PS4 vs Wii U

PS4 vs Wii U

PS4 vs Wii U

The Wii U had a problem before it reached a single shop. The day after Nintendo announced its launch dates in September 2012, marketing manager Bill Trinen admitted that the company had talked about the GamePad so much that some people took the Wii U for an accessory for the old Wii. Nintendo promised to show the console on the box as well.

A year later the PS4 arrived, and every game shop queue had someone in it trying to settle PS4 vs Wii U. You wanted Mario or you wanted Call of Duty, and most of us could only afford one.

The PS4 shipped 117.2 million consoles and the Wii U sold 13.56 million, more than eight for every one. Wii U owners will tell you that number only counts boxes, and that they had the better games for years. In this article we will find out who really won.

The Wii U name lost the fight before the PS4 showed up

Nintendo Land
Nintendo Land.

Nintendo Land was built to show off the GamePad, and it still could not fix that accessory problem. Players still call the name one of the console's biggest mistakes, and plenty of them admit they thought it was an add-on for the Wii. Nintendo of America boss Reggie Fils-Aimé later blamed the lack of clarity about what the GamePad did, and he changed the marketing for the Switch because of it.

The PS4 had a bigger number on it than the PS3, and that was all the explaining it needed. In March 2014, four months after launch, its worldwide sales passed the Wii U's total, even though the Wii U had a year's head start. Nielsen found that 31 percent of PS4 sales by August 2014 had gone to Wii and Xbox 360 owners who had never owned a PS3. The PS4 takes this round without pressing a button.

The Wii U was cheaper and the PS4 was worth the extra money

Uncharted 4: A Thief's End
Uncharted 4: A Thief's End.

The Wii U launched at $299.99 for the Basic Set and $349.99 for the Deluxe Set, and the Deluxe dropped to $299.99 in September 2013. The PS4 cost $399 two months later. On price alone, Nintendo wins.

Then you look at what the money bought. The Basic had 8 GB of storage and the Deluxe had 32 GB, while the PS4 had a 500 GB hard drive. The Wii U had 2 GB of memory with 1 GB reserved for the operating system. The PS4 had 8 GB of GDDR5. Players say the Wii U sat closer to the PS3 and Xbox 360 than to the PS4, and it could not run the most demanding games built for Sony's console. Play Uncharted 4 and you can see where the memory went. An extra $100 has rarely gone further.

Third-party publishers left the Wii U and the PS4 got everything

Rayman Legends
Rayman Legends.

It started well. When Nintendo unveiled the Wii U at E3 2011, EA's then-CEO John Riccitiello came on stage to talk about his company's plans for the console. Fils-Aimé later listed the lack of third-party support as one of the reasons the Wii U failed.

Rayman Legends is the sad version of that story. It was meant to be a Wii U launch window exclusive, but ZombiU lost Ubisoft money, so Ubisoft made Rayman Legends multiplatform. The release slipped from February 2013 to September 2013 so PS3 and Xbox 360 owners could join in, even though the developers said the Wii U version was already finished. Over 11,000 fans signed a petition, and the delay stayed.

By late July 2016 the Wii U had 118 third-party games on disc in the United States, the lowest figure for any Nintendo console. Players say the big third-party games were a deciding reason to pick the PS4, and it is hard to argue. The PS4 wins by a mile.

The GamePad was the Wii U's best idea

Super Mario Maker
Super Mario Maker.

Marketing it was a mess, but the GamePad itself was great. You could put a whole game on its 6.2 inch touchscreen and hand the TV over to the rest of the house. Players who owned one say the second screen made games better, and some picked the Wii U version of a game over the PS4 version because of it.

Super Mario Maker is the best proof. You drew levels on the GamePad with the stylus, and by May 2016 players had made more than 7.2 million courses, which had been played more than 600 million times. Drawing a level on your lap beat doing it with a thumbstick.

Sony's answer was Remote Play. Players called it the PS4's version of the GamePad, and it was a good one, except that you had to buy a Vita to use it until a PC and Mac update arrived in April 2016. The GamePad had a short battery life of 3 to 5 hours and it was often wasted in games. It still came in the box, so every game could count on it. The Wii U wins this one.

The Wii U had the better games for its first few years

Mario Kart 8
Mario Kart 8.

The PS4 sold like mad and had almost nothing of its own to play. Players said so at the time, and they kept saying the Wii U's exclusives beat the PS4's for years.

Mario Kart 8 is the best-selling Wii U game at 8.46 million copies, and when it came out, Wii U console sales in the United Kingdom reportedly went up 666 percent. Super Mario 3D World sold 5.89 million. Super Smash Bros. for Wii U sold 490,000 copies in the United States in its first three days, and December 2014 became the console's biggest month there. If you judge 2014 alone, the Wii U wins.

