Retro Games That Didn't Live Up to the Hype

Retro Games That Didn't Live Up to the Hype

Retro Games That Didn't Live Up to the Hype

You read every preview, counted down the days and told your friends this one would change everything. Then you sat in front of the TV waiting for the good part to start. These are the retro games players say never matched all that talk, and a few of them are still great.

Metal Gear Solid 2: Sons of Liberty (2001)

Metal Gear Solid 2: Sons of Liberty gameplayMetal Gear Solid 2: Sons of Liberty box art

The trailers and the demo for Metal Gear Solid 2 showed you Solid Snake on a tanker. You bought the game, finished that opening, and spent about 80% of what was left as Raiden, a newcomer nobody had asked for. People got so mad. It may be the greatest prank ever pulled on players who had already paid.

Hideo Kojima meant it, since the game is about false information and he wanted the false trailers to match. Fans forgave him slowly. Years later many came around to the game and to Raiden, and some now call him the best hero in the series.

Metal Gear Solid 2: Sons of Liberty screenshot 1Metal Gear Solid 2: Sons of Liberty screenshot 2Metal Gear Solid 2: Sons of Liberty screenshot 3
Metal Gear Solid 2: Sons of Liberty gameplay.

Black & White (2001)

Black & White gameplayBlack & White box art

Black & White promised to make you a god, with a giant creature that learned from everything you did. Players were very hyped about that creature AI, and this was the same Peter Molyneux, a few years before the tree. Like his later games, it fell short of what he had promised.

The creature did learn, which was the trouble. You trained it to help your village, and it pooped on the village and kicked a man across the map. Being a god turned out to be mostly toilet training. Plenty of players loved and hated that creature in equal measure.

Black & White screenshot 1Black & White screenshot 2Black & White screenshot 3
Black & White gameplay.

Doom 3 (2004)

Doom 3 gameplayDoom 3 box art

Doom 3 made you switch between your gun and your flashlight, in the dark, on Mars, with demons around. This marine can haul a rocket launcher in his pants but cannot work out tape. One of the first mods taped the flashlight to the gun, and the lack of duct tape on Mars became the game's running joke.

The scares wore out fast as well. You walk into a room, the lights go out, and something comes out of the corner. Before long you were firing at the corner first and scaring the imps. Some fans still defend the flashlight as the thing that made it tense.

Doom 3 screenshot 1Doom 3 screenshot 2Doom 3 screenshot 3
Doom 3 gameplay.

Duke Nukem Forever (2011)

Duke Nukem Forever gameplayDuke Nukem Forever box art

Duke Nukem Forever spent about fifteen years in development. Kids who read the first preview had mortgages by the time it came out. A game that takes that long will always seem outdated at launch, and it went down as one of the biggest letdowns in gaming.

Duke had aged worse than the game. The crude humor people laughed at years before now came across as creepy, and that was a lot of waiting for a joke you had outgrown. A few fans did enjoy it for what it was, and nobody honest expected it to match all those years.

Duke Nukem Forever screenshot 1Duke Nukem Forever screenshot 2Duke Nukem Forever screenshot 3
Duke Nukem Forever gameplay.

The Legend of Zelda: Twilight Princess (2006)

The Legend of Zelda: Twilight Princess gameplayThe Legend of Zelda: Twilight Princess box art

The first Twilight Princess trailer is a core memory for a lot of Zelda fans, and some still call it one of the greatest reveals ever. The game opens with a long intro in Ordon Village. The chosen hero of legend begins his adventure with a goat job, and the goats are not impressed.

Then you turn into a wolf and hunt for Tears of Light, finding bugs in the dark. Nothing cools down a trailer like doing pest control as a dog. For some fans who rushed home with it, this was the first Zelda that let them down.

The Legend of Zelda: Twilight Princess screenshot 1The Legend of Zelda: Twilight Princess screenshot 2The Legend of Zelda: Twilight Princess screenshot 3
The Legend of Zelda: Twilight Princess gameplay.

