PS2 vs Xbox

PS2 vs Xbox

PS2 vs Xbox

Sony told the world the PlayStation 2 would one day replace the computer in your home. Bill Gates saw that as a threat to Windows. Microsoft tried to buy its way into games, going after Nintendo, Electronic Arts, Square Enix and Midway, and got none of them. It built its own console out of PC parts instead and called it the Xbox.

One kid had Halo in the basement. The other had Grand Theft Auto and a stack of RPGs. Every sleepover ended in the same fight over PS2 vs Xbox.

The PS2 sold 160 million consoles to the Xbox's 24 million. Xbox fans will tell you that only counts boxes, and the better versions of the games were on theirs. In this article we will find out who really won.

The PS2 was on shelves a full year before the Xbox

Metal Gear Solid 2: Sons of Liberty
Metal Gear Solid 2: Sons of Liberty.

The PS2 wins the race to the store. It reached North America on October 26, 2000 with 29 games, even though Sony had to cut its first US shipment from one million consoles to about 500,000. The Xbox followed on November 15, 2001. Both cost $299.

Sony shipped 10 million PS2s in under 15 months, and by 2001 it had a commanding lead thanks to Grand Theft Auto III and Metal Gear Solid 2.

The Xbox launch was still a hit, with 1.5 million sold before the end of 2001. Each one cost $425 to make, so Microsoft lost about $125 on every console.

The PS2 was also your DVD player

Gran Turismo 3: A-Spec
Gran Turismo 3: A-Spec.

The PS2 wins the living room. At launch it was priced about the same as a standalone DVD player, and the best-selling title in Japan during the launch period was a DVD of The Matrix.

Players still name the DVD drive as a big reason the PS2 won. The Xbox played movies too, but only after you bought a separate remote kit.

The PS2 also played almost all original PlayStation games. Plenty of families chose it for that alone, because the old PS1 collection came along for free.

The Xbox had the most powerful hardware

Tom Clancy's Splinter Cell
Tom Clancy's Splinter Cell.

The Xbox wins on power, and it isn't close. It had a 733 MHz Pentium III, Nvidia graphics and 64 MB of memory, where the PS2 had 32 MB. Players rate the PS2 as the weakest console of that generation.

You could see it in the games both consoles shared. Xbox versions of cross-platform games sometimes had extra features or better graphics, and players who owned both bought the Xbox copy.

The PS2 had more good games than anyone could finish

Shadow of the Colossus
Shadow of the Colossus.

The PS2 wins the library. It had over 4,000 games and sold 1.54 billion copies of them. God of War, Kingdom Hearts, Devil May Cry, Katamari and Ratchet & Clank all started there.

Ask players what the PS2 had that the Xbox didn't and they will point at the sheer size of that library. Their case against the Xbox is that past Halo, Ninja Gaiden and a few others, the list runs out fast.

Halo was the reason to buy an Xbox

Halo: Combat Evolved
Halo: Combat Evolved.

The Xbox wins the shooter fight. Halo: Combat Evolved was a launch game, and in the two months after release it sold alongside more than 50% of Xbox consoles. One million copies were gone roughly five months after release.

Plenty of players bought the console for that one game. Fans also credit Halo with making two sticks the standard way to play a shooter on a console.

Halo 2 made over $125 million on its first day. It went on to sell more than 8 million copies, the most of any Xbox game.

Xbox Live left the PS2 behind online

Halo 2
Halo 2.

The Xbox wins online. Xbox Live launched on November 15, 2002, on a console with an Ethernet port built in. It signed up 100,000 people in its first week and reached one million subscribers in July 2004.

PS2 owners had to screw a network adaptor into the back of the console. Sony ran no service of its own, so each publisher ran its own servers and you often needed a separate login for each game. In early 2004 only about 2.6 million of the 25 million PS2s in North America were equipped for online play.

Players who tried both call Xbox Live the far better service. The PS2 had two points in its favor: Sony charged no subscription, and it worked on dial-up while the Xbox needed broadband.

