Switch vs Wii U

Switch vs Wii U

Switch vs Wii U

Satoru Iwata halved his own salary in 2011 and again in 2014 while Nintendo's sales fell. He oversaw the Switch through the final months of his life and died on July 11, 2015. Players later found NES Golf, a game Iwata programmed himself, hidden inside the Switch. It only opened if the system clock said July 11 and you moved the Joy-Con the way he moved his hands in his Nintendo Direct videos. Nintendo has never confirmed it.

Wii U owners took the Switch personally too. They had stuck with their console through the long gaps between games, then watched those same games turn up on a new machine. Everyone who owned one had to decide whether to keep it or trade it in, and every group of Nintendo friends had an opinion on Switch vs Wii U.

Mario Kart 8 Deluxe has sold 71.08 million copies on the Switch, about five for every Wii U ever sold. Wii U owners say that number only counts the people who missed out. In this article we will find out who really won.

The Switch went where the GamePad couldn't

Super Mario 3D World
Super Mario 3D World.

People liked the GamePad, right up until they walked too far from the console and it stopped working. Reggie Fils-Aimé of Nintendo of America named that as a common complaint, and it prompted Nintendo to design a home console you could take anywhere. Wii U owners still say the range was too short, and that the GamePad was a portable tied to the TV. The Wii U's world ended about where the kitchen did.

The Switch has a 6.2-inch screen, the same size as the GamePad, with the console built in behind it. Players took it on the train and into bed, and some say most of their hours are in handheld mode. They call the Wii U the prototype and the Switch the console Nintendo wanted to make the first time. The Switch wins this one easily.

Breath of the Wild ran better on the Switch

The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild
The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild.

Breath of the Wild was once planned for release in 2015. It kept slipping, and it launched for both the Wii U and the Switch on March 3, 2017, as the last Nintendo-published game on the Wii U. Players still have to remind people that it was a Wii U game first.

Both versions run at 30 frames per second. Docked, the Switch runs at 900p, and the Wii U stops at 720p. The sales gap was far wider, with 34.06 million copies on the Switch and 1.70 million on the Wii U. The Wii U threw its own retirement party and the Switch ate the cake.

Almost every great Wii U game moved to the Switch

Mario Kart 8
Mario Kart 8.

Most of the Wii U's exclusive games were ported to the Switch, and that is the hardest fact in this fight. Mario Kart 8 is the best-selling Wii U game at 8.46 million, and more than half of Wii U owners own a copy. It came back on the Switch in April 2017 as Mario Kart 8 Deluxe, with the DLC and a revamped battle mode, and critics called it the definitive version.

Players say the best games all left, and that this made the old console close to obsolete. Bayonetta 2 reached the Switch in 2018, and Xenoblade Chronicles X followed in 2025 as a remaster. The Switch wins it with the Wii U's own games.

Wii U owners refused to pay twice

Donkey Kong Country: Tropical Freeze
Donkey Kong Country: Tropical Freeze.

The ports were great news for anyone new to these games. Fans who had backed the Wii U already owned them, and plenty refused to buy them again. Players still grumble about what the ports cost, and Tropical Freeze comes up often.

Nintendo was happy to sell you Mario Kart 8 a second time. A lot of Wii U owners decided one copy was plenty, and this round goes to their wallets.

The big publishers left the Wii U and came back for the Switch

The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim
The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim.

Early Wii U sales were weak, and Electronic Arts and Ubisoft pulled their support near the end of its first year. Players remember a console with very little from outside Nintendo. The name did not help, since the marketing failed to separate it from the original Wii.

Nintendo learned from it. The Switch uses an existing chip so that developers could port games easily, and its first trailer showed Skyrim. Nintendo also tried to bring indie developers to the Wii U at E3 2015, but by then it was already seen as a failure. Players agree third-party support on the Switch was much better, and it's a clear win.

The GamePad felt better than a pair of Joy-Con

Super Mario Maker
Super Mario Maker.

The Wii U finally gets a win. Critics praised the comfortable feel of the GamePad, and players still say it beats Joy-Con. Players call Joy-Con tiny and uncomfortable.

Then there is drift, when a stick moves your character on its own. A class action lawsuit followed in 2019, and a leaked memo told North American customer service to fix drifting Joy-Con for free. The GamePad has its own faults: a short battery life and an 854 × 480 screen against the Switch's 720p. Your hands will still pick the GamePad.

Two screens made the Wii U Zeldas better

The Legend of Zelda: The Wind Waker HD
The Legend of Zelda: The Wind Waker HD.

Players loved the second screen most in Zelda. You looked down to change items or check the map while the game kept running on the TV. Fans say it made both HD Zeldas feel far smoother.

Wind Waker HD never came to the Switch. Neither did Twilight Princess HD, and Nintendo Land stayed on the Wii U too. Players name those games and ZombiU as proof the idea worked. The Switch has one screen at a time, so the Wii U keeps this round.

The Wii U plays your whole Nintendo shelf

Super Mario Galaxy
Super Mario Galaxy.

The Wii U is backward compatible with Wii software and accessories, so your old discs still work. Its Virtual Console sold NES and Super NES games. Game Boy Advance games came next, followed by Nintendo 64 and Nintendo DS games. GameCube games take a homebrew application. Players call it one of the best ways to keep Nintendo's older games in one box.

The Switch uses cartridges and is not backward compatible, and players count that against it. The Wii U store did stop selling new content on March 27, 2023, which hurts. The discs on your shelf still work, and that makes this one a Wii U win.

A Wii U game costs about a third of its Switch port

The Legend of Zelda: Twilight Princess HD
The Legend of Zelda: Twilight Princess HD.

Check the sold prices and the Wii U is a bargain. A loose Mario Kart 8 goes for $10, and a loose Mario Kart 8 Deluxe goes for $32. Pikmin 3 is $10 against $35 for the Switch's Deluxe version. Xenoblade Chronicles X is $13 against $38 for the Definitive Edition. Players say Wii U games tend to be cheap, and the numbers back them up.

The Switch copy holds more value if you sell. The games that stayed behind cost more, with Wind Waker HD at $45 and Twilight Princess HD at $100. Buy a Wii U for the cheap games, and grab those two before they climb.

Which one wins?

Put the numbers side by side and the Switch wins by a mile, with the bigger library and a screen that leaves the house. That changes nothing about the console under your TV. If you finished Wind Waker HD on a Wii U, or shared one pair of Joy-Con on a long bus ride, that console is yours and no sales chart gets a say. The specs were never the point. What you keep is the memories you made with it, and those never needed a port.

Related articles