and the Wii sold over 101 million. Wii fans will tell you that number means little, because Wii Sports reached 82.90 million copies with the pack-ins counted and the best-selling PS2 game stopped at 17.33 million. In this article we will find out who really won.

The PS2 had the bigger shelf

Shadow of the Colossus
Shadow of the Colossus.

The PS2 got over 4,000 games and sold 1.54 billion copies of them. God of War, Kingdom Hearts, Devil May Cry, Katamari and Ratchet & Clank all started there. Shadow of the Colossus is on that shelf too.

Ask which console of that era had the best library and players point at the PS2. The Wii sold 921.85 million games by June 30, 2022, a huge number that leans hard on Mario and bowling. If you want to pick up a console and try something different every week for a year, this round belongs to Sony.

The Wii filled up with shovelware

Wii Play
Wii Play.

Wii Play sold 28.02 million copies, and the cheap minigame collections came running after it. Players remember the rest as well. They call the Wii a shelf of shovelware and say the PS2 had the better ratio of good games to bad ones.

The third-party story was worse. Players say big outside support never really showed up, and major publishers were passing over the Wii by 2011 because it was underpowered and used non-standard development tools. The PS2 had its own junk, since a console with 160 million owners attracts it, but it also had a real game from almost every big studio in the world. The Wii loses this one.

Wii Sports got your grandma playing

Wii Sports
Wii Sports.

Iwata's plan worked. Wii Sports and Wii Fit are credited with bringing in more casual, female and elderly players. Retirement homes formed their own Wii Sports bowling leagues, and Wii Fit alone sold 22.67 million copies. Players who were there agree that the Wii sold to people who didn't normally play games.

Many of those buyers stopped after a game or two, and fans of the PS2 love to bring that up. It doesn't change the result. Nobody's grandmother ever asked to have a turn at Devil May Cry. The Wii takes this round with ease.

Grand Theft Auto made the PS2 the teenager's console

Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas
Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas.

Sony had the games you hid from your parents. By 2001 the PS2 had a commanding lead thanks to Grand Theft Auto III and Metal Gear Solid 2, and San Andreas sold those 17.33 million copies by itself.

The Wii never got a Grand Theft Auto. It had MadWorld and No More Heroes, and both are good fun, but the console's whole look said family room. The PS2 wins this one, and it was never close.

The PS2 was the home of Japanese RPGs

Final Fantasy X
Final Fantasy X.

Final Fantasy X was a PS2 exclusive and shipped over 8.5 million copies on the console. RPG fans call the PS2 years a golden era, and plenty will tell you no console ever did the genre better.

Wii owners had to fight for theirs. In 2011 fans started a campaign called Operation Rainfall to get Xenoblade Chronicles, The Last Story and Pandora's Tower released. Xenoblade's North American release stayed unconfirmed until December 2011 and it finally arrived on April 6, 2012. All three are worth playing. PS2 owners just never had to write letters to get them.

Super Mario Galaxy is the Wii's trump card

Super Mario Galaxy
Super Mario Galaxy.

Super Mario Galaxy holds a Metacritic score of 97 and sold 12.80 million copies. Players still call the two Galaxy games some of the best 3D platformers ever made.

The PS2 has an answer in Shadow of the Colossus and Metal Gear Solid 3. But when a Wii owner needs one game to end the argument, Mario running around a tiny planet upside down does the job. Sony never had a platformer mascot who could touch it.

The Wii was stronger, and most games didn't show it

Super Mario Galaxy 2
Super Mario Galaxy 2.

The Wii came six years later and the numbers show it. Its processor runs at 729 MHz against 294.912 MHz for the PS2's Emotion Engine, and it has 88 MB of memory against 32 MB. That still made it the least powerful of the major home consoles of its generation, and players call it an overclocked GameCube.

Both consoles top out around the same picture on most games. The Wii stopped at 480p. The PS2 outputs from 480i to 480p, and a few games like Gran Turismo 4 go up to 1080i. Super Mario Galaxy 2 looks far better than anything Sony's old box could do. Outside Nintendo's own studios, the gap was hard to see. The Wii wins on paper by less than you would think.

Sony got you waving first and Nintendo made it stick

Wii Fit
Wii Fit.

The EyeToy, a camera for the PS2, came out in Europe on July 4, 2003 and in North America on November 4. It sold 10.5 million units and had people jumping around in front of their TVs three years before the Wii. Nintendo was already on the same path, having started work with the motion company Gyration on September 24, 2001.

The Wii Remote put all that in your hand and in the box, and the Balance Board that came with Wii Fit sold 42 million units. Players got tired of it fast, though, and many call the motion controls a gimmick. In 2009 Nintendo released the Classic Controller Pro, which was modelled after the GameCube and PlayStation 2 controllers. Nintendo gets this round for the idea. Sony gets a nice little win for the pad.

