20 Reasons Why I Play Retro Games and Not Modern Games

20 Reasons Why I Play Retro Games and Not Modern Games

20 Reasons Why I Play Retro Games and Not Modern Games

To each their own, but I have been drawn more and more to retro games and away from modern ones. Here are my 20 reasons.

A few minutes is enough

A person plays a handheld on a park bench with a sandwich
A person plays a handheld on a park bench with a sandwich.

Older games start the moment you turn them on, and players say they are easier to pick up and play for a short session. On a lunch break I can get through a few levels of something on a handheld and feel like I played a game.

Most modern games want a whole evening from me before anything happens. I do not always have one.

Cheat codes were free

A kid enters a code from a magazine as stars burst from the TV
A kid enters a code from a magazine as stars burst from the TV.

Back then a cheat code was a secret you traded at school or found in a magazine. Now the same shortcut is often for sale. Players have noticed that modern DLC and microtransactions sell what used to be a cheat code.

I like a game that lets me be silly with it after the credits, at no charge, and with no store page in sight.

Manuals

A kid reads a game manual in the back seat of a car
A kid reads a game manual in the back seat of a car.

The game started before you got home. Plenty of players remember reading the manual on the way back from the store, and I get it. Good manuals had art, story and tips you could not find in the game.

Now you get a download and a menu of tooltips. Nobody has ever stared lovingly at a tooltip in the back seat of a car.

Friends on the couch

Two friends laugh on a couch playing split screen
Two friends laugh on a couch playing split screen.

Old games assumed your friends were in the room. You passed the controller, you looked at their side of the screen, and you got punched in the arm for it.

Players miss this badly. They say couch co-op is disappearing and that split screen is rare now. A retro console and a second controller still fix that in one evening.

Simplicity

A person pushes a cartridge into a console
A person pushes a cartridge into a console.

Put a game in the console and play. Compare that to downloading a game, likely signing up for another account, and on Steam maybe needing another launcher. It is a common complaint among players, who just want to buy a game without an extra launcher and account in the way.

Take Tekken 3: press start. I still could not believe Tekken on the PSP asked me to pick a character and enter a name. I remember getting Battlefield 1, slogging through the download, and then meeting the EA launcher I had to sign up for. I just wanted to play the darn game.

I can read the screen

A person squints at a screen full of sparks and shapes
A person squints at a screen full of sparks and shapes.

Graphics were simpler back then, so you do not have to work to decode what is happening. Real life vision is taxing, and realistic games ask the same of your brain. I am not a fan of the Final Fantasy VII Remake series. It looks insanely better than the blocky PS1 original, and yet I never once questioned what was going on in the original. In the remake I was often lost.

Players call this visual clutter, and they complain about it a lot in modern games. Flashy works in context. When everything is flashy all the time, it is tiring.

They had charm

A kid and a friendly dinosaur play together by an old TV
A kid and a friendly dinosaur play together by an old TV.

Call it mojo, charm, je ne sais quoi. These games had soul the way Jurassic Park had soul and Jurassic World does not. The original was perfect. World does what many companies are doing with their old IPs: very flashy, no soul.

Limited graphics and focused budgets met boundless creativity, and the result was games still unmatched today.

Small ideas got made

A suit points at a rising chart next to a worried game maker
A suit points at a rising chart next to a worried game maker.

Ever since big business came in, returns are expected. That is fine, but it creates a culture where bigger is better. Then comes the sinking feeling that games like Professor Layton, Ghost Trick or even the original Monster Hunter probably would not get made today.

Players make the same point: a high budget means less room for risk. Those three games were odd ideas, and they got a chance.

No huge downloads

A player with a floor-length beard waits on a loading bar
A player with a floor-length beard waits on a loading bar.

Fifty gigabyte downloads. Seriously demanding games take hours to download, and even a one terabyte drive fills up fast. Players report patches over 40 GB and a fighting game over 100 GB. If you do not own it on disc, or there is a hefty day one patch, you wait before you play.

A cart has no progress bar. By the time a modern game is ready, I could have finished Sonic the Hedgehog and started it again.

Respect for my time

A fairy talks non-stop into a tired player's ear
A fairy talks non-stop into a tired player's ear.

Too many tutorials, too much handholding. There is a meme that imagines Mario as a modern big-budget game, and it works because you can picture it right away: Mario walks slowly down a corridor while someone in his earpiece explains what a Goomba is.

Super Mario Bros. teaches you how to play in its first level without any text. Now players complain about opening tutorials that run for hours, and about characters who never stop talking. Let me play, please.

The arcade feeling

A red race car drifts around a corner
A red race car drifts around a corner.

Midnight Club was so much fun. Then the series went realistic, and Midnight Club: Los Angeles is nowhere near as fun. Realism does not equal fun. We lost the sense of speed and the arcade feeling once everything had to be realistic and big budget.