Final Fantasy VIII (1999)

Final Fantasy VIII gameplayFinal Fantasy VIII box art

Final Fantasy VIII had to follow the huge success of Final Fantasy VII, and it got a ton of hype for it. Then you met the draw system, which many players still count as the game's biggest mistake. You stood in a fight pulling spells out of a monster a handful at a time, while the monster wondered if you had a plan.

The story had a surprise too. Partway through, your party finds out they all grew up in the same orphanage and forgot because of amnesia. You would think someone might have brought it up at lunch. Plenty of players still defend the odd systems, and the kids who loved it never stopped.

Final Fantasy VIII screenshot 1Final Fantasy VIII screenshot 2Final Fantasy VIII screenshot 3
Final Fantasy VIII gameplay.

Spore (2008)

Spore gameplaySpore box art

Spore had some of the most exciting demos players had ever seen. They watched Will Wright explain the game in long videos and followed every one for years. Life would grow from a single cell to the stars, and you would guide all of it.

What came out felt like a series of mini-games with little depth, and each stage was shallow. Creating life turned out to be easier than making it interesting. Darwin would have asked for a refund. For some players it is still the biggest letdown they ever had, and the last game they ever pre-ordered, though many admit they had fun with it.

Spore screenshot 1Spore screenshot 2Spore screenshot 3
Spore gameplay.

Fable (2004)

Fable gameplayFable box art

Before Fable came out, Peter Molyneux talked about a world where a tree you touched in your childhood would grow with you over the years. That tree is the most famous seedling in gaming, and it still hasn't sprouted. The game that arrived came up well short of the promises. You could get fat, though, so nobody can say the world didn't react to you.

Fable was a good game with a hype problem. It had been sold as somewhere to spend ages, and the main complaint was how short it was. You could live a hero's entire life in about a weekend, which is a lot to ask of a weekend. Some players never let themselves get hyped for a game again.

Fable screenshot 1Fable screenshot 2Fable screenshot 3
Fable gameplay.

The Elder Scrolls III: Morrowind (2002)

The Elder Scrolls III: Morrowind gameplayThe Elder Scrolls III: Morrowind box art

Morrowind has devoted fans who will tell you it was never bettered, and plenty of newcomers tried for hours on that advice and could not get into it. You start out with an excruciatingly slow walk, and your speed has to be levelled up before you move any faster. Your sword can pass straight through a rat, and dice rolled behind the scenes still call it a miss. The rat has never felt so confident.

Then came the cliff racers, flying pests that have gone down as one of the worst things in any game. For some players the best moment in Morrowind was the mod that removed them.

The Elder Scrolls III: Morrowind screenshot 1The Elder Scrolls III: Morrowind screenshot 2The Elder Scrolls III: Morrowind screenshot 3
The Elder Scrolls III: Morrowind gameplay.

Half-Life (1998)

Half-Life gameplayHalf-Life box art

Half-Life carries the heavy label of the shooter that changed everything. Players who came to it late, after years of that praise, often found a dated game and waited for a magic that never clicked. Your friends tell you it was revolutionary, and you are stuck in an air vent wondering which part.

Fans of the game mostly agree on the ending. Near the finish you land in Xen, the alien world almost nobody likes, and the game turns into a run of first person jumping puzzles. A doctorate in physics is no help when you can't see your own feet.

Half-Life screenshot 1Half-Life screenshot 2Half-Life screenshot 3
Half-Life gameplay.

The Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion (2006)

The Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion gameplayThe Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion box art

People were blown away by the promo shots of Oblivion's character faces. Those faces went on to be known as the potato faces. The main quest then sent you through Oblivion gates, and every trip through one looked the same and felt like a chore. Hell is pouring into the countryside, and you would still rather go pick flowers.

Everything in the world levelled up with you, too. Late in a save, roadside bandits wore full Daedric and glass armor worth thousands, then stopped you to demand pocket change. Nobody in the history of crime has needed a career change less.

The Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion screenshot 1The Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion screenshot 2The Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion screenshot 3
The Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion gameplay.

Related articles