PS4 vs Xbox One

PS4 vs Xbox One

PS4 vs Xbox One

Microsoft showed the Xbox One to the world on May 21, 2013, and talked about television for over 30 minutes before it showed a single game. Several employees complained about it to Phil Spencer, who later ran Xbox. At E3 that June, Sony announced the PS4 at $399, a full $100 under the Xbox One.

The two consoles launched a week apart that November, and friends who had played together for years had to pick a side. Group chats and game store counters everywhere were arguing about PS4 vs Xbox One.

Sony shipped 117.2 million PS4s, about double the 58 million Xbox Ones Microsoft reported. Xbox fans say that number tells you nothing about Game Pass or the old games their console could still play. In this article we will work out who really won.

Sony won E3 2013 with a $399 price tag

Killzone: Shadow Fall
Killzone: Shadow Fall.

Microsoft's first plan for the Xbox One was strict. The console had to connect to the internet once every 24 hours, and if it couldn't, your games stopped working. Sony went on stage at E3 with its lower price and a pitch about how easy it was to share games on a PS4. The Xbox One cost $499.

Microsoft gave in on June 19, 2013, and dropped the plan. Don Mattrick, then president of its Interactive Entertainment Business, left for Zynga on July 1. The rules were gone by launch, but the price gap stayed. Players still say the $100 was what decided this generation. Sony takes the first round without breaking a sweat.

Microsoft built a TV box and Sony built a game console

Kinect Sports Rivals
Kinect Sports Rivals.

The Xbox One could run your cable box through its HDMI port and show live TV with its own program guide. Every launch console also came with a Kinect camera. Players blame that camera for the higher price, and many had no wish to pay for one.

People who only wanted games felt left out. They called the Xbox One a media device that happened to play games, and they liked that the PS4 put games first. The menus got the same complaints. Players remember a slow Xbox dashboard full of ads and a PS4 home screen they could find their way around.

Microsoft backed down again. A version with no Kinect went on sale on June 9, 2014, for $399, and US sales more than doubled that month. Microsoft ended production of Kinect for Xbox One in October 2017. By then a lot of those cameras were living in closets.

The PS4 had the stronger hardware at launch

Call of Duty: Ghosts
Call of Duty: Ghosts.

Both consoles had 8 GB of memory, and the PS4's was the faster kind. It used GDDR5 with 176 GB/s of bandwidth. The Xbox One used DDR3 at 68.3 GB/s, with a small 32 MB pool of ESRAM to help.

You could see the gap in the launch window. Call of Duty: Ghosts and Assassin's Creed IV: Black Flag ran at 1080p on the PS4. On the Xbox One they ran at 720p and 900p. Players say pretty much all the cross-platform games looked or ran better on the PS4 for years, and that hurt in a generation sold on 1080p.

The Xbox One X took the power crown back

Red Dead Redemption 2
Red Dead Redemption 2.

Microsoft answered on November 7, 2017, with the Xbox One X. It had 12 GB of GDDR5 and 326 GB/s of bandwidth, and it could render games at 4K. It cost $499 against $399 for the PS4 Pro, which had come out in 2016.

Players agree the One X was the most powerful console of its time. The Xbox line had one more trick. The Xbox One S could play Ultra HD Blu-ray discs, and the PS4 Pro does not support them. Microsoft wins this round, four years late.

The PS4 ran away with the exclusives

Bloodborne
Bloodborne.

This is the fight players bring up first, and the PS4 wins it easily. Bloodborne, Uncharted 4, God of War, Marvel's Spider-Man and Horizon Zero Dawn were PlayStation games when they came out, and they sold like it.

God of War had sold 23 million copies by November 2022. Horizon Zero Dawn has sold over 24 million units. Uncharted 4 passed 18 million, and Bloodborne had sold 7.46 million by February 2022. Marvel's Spider-Man sold 3.3 million units in its first three days. Plenty of players sold their Xbox One to buy a PS4 for these games.

Xbox's biggest names let its fans down

Halo 5: Guardians
Halo 5: Guardians.

Halo 5: Guardians sold five million units within three months. It also had no split-screen, unlike the Halo shooters before it, and its story took a beating. Players felt Microsoft kept leaning on Halo, Gears of War and Forza with little else behind them.

