Wii U vs Wii

Wii U vs Wii

Wii U vs Wii

When Nintendo announced the name Wii in 2006, it said people all over the world could remember it, and it ended the thought with two words: "No confusion." Six years later, one of its own marketing managers admitted that some people had mistaken the Wii U GamePad for an accessory for the existing Wii.

Families who had been bowling in the living room since launch stood in shops trying to work out what they were looking at. Anyone who owned a Wii got asked about it at dinner, and the whole table ended up arguing over Wii U vs Wii.

The Wii sold over 101 million units. The Wii U sold 13.56 million, about one for every seven. Wii U owners shrug at that number and say sales never played a game for anyone. In this article we will find out who really won.

The Wii got your grandparents off the couch

Wii Sports
Wii Sports.

The Wii wins this one easily. Wii Sports came in the box in most regions, and it reached 82.90 million copies with the pack-ins counted. It drew in people who typically did not play video games, and those people made the console.

Mario Kart Wii added 37.38 million. The Wii U's best seller, Mario Kart 8, sold 8.46 million.

Players say the crowd who bought a Wii for bowling never came back for the Wii U. Their old console still worked. Somewhere a grandmother is still undefeated at tennis.

The Wii U's name fooled the Wii's own customers

Nintendo Land
Nintendo Land.

Nintendo had spent six years putting Wii in front of everything, from Wii Fit to the Wii Remote. Players say Wii U looked like one more of those, and plenty of them thought it was a tablet add-on for the console they already had.

The Basic Set cost $299.99, which is a lot for what looked like an accessory. The Deluxe Set came with Nintendo Land to show the idea off, but you had to buy the console first.

Nintendo said later packaging would show the console and the GamePad together. Reggie Fils-Aimé, then head of Nintendo of America, went on to blame the lack of clarity around the GamePad for part of the failure, and Nintendo changed how it marketed the Switch because of it.

The GamePad was the Wii U's best idea

Super Mario Maker
Super Mario Maker.

The GamePad has a 6.2-inch touchscreen and can stream the game from the console. That is Off-TV Play. Someone else can have the TV while you keep playing, and owners still bring it up as the thing they loved most.

Super Mario Maker is the best use of that screen. You edit your levels on the GamePad with a finger or the stylus, and no Wii Remote could do that.

The battery was the weak spot. One launch review got 3.5 hours out of it, and Nintendo later sold a bigger pack that lasts between five and eight hours. The Switch kept the idea, which tells you who won this round.

The Wii stopped at 480p and the Wii U went to 1080p

The Legend of Zelda: The Wind Waker HD
The Legend of Zelda: The Wind Waker HD.

The Wii's best picture is 480p over component cables. The Wii U outputs up to 1080p over HDMI, and The Wind Waker HD looks wonderful on it. Players who go back to the big Wii games on a modern TV say they look like a blurry mess.

The Wii U doesn't upscale Wii games. Players still say they look better through its HDMI port, and it works with a modern TV straight out of the box.

Every Wii game runs on a Wii U

Super Mario Galaxy
Super Mario Galaxy.

The Wii U is compatible with all Wii games and with the Wii Remote, Nunchuk and Balance Board. Your old discs and controllers keep working, so Super Mario Galaxy plays the way you remember. Players say that leaves little reason to buy a Wii over a Wii U.

You play them in Wii Mode, and the GamePad's own controls don't work there. You still need a Wii controller.

Neither console sells downloads any more. The Wii Shop closed in January 2019, and purchases on the Wii U eShop ended on March 27, 2023.

Only the first Wii plays GameCube games

Super Smash Bros. Melee
Super Smash Bros. Melee.

This round goes to the Wii. The launch console has four GameCube controller ports and two memory card slots under its top panel, and it plays all GameCube software. Super Smash Bros. Melee runs with a real GameCube controller in your hands.

The Wii U has no such ports and can't play GameCube games without help. Players point this out every time someone asks which one to buy.

Check the model first. The revised Wii that reached North America on October 23, 2011 and the Wii Mini both dropped GameCube support.

A hacked Wii U plays all three

Super Mario 3D World
Super Mario 3D World.

A homebrew app gives the Wii U its GameCube support back, and players call a modded one the best deal in the family. Super Mario Sunshine and Super Mario 3D World can sit on the same console, and you can play on the GamePad like a handheld.

The Wii can be modded too and players say it is easy. It still tops out at Wii games, so the Wii U takes this one.

The Wii U got fewer games than any Nintendo console

Bayonetta 2
Bayonetta 2.

By late July 2016, the US had 39 first-party and 118 third-party Wii U games on disc, the lowest for any Nintendo console. Fils-Aimé also named the lack of third-party support as a reason it failed.

Players say third parties never loved the Wii much either, and it was the least powerful of the major home consoles of its day. It still sold 921.85 million games to the Wii U's 103.60 million. The Wii wins on size.

Players still name Bayonetta 2 when they make the case for the Wii U. Quality was never its problem.

Most Wii U games moved to the Switch

Mario Kart 8
Mario Kart 8.

Most of the Wii U's exclusive games were ported to the Switch, and Mario Kart 8 got there on April 28, 2017. Players say you can skip the Wii U for those games now, and buy one for the Wii library and the Virtual Console.

The Wii kept more of its identity. Plenty of games built around pointing and waving a Wii Remote never left, and that makes a Wii game feel more like a Wii game than a Wii U game feels like a Wii U game.

Rare Wii games sell for the most

Rhythm Heaven Fever
Rhythm Heaven Fever.

A loose copy of Rhythm Heaven Fever typically sells for $113, and Metroid Prime Trilogy for $92. The Wii U has one game near them: Twilight Princess HD at $100. Game & Wario comes next at $60.

The everyday games tell the same story. Wii Sports and Mario Kart Wii each go for $29, while Mario Kart 8 sells for $10, Xenoblade Chronicles X for $13 and Bayonetta 2 for $15. The Wii U sold about a seventh as many consoles, and players still call its games cheap second hand. Hold on to that Wii Sports disc.

Which one wins?

Line up the features and the Wii U wins, with HD, the GamePad and the Wii's whole library on top. None of that settles anything. If the Wii was the console your whole family crowded around, it stays yours, and the same goes for a Wii U and the first level you ever built in Super Mario Maker. A console is the memories you made with it, and nobody can sell you better ones.

Related articles