Resident Evil 4 and Okami got better on the Wii

Resident Evil 4: Wii Edition
Resident Evil 4: Wii Edition.

The Wii's best argument is that it could take games PS2 owners loved and improve them. Resident Evil 4: Wii Edition reached North America on June 19, 2007, and you aim by pointing the Remote at the screen. It also includes the extra content from the PS2 and PC versions. Players say the Wii version has the better graphics too.

Okami came out on the PS2 on September 19, 2006 and on the Wii on April 15, 2008. The game has you painting on the screen, so the Remote was an obvious fit, even though the motion control scheme received mixed reviews. The North American box has an IGN watermark by the wolf's mouth, which is the sort of thing that happens when a publisher grabs its cover art from a website. Players who owned these games on PS2 often say they liked the Wii versions more. PS2 owners had these games first and the Wii wins with them, which has to sting.

The PS2 was also your DVD player

Metal Gear Solid 3: Snake Eater
Metal Gear Solid 3: Snake Eater.

At launch the PS2 cost about the same as a standalone DVD player, and the best-selling title in Japan during the launch period was a DVD of The Matrix. Players remember people buying it just for that. It could play a film on Friday night and Metal Gear Solid 3 on Saturday morning.

The Wii came along six years later and does not support DVDs or CDs. Nintendo planned to add DVD playback in a later revision, then demand for the console pushed the idea back until it lost interest. Nintendo also said most people already owned something that could play a DVD. By 2006 that was true, and a lot of those somethings were PS2s.

Four Wii Remotes beat the multitap

Mario Kart Wii
Mario Kart Wii.

Up to four Wii Remotes could connect wirelessly to a Wii. The PS2 has two controller ports, and owners had to go out and buy a multitap to get four players in. Mario Kart Wii sold 37.38 million copies, and players still keep a Wii around for party games with friends.

The PS2 has one big party answer. Guitar Hero came out on November 8, 2005 for the PS2, on a budget of about one million dollars, and it filled a lot of living rooms with plastic guitars. It's a great memory. It still needed a trip to the shop for extra gear, and the Wii only needed three more Remotes, so Nintendo wins.

The Wii came online out of the box

Super Smash Bros. Brawl
Super Smash Bros. Brawl.

The Wii was Nintendo's first console with native Internet connectivity. Sony left PS2 online play to publishers, so you often needed a separate login for each game, and early models needed a network adaptor you bought separately. In early 2004 only about 2.6 million of the 25 million PS2s in North America were equipped for online play.

The Wii wins this round on the day, and nobody should get too excited about it now. Nintendo shut the service down on May 20, 2014, and Super Smash Bros. Brawl lost its online mode with it.

A modded Wii reaches further back than a modded PS2

The Legend of Zelda: Twilight Princess
The Legend of Zelda: Twilight Princess.

Both consoles respect your old games. The PS2 plays almost all original PlayStation games, and plenty of families chose it for that alone. The first Wii models play GameCube discs.

The modders took it further, and a Zelda game opened the door. In 2008 a hacking team released the Twilight Hack, which uses a malformed save file in the Wii version of Twilight Princess to run outside code. Players say a modded Wii is easy to set up and plays everything from the NES onward on one console. The PS2 has its own trick with FreeMcBoot, a softmod that lives on a memory card, and players love running their games from a hard drive with it. The PS2 stops at the PS2, though. The Wii wins here.

Wii hits hold their value and PS2 rarities cost a fortune

Rhythm Heaven Fever
Rhythm Heaven Fever.

Nintendo games hold their value and the big Wii games show it. A loose Mario Kart Wii typically sells for $29, and so does Wii Sports, the disc that came free in the box. Rhythm Heaven Fever sells for $113. The biggest PS2 games are cheap by comparison, with Final Fantasy X at $7 and San Andreas at $13.

The top of the PS2 market is a different story. Kuon sells for about $600 and Rule of Rose for about $488. Silent Hill: Shattered Memories came out on the Wii first, in December 2009, and reached the PS2 in January 2010. The Wii copy is $80 and the PS2 copy is $290. If you are buying games you have heard of, the PS2 saves you money and the Wii holds its price better. The Wii wins on resale for most people. A PS2 owner with Kuon in the closet wins bigger.

Which one wins?

On paper the PS2 takes it, with the bigger sales number and the bigger shelf. It doesn't matter. If your grandmother beat you at Wii tennis on Christmas Day, no sales chart can take that away. The same goes if you stayed up with San Andreas until your parents came downstairs. What you remember is who was on the sofa next to you, and that is what made your console yours.

Related articles