PS3 vs Xbox 360

PS3 vs Xbox 360

PS3 vs Xbox 360

Sony and Microsoft both paid a fortune for this fight. The 60 GB PS3 sold for $599 and cost an estimated $241 more than that to build. Microsoft took its hit when Xbox 360s started breaking. Peter Moore told CEO Steve Ballmer the repairs would cost $1.15 billion, and Ballmer said "do it" without a pause.

A lot of people bought whichever box their friends had, because you could only play online with your own side. Every lunch table and dorm room in the country argued over PS3 vs Xbox 360.

The PS3 finished ahead, 87.4 million sold to about 84 million, after launching a year later at a higher price. Ask anyone who spent those years on Xbox Live and they will tell you that number means nothing. In this article we will find out who really won.

The Xbox 360 got a year's head start at a lower price

Gears of War
Gears of War.

The Xbox 360 wins the launch. It came out on November 22, 2005 at $399, or $299 for the Core model. The PS3 reached North America on November 17, 2006 at $499 for 20 GB and $599 for 60 GB.

By then 360 owners had a whole year of games on the shelf. Gears of War alone sold 3 million copies in 2006, and the PS3 launched in North America with 14 titles.

Ask players how the 360 did so well and they point at Sony's price. Sony wasn't making money at that price either. It later acknowledged about $3.3 billion in hardware losses through mid-2008.

Halo and Gears of War sold the Xbox 360

Halo 3
Halo 3.

The 360 wins the blockbuster fight. Halo 3 grossed $170 million on its first day and $300 million in its first week. More than a million people played it on Xbox Live in the first twenty hours, and it was the best-selling game of 2007 in the United States.

Players say it plainly: Halo and Gears are why they bought the console.

Xbox Live was worth paying for

Halo: Reach
Halo: Reach.

The 360 wins online for most of the generation. Xbox Live started back on the original Xbox in 2002, so dedicated players arrived with a friends list ready to go. Players say the friends list and party chat worked better than anything on PSN, and more of their friends were there.

Gold ended up costing $59.99 a year. For that money you got to hear a stranger insult your mother in real time.

Sony's worst moment came in April 2011, when a hack took PSN down for 23 days and exposed personal details from about 77 million accounts. Sony said sorry with two free PS3 games.

PS3 owners never paid to play online

Uncharted 2: Among Thieves
Uncharted 2: Among Thieves.

The PS3 wins on value. Players who owned both bring up free online first, and they remember it fondly now that every console charges for it.

Microsoft made you pay for Gold just to open Netflix until June 2014. Sony went the other way and showed PS Plus at E3 2010 as an optional extra. Players called it a far better deal than Xbox Live.

Multiplatform games ran better on the Xbox 360

The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim
The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim.

The 360 wins this one, at least early on. Developers found the PS3 difficult to program for, and the Cell processor at its heart was nothing like a PC. The early EA Sports games ran at 60 frames per second on the 360 and 30 on the PS3. Bayonetta was made for the 360, and Sega handed the PS3 port to another studio.

Sony's side will tell you the PS3 versions caught up by 2008. Players mostly don't buy it, and they still say the 360 version is the better one. Skyrim is the game they bring up most. Players warned each other off the PS3 version and told them to get it on 360.

The Red Ring of Death cost the 360 the reliability fight

Mass Effect
Mass Effect.

The PS3 wins, and it isn't close. In 2009 SquareTrade put the 360's failure rate at 23.7%, and a Game Informer survey said 54.2%. SquareTrade's figure for the PS3 was 10% over two years.

Three red lights on the front meant your console was dead. Microsoft extended the warranty to three years for the fault, and $240 million of the repair bill was FedEx alone. Players talk about going through three, five, even seven consoles. You could be twenty hours into Mass Effect when the lights came on.

The PS3 had its own version, the yellow light of death. Sony said only about 0.5% of consoles came back with it. Players say it never hit the same scale as the red ring, though plenty of fat PS3s did die from it.

Blu-ray won the format war, and the PS3 won with it

Metal Gear Solid 4: Guns of the Patriots
Metal Gear Solid 4: Guns of the Patriots.

The PS3 wins the disc fight. It was the first console to use Blu-ray as its main format. Xbox 360 games were limited to 8.5 GB on a DVD, while Metal Gear Solid 4 came on a 50 GB disc. Players remember big 360 games spread across two or three discs when the PS3 needed one.

Microsoft backed HD DVD with a $199 add-on in November 2006. Toshiba gave up on the format on February 19, 2008, and the add-on was gone the same year. The PS3 is one of the main reasons Blu-ray won, and players say plenty of people bought one as a cheap Blu-ray player.

The catch was speed. The PS3's drive ran at 2× and Bayonetta needed an update to install to the hard drive, which cut its load times.

The PS3 ended the generation with the better exclusives

The Last of Us
The Last of Us.

The PS3 wins this one late. Uncharted 2, Metal Gear Solid 4, Demon's Souls and The Last of Us all came out on Sony's console. Edge magazine ranked the 360 the second-best console of 1993 to 2013 and still admitted "there's nothing to trump" Naughty Dog's PS3 games.

Ask people who owned both and they give the PS3 the exclusives. Some 360 owners gave in and bought a PS3 late in the generation to play them.

Japan never bought the Xbox 360

Lost Odyssey
Lost Odyssey.

The PS3 wins for JRPG fans. The 360 sold 1.62 million in Japan over its whole life, and the PS3 had reached 9.3 million by June 2013. Japanese studios followed the audience, and players will tell you the PS3 is the console to get for JRPGs.

Microsoft did try. Blue Dragon and Lost Odyssey came from Mistwalker, and only three 360 games ever passed 200,000 copies in Japan. Players still say Lost Odyssey and the few other 360 exclusives are worth owning the console for.

The Xbox 360 controller fit your hands better

Geometry Wars: Retro Evolved 2
Geometry Wars: Retro Evolved 2.

The 360 wins. Players say its sticks and triggers beat the DualShock 3, whose domed sticks let your thumbs slip off and whose triggers were easy to press by accident. Sony was so sure of its old shape that it barely changed it. PC players made the 360 pad their standard, and PC games and Steam still treat controllers as if they were one.

An Xbox 360 game still plays on a new Xbox

Red Dead Redemption
Red Dead Redemption.

The 360 wins the long game. The Series X plays every 360 game that was already backward compatible on the Xbox One. Players point out that a PS3 disc needs a PS3.

Digital buyers lost out though. The Xbox 360 store stopped selling on July 29, 2024.

The PS3's exclusives hold a little more value

Demon's Souls
Demon's Souls.

Resale is close to a tie, and the PS3 edges it. Players have called both libraries dirt cheap for years. A loose copy of Grand Theft Auto V sells for about $7 on either console. Red Dead Redemption is $9 on PS3 and $8 on the 360.

The big exclusives are where they split. Halo 3 sells for about $7 and Gears of War for $5. Metal Gear Solid 4 is $10, Demon's Souls is $19 and Folklore is $42. The 360 has one answer in Lost Odyssey at $20.

Which one wins?

On paper the PS3 wins, with more consoles sold and the better exclusives. It doesn't matter. If you spent your teens on Xbox Live with your friends yelling in your headset, nobody can tell you the 360 lost. What made your console special was never the sales chart or the disc drive. It was the memories you made with it.

Related articles