Wii vs Xbox 360

Wii vs Xbox 360

Wii vs Xbox 360

Microsoft could have had the Wii Remote first. A company called Gyration, which made wireless motion-sensing computer mice, pitched its motion controller to Microsoft and Sony, and both said no. Nintendo licensed motion-sensing patents from Gyration in 2001, the same year work on the Wii Remote began.

Five years later, every Christmas list in the country came down to Wii vs Xbox 360. The kids wanted Halo, the grandparents wanted bowling, and a lot of houses ended up with one of each.

The Wii shipped 101.63 million consoles and the Xbox 360 sold about 84 million. Xbox fans shrug at that lead, because plenty of those Wiis went into a closet once the bowling got old. In this article we will find out who really won.

The Wii cost less and worked on your old TV

Wii Play
Wii Play.

The Xbox 360 had a head start. It came out on November 22, 2005, in $299 and $399 models. The Wii followed on November 19, 2006, at $249.99, with Wii Sports in the box.

Players say the low price was a big part of why it sold. The Wii also topped out at 480p, which meant the old TV in the living room was all it needed. The Wii wins this round.

The Xbox 360 looked like a new generation and the Wii did not

Gears of War
Gears of War.

The Xbox 360 could put out 720p and 1080p. The Wii was the least powerful of the major home consoles of its generation, and players still say it plainly: the Wii was not HD and sat a generation behind.

Gears of War showed the gap. It was the best-selling game on the 360 in 2006, with 3 million copies. Plug a Wii into a new HDTV and players say the picture turns blurry and jagged. The Xbox takes this one easily.

Wii Sports got everybody off the couch

Wii Sports
Wii Sports.

Wii Sports reached 82.90 million copies with the bundled ones counted, which makes it the fourth-best-selling video game of all time. Wii Fit added 22.67 million more, and its Balance Board even worked as a bathroom scale.

Players remember the Wii as the console that came out when people came over, and it did wonderfully with people who never touched games. Nobody's aunt ever picked up a Gears of War controller at Christmas and asked for one more round. The Wii wins here without breaking a sweat.

A lot of Wiis ended up in a closet

Super Mario Galaxy 2
Super Mario Galaxy 2.

Then the party ended. Players remember the motion control novelty wearing off and the console going quiet under the TV or into the closet, sometimes after a month or two.

Microsoft had numbers to rub this in. By March 2008 it said the Xbox 360 had 7.5 games per console in the US, against 3.5 for the Wii. It was Microsoft's own count, so take it with a pinch of salt, but the 360 was the console people kept feeding. This round goes to Xbox.

Halo and Call of Duty lived on the Xbox 360

Halo 3
Halo 3.

Halo 3 grossed US$170 million on its first day, and that September the Xbox 360 outsold the Wii in North America. Players who wanted competitive shooters went to the 360, and the Wii was never that kind of console.

Call of Duty 4 shows how far behind Wii owners were. It reached the Xbox 360 on November 5, 2007, and the Wii on November 10, 2009. For two years a Wii owner could wait or go bowling. Xbox wins this round.

Xbox Live made Wii online look like a joke

Mario Kart Wii
Mario Kart Wii.

The Wii was Nintendo's first console with native Internet connectivity, and Mario Kart Wii supported up to 12 participants, so it was a real step for Nintendo. Players still call Wii online a joke.

Xbox Live cost US$59.99 a year, and people paid. More than one million people played Halo 3 on Xbox Live in the first twenty hours. Nintendo switched off online multiplayer for Wii games in May 2014. This one is not close.

The Wii got the worst version of every port

Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare
Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare.

Players say that on a game made for several consoles, the Wii version was usually the worst one, a cut-down copy of the 360 game. Then came the shovelware, which means cheap games made in a hurry to cash in. Players agree the Wii had piles of it.

Third-party support collapsed in the Wii's later years. The Xbox 360 wins this, and the Wii still owes everyone an apology for the minigame collections.

Super Mario Galaxy is the Wii's trump card

Super Mario Galaxy
Super Mario Galaxy.

Super Mario Galaxy scored 97 out of 100 on Metacritic. When GameRankings closed in 2019 it was the highest-rated game on the site, and it sold 12.80 million copies. Mario Kart Wii sold 37.38 million.

