
Nintendo showed its motion controller first, and then Sony had one too. At E3 2006 Sony announced the Sixaxis, less than eight months after Nintendo revealed motion sensing in its own controller. People suspected a late decision to follow Nintendo, and the developers of Warhawk said they got the motion controllers only about 10 days before the show.
That November the two consoles reached America two days apart, the PS3 on November 17 and the Wii on November 19. Every family with one Christmas list had the same fight over PS3 vs Wii.
The Wii shipped 101.63 million consoles and the PS3 sold 87.4 million. PS3 owners will tell you that number means little, since plenty of those Wiis never played a second game. In this article we will find out who really won.
The Wii reached people who had never owned a console

Wii Sports came in the box in all regions except Japan, and it sold 82.90 million copies. Residents at senior centers and retirement homes formed their own Wii Sports bowling leagues. Wii Sports and Wii Fit are credited with bringing in more casual, female and elderly players, and Sony had nothing to match them.
Wii Fit went further. The Balance Board sold 42 million units by January 2012 and set a Guinness World Record for "best-selling personal weighing device". The scale in your bathroom never saw it coming.
There was a catch. Players say millions of people bought a Wii for one game and never bought another. Nintendo also acknowledged that the console was unpopular among hardcore gamers. The Wii still wins this one, because a console in your grandmother's living room counts.
The $599 PS3 lost the price fight before it started

The PS3 launched at $499.99 for the 20 GB model and $599.99 for the 60 GB model. The Wii cost $249.99, half the price of the cheaper PS3. Even then Sony sold the PS3 at a loss. The graphics chip was estimated at $129 and the Blu-ray drive at $125, so those two parts alone came to about $254, more than a whole Wii.
Nintendo went the other way. One analyst estimated a profit of $49 on each Wii sold in the United States in 2007. Demand for the Wii outstripped supply throughout 2007.
Players remember that price gap deciding the fight, and some who wanted a PS3 went home with a Wii. The Wii takes this round with ease.
The PS3 brought HD and the Wii stayed at 480p

The PS3 was the first console with an HDMI port and the first that could output games in 1080p. The Wii stopped at 480p. Satoru Iwata reportedly used a stack of three DVD cases as a reference for the Wii's size, and you can tell where Nintendo's priorities were.
If you owned an HD TV, you saw the difference straight away. Players call the Wii far weaker and still complain that it never reached 720p. Going back and forth between Gran Turismo 5 and a Wii game made the point better than any spec sheet. The PS3 wins this without trying.
The Wii couldn't play a DVD and the PS3 played everything

The Wii does not support DVDs or CDs. Nintendo felt that most consumers already owned something that could play a DVD. The PS3 read Blu-ray movies, DVDs and CDs, and it helped Sony make Blu-ray the winner over HD DVD. Toshiba gave up on HD DVD on February 19, 2008.
The format mattered for games too. Metal Gear Solid 4 uses a 50 GB dual layer Blu-ray disc. For a lot of households the PS3 was also the movie player, and players still say that was half the reason to own one. Netflix left the Wii on January 30, 2019. Sony takes the living room.
The big third-party games skipped the Wii

More games were being developed for the Wii than for the PS3 at one point, and the count fooled nobody. Major publishers were passing over the Wii by 2011 because it was underpowered and used non-standard development tools. They put their money on the PS3, the Xbox 360 and PC.
Players remember the third-party games that did reach the Wii as watered-down ports or shovelware. Anyone who wanted the games everyone at school was talking about, like Red Dead Redemption, needed the other console. The PS3 wins this one.
Uncharted 2 was the game Wii owners never got

Sony's own studios gave the PS3 its reputation. Uncharted 2 got a Metacritic score of 96 and over 200 Game of the Year awards. The Last of Us sold 10 million copies on the PS3.
A Wii owner had nothing that looked like those games. They were long, cinematic stories made for players who wanted to sit down for a whole weekend, and the Wii was built for twenty minutes of bowling after dinner.
Nintendo's own games were the reason to own a Wii

Super Mario Galaxy holds a Metacritic score of 97, and it became the first Nintendo game to win the BAFTA for Best Game, surpassing Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare. Mario Kart Wii sold 37.38 million copies and New Super Mario Bros. Wii sold 30.32 million. Twilight Princess was a launch game and sold 8.85 million, which made it the best-selling Zelda until Breath of the Wild.
Players who kept a Wii say Nintendo's own games were why. Fans even fought for the console's late RPGs. Xenoblade Chronicles reached North America on 6 April 2012 only after a campaign called Operation Rainfall drew attention to it. For Mario Kart with four friends on one couch, the PS3 had no answer, and Nintendo wins this fight.
The Wii started the motion fight and the Move arrived almost four years later

The Wii Remote changed how a lot of people played. Sony released the PlayStation Move on September 15, 2010, and by November 2012 it had 15 million sold. The Guardian said it was "very hard to go back to the relative inaccuracy of the Wii", and that is fair. The Move was the better wand.
It came far too late. Players got tired of waggle on the Wii, and plenty of them call it a gimmick. The Wii still had the games that used it well, and Resident Evil 4 with a pointer is a good reason to keep one around. Early wrist straps tended to break under heavy use and Nintendo replaced them free of charge, so at least your TV had a chance. The Wii wins for getting there almost four years ahead.
A modded Wii plays the past on one box

Early Wii models play GameCube discs, so one console could cover two Nintendo generations. The PS3 lets you download original PlayStation games from the PlayStation Store, which is handy but a smaller shelf.
Players who want one box for old games go further and pick a modded Wii over a PS3. They use homebrew to run everything from the NES onward, and they say the PS3 looks like a much bigger job. For a retro fan with a tube TV in the spare room, this is the Wii's best trick.
PSN outlasted Nintendo's online

Nintendo Wi-Fi Connection needed a twelve-digit Friend Code to play with a specific person, and using a different copy of a game gave you a new code. Nintendo shut it down on May 20, 2014, and the Wii Shop Channel closed on January 31, 2019.
Signing up for the PlayStation Network is free, and PlayStation Plus, added in June 2010, was optional. The PS3 had a real online service with friend lists that followed you around. The Wii had a code on a sticky note, and the PS3 takes this round too.
Wii games hold their value and PS3 games don't

A loose copy of Rhythm Heaven Fever typically sells for $113, and Metroid Prime Trilogy goes for $92. On the PS3, Metal Gear Solid 4 sells for $10, Red Dead Redemption for $9 and Grand Theft Auto V for $7.
Wii Sports, the disc that came in the box, sells for $29, about four times what you pay for Grand Theft Auto V. The PS3 has a few rare ones, like 3D Dot Game Heroes at $85 and Demon's Souls at $19. Nintendo wins resale the way it usually does, so keep that bowling disc.
Which one wins?
On paper the Wii takes it, with more consoles sold and games that still cost real money. It doesn't matter. If the PS3 was where you watched your first Blu-ray and stayed up finishing Uncharted 2, that console is yours, and a Wii and a family bowling night are just as yours. What made either one special was what you did with it and who you did it with, and no sales chart gets a vote on that.





