10 Most Expensive Xbox Games

The best Xbox games

Original Xbox games are mostly cheap. A bare disc only has to sell for about $40 to make this list, and just four games top $100. These are the 10 most expensive Xbox games.

Every price below is a real eBay sale made between May 2024 and May 2026, never an asking price. For each game we took the sales of loose discs (the disc alone, no case) from its latest year of sales and used the middle price, so one wild auction can't push a game up the list. You only need the disc to play, so the loose price sets the order, with one exception you'll meet at the end.

We ranked regular retail games only. Collector's editions and hardware bundles are left out, and a Platinum Hits reprint shares its entry with the original game. Some games have too few recent sales to rank, and The Guy Game and the Platinum Hits copy of NBA Ballers are two of them.

10. Jurassic Park: Operation Genesis (2003): $40

Jurassic Park: Operation Genesis gameplay on XboxJurassic Park: Operation Genesis box art

Loose discs of Jurassic Park: Operation Genesis sold for a typical $40 across 25 sales between July 2024 and July 2025, and boxed copies went for a typical $75 across 30 sales. Silent Hill 2 and Curse: The Eye of Isis each finished one cent behind it, which is as close as this list gets.

Blue Tongue Entertainment made it over 22 months, and Universal Interactive released it in North America in March 2003. You hatch dinosaurs and build attractions, and the park has to stay secure. The films spent years warning people not to do this, and the game hands you the budget anyway. It also came out on Windows and PS2, and the PS2 version got the better reviews.

9. Fallout: Brotherhood of Steel (2004): $45

Fallout: Brotherhood of Steel gameplay on XboxFallout: Brotherhood of Steel box art

Loose discs of Fallout: Brotherhood of Steel sold for a typical $45 across 18 sales between May 2025 and April 2026, and boxed copies went for a typical $72 across 30 sales. It was the first Fallout game on home consoles. It sold poorly and got mixed reviews, and fans and journalists have ranked it among the worst entries in the series ever since.

Critics compared it to a hack and slash game, with fast combat against big groups of enemies. You play an Initiate looking for missing paladins near the town of Carbon. It added a heavy metal soundtrack, and it replaced the fictional Nuka-Cola with Bawls. Those poor sales may be part of why a loose disc costs this much today, since a game few people bought leaves few discs to go around.

8. Marvel vs. Capcom 2 (2002): $48

Marvel vs. Capcom 2 gameplay on XboxMarvel vs. Capcom 2 box art

Loose discs of Marvel vs. Capcom 2 sold for a typical $48 across 30 sales between October 2024 and August 2025, and boxed copies went for a typical $68 across 30 sales. It started in arcades in 2000 and reached Xbox and PS2 in 2002. The price took a big dive after the digital re-releases in 2009 and 2010, then started to climb again from 2016.

The Xbox disc is the cheapest of the old versions. PS2 discs sold for a typical $61 across 28 sales between November 2025 and February 2026, and Dreamcast discs for a typical $79 across 30 sales between September and December 2025. If you don't need a disc at all, the game is in Marvel vs. Capcom Fighting Collection: Arcade Classics on Switch, PS4, Xbox One and Windows. That was its first console re-release since the Xbox 360 and PS3 versions were delisted.

7. Bloody Roar Extreme (2003): $50

Bloody Roar Extreme gameplay on XboxBloody Roar Extreme box art

Loose discs of Bloody Roar Extreme sold for a typical $50 across 15 sales between August 2024 and May 2025, and boxed copies went for a typical $100 across 30 sales. Eighting made this fourth game in the series, and fighters turn into beasts in the middle of a match. Its fighting has more cancel points than before, so one move can quickly become another.

It came out on GameCube first in 2002 and reached Xbox in 2003. North American GameCube owners got it as Bloody Roar: Primal Fury, so look under that name if you own that console instead. The final boss, Cronos, is the only character in the series with two beast forms. His normal one is a penguin, and the game expects you to be scared of it.

6. Fatal Frame (2002): $50

Fatal Frame gameplay on XboxFatal Frame box art

Loose discs of Fatal Frame sold for a typical $50 across 30 sales between October 2024 and October 2025, and boxed copies went for a typical $72 across 29 sales. That's the good news for horror fans, because the PS2 disc costs more: a typical $79 across 30 sales between October 2025 and April 2026.