The new games that might have helped never came. Fable Legends and Scalebound were cancelled, and Crackdown 3 was delayed. Sony fans spent 2018 playing God of War while Xbox fans were checking release dates.

Xbox exclusives ran on PC anyway

Forza Horizon 4
Forza Horizon 4.

In 2016 Microsoft started releasing its first-party games on Windows 10 PCs at the same time as the Xbox One. That was great news for PC owners. It was bad news for the console, since Forza Horizon 4, which reviewers loved on Xbox One, also came to PC. Players with a gaming PC said the Xbox One had nothing they couldn't play there. Sony takes this one by default.

Japanese games stayed with PlayStation

Persona 5
Persona 5.

Only 0.3% of the 46.9 million Xbox Ones sold through the second quarter of 2019 went to Japan. The PS4 launched there on February 22, 2014, and the Xbox One waited until September 4.

The games followed the players. Fans of Japanese games bought a PS4 for them, and even Xbox One X owners admit these ports could feel like an afterthought on their console.

The Xbox One played your old games and the PS4 didn't

Castle Crashers
Castle Crashers.

Don Mattrick once said "If you're backwards compatible, you're backwards", and claimed only 5% of Microsoft's customers played older games on new consoles. After Phil Spencer took over Xbox in 2014, he restarted the work in relative secret. His team tested it on Castle Crashers.

The feature launched with 104 Xbox 360 titles, and original Xbox games followed. Players still give the Xbox One big credit for this, and hundreds of old games ended up working on it. The PS4 had no backward compatibility on the hardware. Sony's answer was PlayStation Now, which streamed PS3 games to you for a fee. Xbox takes this round.

Game Pass was the deal of the generation

Sea of Thieves
Sea of Thieves.

Microsoft introduced Xbox Game Pass in February 2017. Starting with Sea of Thieves on March 20, 2018, its own games joined the service on the day they came out. Gears 5 was played by 3 million people in its first weekend, the biggest launch Game Pass had seen.

Budget players loved it. An Xbox One with Game Pass and a stack of used discs became one of the best deals in gaming, and it won back some people who had given up on Xbox. If you are buying one of these consoles today on a small budget, this is the strongest argument for the Xbox.

You bought whichever one your friends had

Titanfall 2
Titanfall 2.

Online play cost money on both consoles. PS3 owners had played online for free, but a PlayStation Plus membership was required for multiplayer in most PS4 games. Xbox Live Gold did the same job on the Xbox One.

That left the choice to your friends. Players say it mattered more than any spec, and the PS4's early lead pulled more people in each year. If your group was on Xbox Live, the Xbox One was the right console, whatever the sales charts said. Plenty of people switched sides and left a whole friends list behind.

The controller fight ended in a split

Gears 5
Gears 5.

The DualShock 4 added a touchpad and a light bar, plus a SHARE button that let you go back through the last 60 minutes of play. Its battery is built in and charges over USB. The Xbox One controller kept the layout of the Xbox 360 pad and ran on AA batteries unless you bought a charging kit.

Players never settled this one. Shooter fans tend to take the Xbox pad, and the rest are happy on a DualShock 4. Microsoft did release the Elite Wireless Controller on October 27, 2015, for people who wanted to spend more on one. Call it a draw.

Neither console's games hold their value

The Last of Us Remastered
The Last of Us Remastered.

Players say the games from both consoles are dirt cheap now. A loose copy of God of War sells for about $10 on PS4, and Uncharted 4 is $9. Grand Theft Auto V is $9 and Red Dead Redemption 2 is $12. Even Bloodborne only reaches $14. The Last of Us Part II is the priciest of these at $15.

Both libraries still work on the new consoles. The PS5 plays the majority of PS4 games, and the Xbox Series X/S plays the old Xbox and Xbox 360 games the Xbox One could run. Xbox gets the nod here because one console covers three generations of used discs.

Which one wins?

On paper the PS4 wins, with about twice the consoles sold and the exclusives people still talk about. It doesn't matter. If you spent those years in Halo lobbies, the Xbox One is yours, and no sales chart can take it from you. What you remember from either console is the late nights with your friends on a headset.

Related articles