Mario has been flat since 2000. The first Paper Mario put two-dimensional character cut-outs inside three-dimensional backgrounds, and that look has followed the series from the N64 all the way to the Switch. Under the paper was a turn-based role-playing game, a strange job for a plumber famous for jumping on things. It worked, and the jokes were better than anyone expected from a Mario game. Here are the 7 best Paper Mario games.
The series has changed its mind a few times about what it wants to be. Early on it was a pure role-playing game, then it became a side-scroller for one game, and later stickers and paint took over the battles. Longtime fans still feel the series lost something along the way, so this list has a few arguments in it. It also has the crossover that dropped Paper Mario into the Mario & Luigi series.

7. Mario & Luigi: Paper Jam (2015)


Paper Jam is the fifth installment in the Mario & Luigi series and a crossover with Paper Mario. Mario and Luigi meet Paper Mario, then get back to Peach's Castle to find that two princesses have been kidnapped by both Bowsers. Two Bowsers is an excellent way to double the paperwork. AlphaDream made the game while Intelligent Systems oversaw production. The team first considered a character like Bowser for the third hero, then settled on another variant of Mario himself. The papercraft models were based on shrines found at Japanese festivals.
Critics felt the game failed to use the crossover to its fullest potential, and Mario & Luigi fans often put it near the bottom of that series. It still has its supporters, who enjoy the paper look and the battles. Think of it as the guest star of this list. It plays like Mario & Luigi, with a paper friend along for the ride.


6. Paper Mario: Color Splash (2016)


Color Splash came to the Wii U in October 2016 and gave Mario a paint hammer for solving coloring-themed puzzles. The paint idea came from Atsushi Isano, the director at Intelligent Systems, and it was built to take advantage of the Wii U GamePad. Mario collects the Big Paint Stars, and each one tells a little more about an attack on Port Prisma.
Fans did not take the reveal well. They criticized its similarities to Sticker Star and the decision to keep that game's action-adventure formula. Reviews on release were kinder about its comedic writing and soundtrack, though the combat got much the same criticism as its predecessor. It keeps a small group of fans, and some of them name it among their favourites on the Wii U.


5. Paper Mario: The Origami King (2020)


The Origami King moved the series to the Switch and changed the traditional linear gameplay to an open world format. Nintendo meant to announce it at E3 2020, but the expo was cancelled and the game was revealed on its own. Mario lands with Olivia in Whispering Woods near Toad Town, where many of the Toads have been folded into origami by the Folded Soldiers. Battles use ring-style combat, and boss fights put the enemy in the center with Mario on the outside. Bobby's character arc drew critical praise.
It had sold three million copies by September 2020, two months after release, which made it the fastest-selling game in the series. Plenty of players had a great time with it, but the battles are the sticking point. Many say the combat wears thin, and they would trade the rings for the old system.
4. Paper Mario: Sticker Star (2012)


Sticker Star was the first game in the series on a handheld, and it is the one that split the fans. Allies were cut due to complications with the sticker mechanics, and there was a large decrease in characters with unique designs. Part of that came from the top. Shigeru Miyamoto asked the developers to finish it with only characters from the Super Mario world, and he had them change the battles because he thought they were too similar to The Thousand-Year Door. Mario and Kersti go looking for the Royal Stickers, each one guarded by a boss.
Reviews were generally favorable, though critics went after the unbalanced difficulty and the minimal story. Players are much harder on it, and many point to it as the moment the series went wrong. It still ranks here because so many 3DS owners played it, and a smaller group loved it. Fourth place is the best revenge it could ask for.


3. Super Paper Mario (2007)


Super Paper Mario is the odd one out. The earlier games are turn-based, and this one mixes role-playing with side-scrolling, with Mario flipping between 2D and 3D. Director Ryota Kawade changed the traditional concept with the intention of surprising fans. Luigi can jump the highest and Peach can hover, but only Mario can flip. Flashbacks tell the story of two lovers, Blumiere and Timpani. More than 4.23 million copies had sold by 2014, and critics have since regarded it as one of the best games on the Wii.
Its fans call it underrated, and they know it is a different kind of Paper Mario. Players also love one gag early on. A character asks Mario to save the world, and if you keep saying no, the game gives you a game over. Mario, it turns out, is a few refusals away from retirement.


2. Paper Mario (2000)


The first Paper Mario came out in Japan in 2000 and internationally in 2001. Nintendo had planned to have Square make it, but Square was busy with Final Fantasy VII, so Intelligent Systems developed the game instead. Mario sets out to rescue the Star Spirits, starting with Eldstar in the fortress of the four Koopa Bros. and then Mamar in the Dry, Dry Desert. Yuka Tsujiyoko wrote all of the game's compositions, with arrangements of Super Mario themes by Koji Kondo. GameSpot named it the best Nintendo 64 game of 2001.
Players remember it with a lot of love, and many still call it one of their favourites. They talk about the charm and the humor first. Its sequel drew nearly twice as many players, but second place on this list is no insult, since this game wrote the rules the rest of the list keeps arguing about. You can play it today on Nintendo Classics.


1. Paper Mario: The Thousand-Year Door (2004)


The Thousand-Year Door came to the GameCube in 2004, and a remake followed on the Switch in 2024. Battles happen on a stage, and a spectating audience reacts to how well you perform. Jump on or hammer an enemy before the fight and you get a First Strike. Every 100 Star Points you level up and pick a stat to raise. The story also rotates to short parts where you play as Princess Peach and Bowser, while Mario collects the Crystal Stars and heads for the X-Nauts' base. Vivian, one of your partners, is a transgender woman in the original Japanese, and the initial English script removed any mention of it.
It won Console Role-Playing Game of the Year at the 8th Annual Interactive Achievement Awards, and it has been cited as one of the greatest video games ever made. Nearly twice as many players named it as named the N64 original. Many of them call it one of their favourite games of all time, and the writing is what they keep coming back to.


Which one to play
There you have it, the whole list of the best Paper Mario games. The top three are as good as Mario gets outside his platformers, and even the games at the bottom have good jokes.
If you are unsure, play The Thousand-Year Door, and the Switch remake is the easiest way to get it. If you want the traditional start, play the first Paper Mario on Nintendo Classics. If you want a platformer with a story, go for Super Paper Mario. If you are a Mario & Luigi fan, try Paper Jam. If you like puzzles more than levelling up, The Origami King is your pick. For a hidden pick, find Color Splash on the Wii U.