Bloodborne and God of War took the generation back

God of War
God of War.

Sony's games turned up late and then they did not stop. Bloodborne is the game players name when they explain why they finally bought a PS4, and it had sold 7.46 million copies by February 2022.

God of War was named Game of the Year by numerous outlets and sold 23 million copies by November 2022, more than double Mario Kart 8 on the Wii U. Marvel's Spider-Man had sold 13.2 million by August 2019 and Uncharted 4 passed 18 million. Players who stuck around until the end call this the best set of exclusives of the generation. The Wii U was gone by then, so the PS4 wins on a walkover.

Nintendo paid for Bayonetta 2 when Sega shelved it

Bayonetta 2
Bayonetta 2.

The first Bayonetta came out on PS3 and Xbox 360, and fans were not happy when the sequel turned up as a Wii U exclusive. Then the story came out. Sega had shelved the game and Nintendo stepped in with the funding. Producer Atsushi Inaba said Bayonetta 2 would not exist without that deal.

Nintendo also put a port of the first game in the box on a separate disc. Players keep putting Bayonetta 2 on their Wii U shortlists. Without Nintendo nobody would have got it, so the Wii U takes the round.

The PS4 was where your friends played online

Splatoon
Splatoon.

Nintendo did some lovely things online. Wii U owners paid no subscription fee, and Splatoon showed Miiverse posts as graffiti on the walls of its city. It was the friendliest idea of the generation.

Players still went to the PS4, because that was where everyone else was. Owners of both say they played the PS4 more for online games, and they rated Nintendo's online service well behind Sony's. The Wii U's online shut down on April 9, 2024, so Sony wins this one for good.

Four friends on one sofa was a Wii U thing

Super Smash Bros. for Wii U
Super Smash Bros. for Wii U.

Big publishers were dropping split screen in those years, and players say the PS4 went along with it while the Wii U kept the couch alive. Owners of both say the Wii U had more local multiplayer, and it is the console they turned on when friends came over.

Four players could use Wii Remotes or Pro Controllers at once, and Nintendo even made a GameCube controller adapter with four ports for Smash. Nintendo Land took up to five players, with the GamePad player doing something different from everyone else. The Wii U wins.

The Wii U played your old games and the PS4 did not

Super Mario Galaxy
Super Mario Galaxy.

The Wii U is compatible with all Wii games and accessories, so a new owner could start with a shelf full of them. Players loved this. It was the only one of the three new consoles that could do it, and plenty spent the quiet months playing the Wii games they had missed. The Virtual Console added NES, Super NES, Game Boy Advance, Nintendo 64 and DS games.

The PS4 had no backward compatibility on the hardware. Sony's answer was PlayStation Now, a streaming service you paid for. Your PS3 discs stayed on the shelf, and the Wii U takes the round.

The Wii U's best games all moved to the Switch

The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild
The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild.

Nintendo discontinued the Wii U on January 31, 2017, and most of its popular exclusives were re-released on the Switch. Mario Kart 8 Deluxe has sold 71.08 million copies against 8.46 million for the Wii U original. Breath of the Wild, the last first-party Wii U game, sold 1.70 million on the Wii U and 34.06 million on the Switch.

The holdouts went too. Xenoblade Chronicles X reached the Switch in 2025, and The Wonderful 101 reached the PS4 of all places, after a Kickstarter that raised over $2.25 million. Most of what made a Wii U special is now easier to play somewhere else, so the PS4 takes this round by default.

Wii U games are worth more today

The Legend of Zelda: The Wind Waker HD
The Legend of Zelda: The Wind Waker HD.

Nintendo gets its usual late win here. A loose copy of The Wind Waker HD typically sells for $45 and Twilight Princess HD for $100. Bloodborne goes for $14, God of War for $10 and The Last of Us Remastered for $11.

Both consoles have cheap blockbusters, since Mario Kart 8 is only $10, and both have odd rarities: Devil's Third on Wii U sells for $222 and Godzilla on PS4 for $287. Wii U owners also have a hardware cost that PS4 owners never think about. A replacement GamePad typically sells for $74, so look after yours.

Which one wins?

On paper the PS4 wins: more than eight times the consoles and a game library that kept growing long after the Wii U stopped. None of that counts for much. If the Wii U was the one under your TV, you know what those Mario Kart nights were worth, and no chart can tell you otherwise. The console you grew up with stays yours because of the memories you made on it, and Wii U owners get one small bonus: the discs on their shelf are worth more.

Related articles