
The PS3 logo used a font inspired by the 2002 Spider-Man film, and Ken Kutaragi picked it as one of the first design choices for the whole console. The machine built around it was huge and glossy. The 20 GB model was estimated to cost about $307 more to make than it sold for. When Sony launched the redesign in 2009, the Spider-Man font was gone.
Owners split right there. Some kept the big piano black machine because it still played their PS2 discs. Others wanted a console that didn't sound like a hairdryer, and every gaming friend group ended up arguing over PS3 Fat vs PS3 Slim.
The Slim is 33% smaller and 36% lighter, and it sold over a million units in its first 3 weeks. Ask a Fat owner and they will tell you that number means nothing, because a stock Slim won't play a single PS2 disc. In this article we will find out which one you should buy.
Buy a PS3 Slim, unless you want to play PS2 discs

Both consoles play The Last of Us and the rest of the PS3 library, and all models can play PS1 games. The big difference is PS2 discs, which only some early Fats can run.
Buy a Slim if you came for the PS3 games. It runs cooler and it's less likely to die on you. Buy a Fat only if you want PS2 discs on one console and you can live with the repair risk. Most players give the same advice.
Only some Fat PS3s play PS2 discs

Fat doesn't always mean backward compatible. The 40 GB, 80 GB (CECHK, CECHL and CECHM) and 160 GB models have two USB ports instead of four. They have no PS2 support either, so your Persona 4 disc does nothing in them.
Players use a simple test: count the USB ports on the front. Four ports means it plays PS2 discs.
The four-port models aren't all equal. The first 20 GB and 60 GB NTSC models do it in hardware. The European 60 GB and the CECHE 80 GB dropped the PS2 processor and use software instead, and compatibility slipped a little.
Backward compatible Fats cost a lot more

The last model with built-in PS2 support was the North American 80 GB Metal Gear Solid 4 bundle. Sony never brought that support back. Players say the ones that play PS2 games are much more expensive than a Slim, and you are paying extra for the oldest hardware of the lot.
A PS3 Slim and a PS2 beat one Fat

The Slim can't play Shadow of the Colossus from a PS2 disc. A lot of players solve that by buying two consoles: a PS3 Slim and a slim PS2. One player worked out that the pair is smaller than a Fat, which tells you how big the Fat is.
You also get a real PS2, so there's nothing to worry about with compatibility. Sony also sold PS2 Classics on the PlayStation Store from October 2011, and it put out HD remasters of PS2 games under the Classics HD name.
The Fat is the one that gets the yellow light of death

Some original PS3s fail with a yellow light. In September 2009 the BBC show Watchdog called it the "yellow light of death" and reported that affected consoles usually failed 18 to 24 months after purchase. Sony said only about 0.5% of consoles came back with it. A 2009 study by the warranty company SquareTrade found a two-year failure rate of 10%.
Players are harder on it than Sony was. They say old Fats break more often, and plenty of them replaced a dead Fat with a Slim. Every Fat left on the market is old enough to drive.
If you buy one anyway, ask whether it has been cleaned and given new thermal paste, because owners of old Fats do that to keep them alive. Then run something heavy like Killzone 2 for an hour before you pay.
The Slim runs cooler and quieter

The Slim moved the Cell processor to a 45 nm process, which lets it run cooler and quieter, and Sony redesigned the cooling system too. It uses 34% less power than the Fat it replaced, and 45% less on the CECH-21xx models. The first Fats shipped with a 380 W power supply and the Slim started at 250 W.
Players notice it. They call old Fats loud, and they say those machines get seriously hot. Heavy Rain has a lot of quiet scenes, and on a Fat you get to hear the fan in all of them.
Give a Fat room to breathe. Players say most of the trouble starts inside a cabinet.
The Fat is the better looking console

The Fat has a glossy piano black shell, touch-sensitive power and eject buttons and that Spider-Man font. Plenty of players call it the best looking PlayStation ever made, or the best looking console of all. Next to a shelf of Resistance: Fall of Man and the other early games, it still looks like the future.
It also looks like a countertop grill, and it weighs about the same as one. Point to the Fat anyway.
The Slim is easier to live with

The Fat weighs 5 kg and the Slim weighs 3.2 kg, which you will notice the first time you carry one to a friend's house. Your TV remote can also control a Slim over HDMI. The Slim launched at $299, down from the $599 that the 60 GB Fat cost at launch.
It got some nice colors too. Japan had a white Final Fantasy XIII Slim with pink designs. Players say the Slim is the cheap and reliable one to buy now.
The Slim is the one to mod

Custom firmware is modded system software. If you want to run it, players point to a Slim in the 2100 to 2500 model range.
A modded Slim can run most PS2 games, which is the one thing that made the Fat worth the risk. Most doesn't mean all, so check that Gran Turismo 4 or your favorite game works before you count on it.
The Super Slim is the cheap-feeling option

Sony released a third design in 2012. The Super Slim weighs 2.1 kg and has a sliding disc cover in place of the slot-loading drive. Some models came with only 12 GB of flash memory, so check that before you buy. Reviewers said it felt cheap and called it "ultimately a step back", and players agree that it feels cheap.
It still plays Puppeteer and the rest of the library. Players still call it a solid way to get a working PS3, and it can run HEN, a mod that adds emulators and homebrew. It can't play PS2 discs, so it's a Slim with a worse lid.
Which one wins?
On paper the Slim wins, because it's cooler and much less likely to die halfway through a boss fight. It doesn't matter. If the big glossy Fat sat under your TV, no power figure will talk you out of it. The fan noise was never what you remembered. You remember the late nights with one more chapter of Uncharted, and those are yours on either console.





