
Keeping one game forever is a cruel thing to ask, and players love answering it anyway. Sell the shelf, pack for the desert island, and take one cartridge. These are the old games that keep getting saved from the fire.
Metal Gear Solid (1998)


Metal Gear Solid made players feel like a game could be a movie, and they remember the suspense of the first run. It also turned out to be a short game, so you can run it again every year and still have time to look for fish on the island.
The moment everyone keeps is Psycho Mantis, reading your memory card out loud and judging what you play. Plugging your controller into the second port to beat him still blows people's minds. Alone on an island, you would at least have someone new to talk to, and he already knows you like Castlevania.



Final Fantasy VII (1997)


Final Fantasy VII is the pick for people who already spent their lives on it. Fans keep replaying it, every couple of years for some of them, and they could go on doing it forever. That is a lot of times to walk back into the same church knowing how this goes.
Old PlayStation hands will tell you to bring a good memory card, and that is the only survival tip on this list that came from experience. The death of Aeris is the moment everyone brings up. You would think knowing it was coming would help, and you would be wrong.



Tetris (1989)


Tetris is the smart answer, and its fans know it. Players say stories get old on the fifth trip through, while falling blocks never do. It has no ending to spoil, and you could stay at it long after every other game on your shelf ran out of things to say.
Ask for one game per console and the Game Boy line almost always says Tetris. The long piece is still not coming, though. You can sit on that island for fifty years and it will show up only after you stop needing it.



The Legend of Zelda: Majora's Mask (2000)


Majora's Mask gets picked by players who have to fight themselves first. It keeps landing in the same slot as Ocarina of Time, and people go back and forth over which Zelda stays, because two feels like cheating. Those who choose it talk about the three-day clock, which still feels like nothing else.
That clock is also why it stays with you. Plenty of kids wandered around Clock Town scared, panicked, and turned the days back the moment things went wrong. So you keep the game with the angry face in the sky as your only company, which feels like a choice worth discussing with someone.



Paper Mario (2000)


Paper Mario is the calm pick. Fans call it charming and long, with plenty of side quests, and that is what you want when the only other thing to do is watch the tide. Plenty of the people choosing it have still not reached the end.
That is the second reason it wins. Several players said they never finished it as kids, or always meant to play it and never got around to it, and now they finally have the time. Being stranded forever is one way to clear a backlog.



The Elder Scrolls III: Morrowind (2002)


Morrowind is the pick for people doing the math. Fans say there is so much to do, with the expansions and years of fan mods, that it would take years to see it all. If the sentence is life, this is the longest book in the prison library.
First you have to survive the opening. Your new hero swings at a rat, misses again and again, and loses. Then come the cliff racers, and fans want those gone so badly that some install mods just to do it. By the time you can hit anything, you have earned your island.



GoldenEye 007 (1997)


GoldenEye gets picked for replay value. Players want something they can run again and again, and it has plenty of missions and more to find in them. It turns up next to Mario and Link on a lot of desert island lists.
It has one flaw as a last game: it needs your friends. Multiplayer is what everyone remembers, and the desert island has no bots and nobody around for Slappers Only. You could play against the coconuts, but one of them will pick Oddjob.



Castlevania: Symphony of the Night (1997)


Symphony of the Night fans barely need to be asked, because they already live this way. They go back to it every year or two on purpose, so the rule changes nothing about their calendar. Pickers point to the piles of secrets, and to how long it lasts once you try to find everything.
The hard part is keeping to one copy. Its biggest fans have bought it on several consoles and played every version. Giving up the spares would hurt more than giving up the rest of the shelf.



Doom (1993)


Doom pickers know exactly what they are doing. They are not choosing one game, they are choosing every level anyone ever made for it. Fans keep making new maps and mods, and players say that is why they never run out. This is the closest anyone gets to cheating on this question without being caught.
The rule gets bent further here. Plenty of players would rather take Doom II, and they quietly bring the add-ons too. Nobody has checked their bags yet.



Banjo-Kazooie (1998)


Banjo-Kazooie is the pick for people who cannot leave a level with anything still in it. Clearing all of it is the plan, and it can eat hours you swore you did not have. On a desert island that stops being a problem and becomes a career.
The music comes along for free. Fans say the soundtrack still sounds great, and that one tune can put them straight back in childhood. It also means you will be humming Bubblegloop Swamp at the seagulls by the end of the first week.



The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time (1998)


Ocarina of Time barely gets a reason. Ask why and players act like you asked why they kept the house. Fans replay it regularly and plan to keep doing that for the rest of their lives, and they say it takes them right back to being a kid.
Our favorite pickers are the ones who have never played it. Several people would take it to a desert island on its good name alone. That is a bold way to meet the Water Temple, but at least they have the time.



Super Mario 64 (1996)


Super Mario 64 is the quick answer. Players who pick it have finished it many times and would happily go again. For a lot of them, this game is their childhood, so the choice was over before the question ended.
The plan for forever is speedrunning. Pickers see endless room to get faster, which is a polite way of saying they will jump at the same wall until they retire. The camera is coming along too, and it will not be any nicer on the island.








