Screenshots of the best Fatal Frame games

7 Best Fatal Frame Games

Fatal Frame showed up on the PlayStation 2 in 2001, after the success of Silent Hill pushed Tecmo's Makoto Shibata and Keisuke Kikuchi to try a horror series of their own. The idea still sounds odd today. You get no gun and no sword. All you have is an old camera, and you hurt a ghost by taking its picture. The most damage comes when the ghost is very close, so the game pays you to hold still while something awful comes at your face.

The series was never a big seller, and it had sold a little over one million copies worldwide as of April 2014. Europe knows it as Project Zero. It moved from the PS2 to Nintendo hardware, and the fourth game took 15 years to get an official English release.

We surveyed players across every console the series reached. Spin-offs and remakes count as their own games. Here are the 7 best Fatal Frame games.

The best Fatal Frame games
0

7. Project Zero 2: Wii Edition (2012)

Project Zero 2: Wii Edition gameplay on Fatal FrameProject Zero 2: Wii Edition box art

This is the first remake of the second game, made for the Wii. It was released in Japan and PAL regions but not in North America, which is why this entry carries the European name. Shibata and Kikuchi came back and reworked the gameplay based on Mask of the Lunar Eclipse, with an over-the-shoulder camera similar to Resident Evil 4. A ghost hand may appear and attack now, and Mio has to break free if it catches her. There are six endings, two of them new. Haunted House is a new first-person on-rails mode that you reach through a friendly ghost named Kureha.

Wii owners who like horror tend to list it right next to Silent Hill: Shattered Memories, and they call it amazing. It came up less than any other game on this list, and missing North America cannot have helped.

Project Zero 2: Wii Edition screenshot 1Project Zero 2: Wii Edition screenshot 2
0

6. Spirit Camera: The Cursed Memoir (2012)

Spirit Camera: The Cursed Memoir gameplay on Fatal Frame

The first pitch for this 3DS spin-off was a port of an earlier Fatal Frame. Then-president Satoru Iwata vetoed that because he wanted something more original, so the 3DS itself became the Camera Obscura. Ghosts appear in your real surroundings through augmented reality, and you have to keep them in focus as they move. The story is about a cursed book that steals the faces of those who read from it. Kikuchi wanted to call it Dr Asou's Spirit Camera, after the Camera Obscura's creator, but felt the reference was too obscure for most players.

The booklet in the box is necessary to play, so check for it before you buy a used copy. This may be the only ghost story on the list that a dim lamp can ruin. Players are split: some call it a cool spin-off, others call it boring. Critics were mixed to negative, with complaints about the lack of content and the AR.

0

5. Fatal Frame: Mask of the Lunar Eclipse (2023)

Fatal Frame: Mask of the Lunar Eclipse gameplay on Fatal FrameFatal Frame: Mask of the Lunar Eclipse box art

The fourth game came out on Wii in Japan in 2008, the first in the series on a Nintendo console. Tecmo made it with Grasshopper Manufacture and Nintendo, and Goichi Suda was co-director and co-writer. Ruka Minazuki and Misaki Asou lost their memories after a secret ritual, and Choshiro Kirishima is the detective who rescued them. All of it plays out on abandoned Rogetsu Island. This is where the camera moved to an over-the-shoulder view, and fan complaints about earlier games got the characters' speed increased.

A European release was cancelled and no North American release was planned. A three-person team made a fan translation, and players pointed each other to that English patch for years. The official worldwide release came in 2023, with updated graphics and new unlockable costumes, and that is the year on this entry. It got mixed reviews due to the age of some gameplay elements, while the scenario and art design got praise.

0

4. Fatal Frame: Maiden of Black Water (2014)

Fatal Frame: Maiden of Black Water gameplay on Fatal FrameFatal Frame: Maiden of Black Water box art

Kikuchi proposed this one when he saw that the Wii U GamePad could be used as the Camera Obscura. Three protagonists get drawn into supernatural events on the fictional Hikami Mountain, tied to an ancient ritual to seal away the Black Water. It is the first game in the series set in the 21st century, and it added the ability to dodge or break free from a ghost's grip. A wetness meter tracks how damp your character gets. Being wet increases the camera's damage. It also brings more ghosts and harder hits. The idea was initially inspired by the sweating mechanic from Dead or Alive 5, one of the stranger family trees in horror.