The Xbox version is an expanded port, and critics praised its improved visuals, so you pay less and get more. Makoto Shibata directed this survival horror game, set in an abandoned Japanese mansion. Hostile ghosts can only be fought with the Camera Obscura, an antique camera that captures them, and looking through it switches the game to first person. In North America it was marketed as being based on a true story.

5. Def Jam: Fight for NY (2004): $79

Def Jam: Fight for NY gameplay on XboxDef Jam: Fight for NY box art

Loose discs of Def Jam: Fight for NY sold for a typical $79 across 30 sales between January and March 2026, and boxed copies went for a typical $104 across 30 sales. The Platinum Hits reprint is a little cheaper, at a typical $75 across 12 sales between September 2024 and June 2025. This was a mainstream EA game on three consoles, and fans have kept it in demand.

The Xbox is still the cheap way in. PS2 discs sold for a typical $157 across 30 sales, all of them in May 2026, about double the Xbox price. This sequel to Def Jam Vendetta moved past wrestling into street fighting and martial arts, and you can only win by knockout or submission. Henry Rollins runs the gym where you spend your points.

4. OutRun 2006: Coast 2 Coast (2006): $130

OutRun 2006: Coast 2 Coast gameplay on XboxOutRun 2006: Coast 2 Coast box art

Loose discs of OutRun 2006: Coast 2 Coast sold for a typical $130 across 7 sales between June and October 2024. Boxed copies went for a typical $242 across 29 sales from November 2024 to April 2025, later than the loose sales, so part of that gap may just be time. In 2009 this game was only worth $20 to $28, and it reached $70 to $80 in 2016.

It did not get a very large production run on Xbox, though it stayed plentiful on PS2. It combines OutRun 2 and OutRun 2 SP, with every stage from both plus challenges and online play. You have a very cheap alternative: the original OutRun 2 disc on Xbox sold for a typical $20 across 30 sales between January and July 2025. Coast 2 Coast adds some extra modes and redesigned levels, and you can decide whether that is worth the other $110.

3. Teen Titans (2006): $165

Teen Titans gameplay on XboxTeen Titans box art

Loose discs of Teen Titans sold for a typical $165 across 6 sales between January and November 2025, and boxed copies went for a typical $186 across 30 sales. The Xbox version came out on October 13, 2006, months after the GameCube and PS2 versions, and it has since become much harder to find than either of them.

That makes the cheaper way easy. It's the same game on PS2 and GameCube, and those copies are easy to find for under $20. Artificial Mind and Movement based it on the Cartoon Network series, and most of the original voice actors came back. Up to four players can play together, and you can switch heroes at will. Reviewers liked how true it was to the show, and many found the gameplay boring and repetitive.

2. Futurama (2003): $205

Futurama gameplay on XboxFuturama box art

Loose discs of Futurama sold for a typical $205 across 27 sales between June 2025 and May 2026, and boxed copies went for a typical $332 across 30 sales. Back in 2012 you could get a copy for $30 to $36. The show was cancelled in 2003, the same year the game came out, and Vivendi Universal Games kept the print run low on both PS2 and Xbox.

The PS2 disc saves you a little, at a typical $188 across 30 sales between February and October 2025. This is a 3D platformer with a story by the show's writers, and Matt Groening was involved. Critics praised the writing and the voice acting, then criticized the controls and the camera. Those cutscenes are the part to want, and they came back as Futurama: The Lost Adventure, a bonus feature on The Beast with a Billion Backs DVD.

1. Steel Battalion (2002): $399

Steel Battalion gameplay on XboxSteel Battalion box art

The Steel Battalion controller set sold for a typical $399 across 7 sales between March 2025 and February 2026. That's our one exception: the game needs its own huge controller, so we priced the controller and left out two disc-only sales. It cost $200 new, and most of the value sits in that controller.

It has 44 input points, including two joysticks, a throttle handle, a radio channel dial, five switches, an eject button and three foot pedals. Capcom made limited quantities, and they sold out quickly. A later run has blue buttons where the first edition has green ones. You start up your Vertical Tank by hand at the start of each mission, and if you don't eject when told to, your character dies and the game deletes your save. Dark Souls could learn something. The disc alone sold for a typical $65 across 18 sales between May 2024 and March 2025, and it won't do you much good without the controller.

Typical loose sold price in US dollars

Related articles