Players who stuck with the console say the best Wii games were as good as anything that generation had. When a Wii owner needs one game to end the argument, this is it. The Wii takes the round.

The Xbox 360 pad was better, except for aiming

Metroid Prime 3: Corruption
Metroid Prime 3: Corruption.

Players rate the Xbox 360 controller among the best pads ever made. Plenty of them say Wii motion controls were more gimmick than game, and that a normal controller would have done the job better.

The pointer is the exception. In Metroid Prime 3: Corruption you move with the Nunchuk and aim with the Wii Remote, and players say aiming with the pointer beats an analog stick. The first wrist straps could break under heavy use and send the remote flying, and Nintendo replaced them for free. Nobody ever put an Xbox 360 pad through a TV by accident. The 360 wins on points.

The Red Ring of Death made the Wii the safe buy

Mass Effect
Mass Effect.

A 2009 study by the warranty company SquareTrade put the Xbox 360's failure rate at 23.7% and the Wii's at 2.7%. Players remember the Red Ring of Death as the 360's big hardware problem, and some went through console after console.

Repairs and replacements cost Microsoft US$1.15 billion, and it added a three-year warranty. That helped, but Mass Effect was no use to you while your console was in the post. The Wii wins this round.

Xbox Live Arcade had the indies and the Wii had the classics

Castle Crashers
Castle Crashers.

Players rate the 360's download store as the better one for new games. Braid scored 93/100 on Metacritic, the top-rated game on Xbox Live Arcade, and Castle Crashers sold over 2.6 million there by the end of 2011.

The Wii had the past. Its Virtual Console had NES, Super Nintendo, Genesis and Neo Geo games, and those downloads passed ten million by early 2008. Players used it to catch up on old games they had missed. Retro fans will pick the Wii and everyone else the 360, so we call it a draw. Both stores are closed now: the Wii Shop in January 2019 and the Xbox 360 Marketplace on July 29, 2024.

Kinect was Microsoft admitting the Wii was right

Wii Sports Resort
Wii Sports Resort.

Microsoft felt pressure from the Wii, and the Kinect team studied how people with Wiis used the system at home. Nintendo was already selling MotionPlus with Wii Sports Resort in June 2009. Kinect arrived on November 4, 2010, with no controller at all.

It sold eight million units in its first 60 days and took the Guinness World Record for fastest-selling consumer electronics device. Only an estimated 20% of the 55 million Xbox 360 owners bought one, and players see it as Microsoft chasing the Wii's audience. Microsoft got the record and Nintendo won the argument.

The Wii faded fast and the Xbox 360 kept going in America

Just Dance
Just Dance.

The Wii passed the Xbox 360 in the US in June 2008, and it looked over. Then players watched the Wii go quiet years before the 360 did. The Xbox 360 was the best-selling console in the United States for 32 consecutive months, from January 2011 to October 2013, and by the end of 2014 it had passed the Wii there for good.

Nintendo stopped making the Wii in October 2013, and Microsoft kept the 360 going until April 2016. The last Xbox 360 discs came out in 2018, FIFA 19 and Just Dance 2019, but the Wii got a few more Just Dance sequels after that. Xbox wins America, and the Wii wins the dance floor.

A modded Wii is one of the best cheap retro machines

Xenoblade Chronicles
Xenoblade Chronicles.

Early Wii models play GameCube games out of the box. Add The Homebrew Channel and players say a modded Wii is a great little machine for older consoles, with Nintendo games up to the GameCube in one place.

Players mod the Xbox 360 too, but that is a hobby for its own games. For a retro fan on a budget, the Wii wins this easily.

The Wii wins on resale

Rhythm Heaven Fever
Rhythm Heaven Fever.

Nintendo games hold their value, and the Wii is no exception. A loose copy of Rhythm Heaven Fever typically sells for $113, Metroid Prime Trilogy for $92 and Mario Kart Wii for $29.

The 360's biggest games are cheap. Halo 3 typically sells for $7, Call of Duty 4 for $7 and Gears of War for $5. One Metroid Prime Trilogy buys about thirteen copies of Halo 3.

Which one wins?

The Wii wins on paper, with more consoles sold and older games worth more today. None of that settles anything. If you spent your teens on Xbox Live, the 360 was your console and a sales chart can't take it from you. The same goes for the family that bowled every Christmas. What made either one special was the memories you made with it, on the couch or through a headset.

Related articles