The PS2 was the home of Japanese RPGs

Final Fantasy X
Final Fantasy X.

The PS2 wins this one by a mile. Final Fantasy X was a PS2 exclusive and shipped over 8.5 million copies on the console. RPG fans from that era remember the Xbox having very few of the games they wanted.

Japan never came around. Microsoft hoped to ship six million consoles there by June 2002 and sold 474,992 in the Xbox's whole life. In one week of July 2004 it sold 272 units, fewer than the PSOne sold that same week. A ten-year-old PlayStation design outselling your brand new console has to sting. Microsoft's console was a big black box in a country that wanted compact designs, and it had hardly any Japanese games.

The Xbox got the western RPGs

Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic
Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic.

The Xbox wins here. Microsoft talked Bethesda into making The Elder Scrolls III: Morrowind a console exclusive, and Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic and Fable followed. Players with only a PS2 remember the jealousy.

Sony locked up Grand Theft Auto

Grand Theft Auto III
Grand Theft Auto III.

The PS2 wins the biggest game of the era. Sony secured Grand Theft Auto as a temporary exclusive. San Andreas became the best-selling PS2 game with 17.33 million copies. Take-Two's deal with Sony was later amended and the games came to the Xbox.

The Xbox hard drive let you bring your own music

Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas
Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas.

The Xbox wins this one easily. It was the first console with a built-in hard drive, 8 GB of it, and you could rip your CDs straight onto it. PS2 owners were still buying 8 MB memory cards.

If you hated a game's soundtrack, you swapped in your own albums. It worked in San Andreas and in plenty of other games, and PS2 owners had to sit through the radio.

The PS2 won the controller fight, until the Controller S

Project Gotham Racing
Project Gotham Racing.

The PS2 wins round one. The first Xbox controller was nearly three times the size of Sony's, because Mitsumi refused to make Microsoft the same folded circuit board it made for the DualShock 2. It won Game Informer's "Blunder of the Year" in 2001 and later a Guinness World Record as the biggest controller. Fans named it the Duke.

By 2002 the smaller Controller S had replaced it in the box. Players with big hands never hated the Duke as much as everyone else did, and some still say the Xbox pad felt better than the cramped PS2 one.

Hackers turned the Xbox into a media center

Jet Set Radio Future
Jet Set Radio Future.

The Xbox wins with the modders. It was a PC in a black box, and its security was broken within a few months of release by MIT student Andrew Huang. Soft mods soon let owners run unsigned code without opening the console.

Players still remember modded Xboxes running emulators and working as media centers years after the console stopped selling.

The PS2 is the easier one to play today

Dragon Quest VIII: Journey of the Cursed King
Dragon Quest VIII: Journey of the Cursed King.

The PS2 wins the retro handheld era. Players report that good handhelds run PS2 games while the Xbox gets left out, since Android and Linux handhelds have no Xbox emulator to speak of. The Xbox does have one card to play: every later Xbox console can run a selection of its games.

PS2 games hold more value, Xbox games save you money

Steel Battalion
Steel Battalion.

The PS2 wins on resale. A loose copy of Kuon sells for about $600 and Rule of Rose for about $488. The priciest Xbox game is Steel Battalion at about $332, and that price is for the game with its giant controller.

Buying is another story. The same game often costs less on Xbox, as players have been saying for years. Silent Hill 2 sells loose for about $100 on PS2 and $40 on Xbox. Def Jam: Fight for NY is $157 on PS2 and $79 on Xbox.

The big hits are cheap on both sides. Final Fantasy X sells for about $7, Halo 2 for about $7 and San Andreas for $13 on PS2 and $12 on Xbox.

Which one wins?

Count it all up and the PS2 takes it, with more consoles, more games and a whole PS1 library thrown in. That settles nothing. If you grew up with a Duke controller in your lap and Halo on the TV, the Xbox was the best console ever made and no sales chart will talk you out of it. A console is worth what you remember doing on it, and for most of us that means the friends piled on the floor at two in the morning.

Related articles