Players keep coming back to the GamePad, which they call a perfect fit for the camera. The 2021 remaster reached other consoles and adjusted the camera for regular controllers, but it saw mixed responses, and the main criticisms were its controls and a lack of frightening elements.

Fatal Frame: Maiden of Black Water screenshot 1Fatal Frame: Maiden of Black Water screenshot 2
0

3. Fatal Frame III: The Tormented (2005)

Fatal Frame III: The Tormented gameplay on Fatal FrameFatal Frame III: The Tormented box art

You play three characters here: Rei Kurosawa, Kei Amakura and Miku Hinasaki from the first game. All three lost loved ones and get drawn into the Manor of Sleep, a haunted place set in their dreams. Each has different strengths, such as stronger attack or stealth. Outside the manor you are back in the real world, and later in the game passive ghosts start appearing in Rei's apartment. Shibata based the concept on his own nightmares, with the theme of horror emerging from the familiar. It was planned as the series' final entry for PS2, and it is the one PS2 game of the three with no Xbox port.

Critics praised its atmosphere and story, though many faulted a lack of innovation in the gameplay. Players are warmer about it. A good number call it their favorite or the best in the series, and they often name it together with the second game as the scariest of the lot.

Fatal Frame III: The Tormented screenshot 1Fatal Frame III: The Tormented screenshot 2
0

2. Fatal Frame (2001)

Fatal Frame gameplay on Fatal FrameFatal Frame box art

You play Miku Hinasaki, who searches the haunted Himuro Mansion for her brother Mafuyu. Ghosts can only be fought with the Camera Obscura, an antique camera that switches the view to first person. Shibata got the concept from his own dreams and from encounters with what he felt were supernatural occurrences. Japanese horror and war movies inspired the atmosphere, and some parts were cut for graphic content. In North America, it was marketed as being based on a true story, which is a bold thing to print on a box about a ghost mansion. Fatal Frame Special Edition, an expanded Xbox port, followed on November 27, 2002 with graphical upgrades and new ghosts. It also has a third ending.

Players rank it among the scariest games they have ever played. They also treat the first three as a set, and that is how the series usually gets recommended.

Fatal Frame screenshot 1
0

1. Fatal Frame II: Crimson Butterfly (2003)

Fatal Frame II: Crimson Butterfly gameplay on Fatal FrameFatal Frame II: Crimson Butterfly box art

Twin sisters Mio and Mayu Amakura get trapped in a ghost-filled village, cursed by a failed ritual that they are being forced to re-enact. You play Mio. Mayu helps find puzzle clues, but ghosts can attack her too. The game ends if either twin takes too much damage. Shibata and Kikuchi returned, along with writer Tsuyoshi Iuchi. The first game had been too scary for some players to complete, so the team set out to create an interesting storyline that would pull people to the end.

It scored 81 out of 100 on Metacritic and was later called a classic of the survival horror genre. More players named it than any other Fatal Frame game, more than twice as many as the first game, and they call it the best in the series or the scariest horror game they played. An Xbox port followed in 2004 with a first person camera option and a new ending. The 2026 Remake from Team Ninja has too few player opinions to rank yet.

Fatal Frame II: Crimson Butterfly screenshot 1Fatal Frame II: Crimson Butterfly screenshot 2

Which one to play

There you have it, the whole list of the best Fatal Frame games. The top three are all from the PS2 years, and players still name them when they talk about the scariest horror on that console.

If you are unsure, start with Crimson Butterfly. For the roots of the series, play the first Fatal Frame. If you want more than one character to play, go with The Tormented. If you still have a Wii U, pick Maiden of Black Water and use the GamePad. On a modern console, try Mask of the Lunar Eclipse. For a hidden pick, find Spirit Camera with its booklet.

Related articles