Players who love these games have noticed that pure arcade racers are much rarer than they used to be. I just want to take a corner sideways at a silly speed and not think about tyre wear.

Real progression

A player celebrates on top of a beaten monster
A player celebrates on top of a beaten monster.

Racing games give you everything from the start. Monster Hunter gives you a hunter who is overly powerful. Games are a virtual world where you can experiment safely and get good at something. Remove the challenge and you remove the sense of accomplishment.

I get that some people want to be guided from point A to point B. There is still something to be said for beating a boss after getting better. It is how life works: things do not always get easier, you just get better.

Remakes everywhere

A photocopier spits out identical game boxes
A photocopier spits out identical game boxes.

Capcom and Nintendo keep looking back, which tells me things were better. Everything is getting remade: Assassin's Creed IV, Zelda, Resident Evil. There are not many new IPs. I understand they are risky, but put that next to everything looking the same and it is not great.

How much more can Square Enix milk Final Fantasy VII? I am not alone here. Plenty of players have run out of patience with the remake trilogy and call it a cash grab.

You could finish a game

A person slides a finished game onto a shelf
A person slides a finished game onto a shelf.

Once you were done with a game, you moved on. Now developers want to bring you back with seasons. Players who have tried live service games describe them the same way, as a job with daily chores. To each their own, but I like a game being done.

Putting a finished cart back on the shelf is one of my favourite feelings in gaming. Nobody emails me about the new season afterwards.

Pride and soul

An artist paints a tiny castle at a desk
An artist paints a tiny castle at a desk.

Look at a game like Ni no Kuni and you can see the art, the polish and the attention that went into it. Games used to be both art and product. Now they are more product.

You can feel when someone cared about a town nobody had to visit, or a joke hidden behind a wall. I go back to old games looking for that, and I still find it.

No DLC, no microtransactions

A robot offers coins and chests to a player who ignores it
A robot offers coins and chests to a player who ignores it.

You had the game in full. You bought Tekken: Dark Resurrection and it was yours. Modern Tekken keeps adding more and more characters. I get it, games are expensive to make and developers want to milk them for as long as possible. It is just not for me.

Plenty of players feel the same about the old days: you bought a complete game, and that was the whole deal.

I own my games

A person hugs a game cartridge
A person hugs a game cartridge.

I have a cart, I put it in, it plays. It does not need to go online to ask for permission. Digital has its benefits, convenience first of all, but lose your email or watch the servers shut down and you find out you held a license. Players point this out all the time: you are paying for a license to play the game.

Sony has already pulled paid movies out of people's libraries, and it is not hard to imagine the same thing with games. Ubisoft permanently shut down the servers of The Crew in 2024, which left that 2014 racing game unplayable. Try launching Steam on a plane without WiFi and you may not be playing. Better have brought the PSP.

Art direction died

Four identical armoured warriors in a row
Four identical armoured warriors in a row.

Everything is Unreal Engine now and it all looks the same, especially on PC and PlayStation. Swords, monsters, dark and brooding. Not every game, but even Onimusha does not look like itself anymore. Players notice this as well: big releases look alike, and they say so.

Old hardware forced choices, and those choices gave each game its own look.

Bloat

A person stares at a wall map covered in tiny markers
A person stares at a wall map covered in tiny markers.

Games are bloated to justify their full ticket price. Players keep saying it too: too much padding, hours of it, stuffed into big releases. I would rather play something that ends when its ideas run out.

A map covered in icons used to look like a lot of game to me. Now it looks like a to-do list, and I already have a job.

Spectacle replaced soul

A person yawns on the sofa at a huge TV explosion
A person yawns on the sofa at a huge TV explosion.

Big budgets and great graphics now stand in for soul. A modern blockbuster can look like a film and still leave me cold. Plenty of players say the same about new releases: all that realistic graphics work, and no soul behind it.

Older games had no such cover. With a few colours and a small cartridge, the designers had to make the game itself fun.

Is it all bad?

No. But the new games I want to play pale in comparison with the retro games I want to play. I am vaguely interested in Crimson Desert and not much else.

Remakes are not all bad either. I would question whether the Final Fantasy VII Remake series is even a remake, or whether Resident Evil 4 needed one, but some are done with love and care, like the Trails remake. Every revisit carries the chance that someone changes everything. The closest thing to a true Final Fantasy VII remake is Final Fantasy VII: Ever Crisis, a mobile gacha game.

Indies keep the light burning. Some big games feel semi-retro to me, like Red Dead Redemption II and Breath of the Wild, and there are exceptions to everything. If you like the latest and greatest, enjoy it. To each their own.

For the most part, I find more creativity and care in the past. R4: Ridge Racer Type 4 is still unmatched by the newer Ridge Racers. So I play retro more than anything modern.

Related articles