One horror game on this list costs more than three times as much on the PlayStation 2 as it does on the Wii. The Wii is mostly a cheap system to collect for, and none of the ten games here sells for more than $120 loose.
Every price below is a real eBay sale made between August 2024 and September 2026, never an asking price. For each game we took the sales of loose discs (the disc alone, no case) from its latest year of sales and used the middle price, so one wild auction can't push a game up the list. You only need the disc to play, so the loose price sets the order. Boxed prices only show up where enough complete copies sold to mean something.

10. Tatsunoko vs. Capcom: Ultimate All-Stars (2010)

Loose discs of Tatsunoko vs. Capcom: Ultimate All-Stars sold for a typical $28 across 29 sales between October 2025 and February 2026, and boxed copies went for a typical $40 across 30 sales. Capcom put its own fighters up against Japanese cartoon heroes made famous by the animation studio Tatsunoko in the 1970s and 80s.
The Capcom side is oddly light on Street Fighter. Instead you get Zero from Mega Man X and Frank West from Dead Rising, and they fight the cast of Gatchaman and Tekkaman Blade. The fighting mixes the old Capcom versus games with the pace of Street Fighter IV, and it is deep enough for serious players. It looked better than nearly anything else on the Wii, and it had online play too. Nobody expected a game like this to come out on the Wii, let alone leave Japan, and it still sits among the best fighters on the system.
9. Mario Party 9 (2012)


Loose discs of Mario Party 9 sold for a typical $35 across 30 sales between August and September 2026, and boxed copies went for a typical $42 across 30 sales. That is a lot for a game that had sold 3.11 million copies by the end of 2020, enough to make it the 26th best-selling game on the Wii. Plenty of copies exist, and plenty of families still want one.
It was the first main Mario Party not made by Hudson Soft, which Konami had absorbed on March 1, 2012, the day before the game came out in Europe. NDcube made it instead, and it was the last Mario game released on the Wii. All players ride one vehicle across each board, with a boss battle halfway through and another at the end. There are seven boards, twelve playable characters and more than eighty minigames.


8. Dokapon Kingdom (2007)


Loose discs of Dokapon Kingdom sold for a typical $35 across 28 sales between August 2024 and April 2025, and boxed copies went for a typical $55 across 30 sales. Atlus brought it to North America, and Atlus RPGs usually came out in fairly small numbers.
There were two print runs. GameStop paid for the second one, and those copies have colored disc art instead of the plain monochrome discs of the first run. What GameStop did with the cases and manuals for that run is still a mystery. The game is half RPG and half board game, with a cute anime look and a battle royale mode where four players each get a mission. Friendships have ended over less. It started on the PlayStation 2, and the easier way in today is Dokapon Kingdom: Connect, a remake for the Nintendo Switch that came out worldwide on May 9, 2023.


7. The Last Story (2011)


Loose discs of The Last Story sold for a typical $50 across 30 sales between January and September 2025, and boxed copies went for a typical $57 across 30 sales. Hironobu Sakaguchi, the creator of Final Fantasy, directed it at his studio Mistwalker, and it was his first time in the director's chair since Final Fantasy V.
It came out in Japan in 2011 and topped the charts there, but North America only got it in August 2012, after a fan campaign called Operation Rainfall pushed for it. Xseed Games published it, and it became Xseed's best-selling game, ahead of Xenoblade Chronicles. You play as Zael, a mercenary who dreams of becoming a knight on the island fortress of Lazulis. Demand stayed strong, so for years its price barely moved from what it cost new. A limited edition was sold too.


6. Pandora's Tower (2011)


Loose discs of Pandora's Tower sold for a typical $65 across 17 sales between October 2024 and August 2025, and boxed copies went for a typical $71 across 30 sales. It was the last of the three Operation Rainfall games to reach North America. Xseed Games released it in April 2013, almost two years after Japan, citing the game's vocal fans in the West and the success of The Last Story.
Ganbarion made it. You play Aeron, who climbs thirteen towers to cure Elena, the woman he loves, of a curse that is turning her into a monster. His Oraclos Chain is a weapon in fights and a grappling line for puzzles and platforming. How close Aeron and Elena get decides which ending you see. It was also sold as a download on the Wii U eShop from 2015.


5. Ju-on: The Grudge (2009)


Loose discs of JU-ON: The Grudge sold for a typical $70 across seven sales between October 2024 and August 2025, and boxed copies went for a typical $100 across 30 sales. Critics hated it, and it holds a 39 out of 100 on Metacritic.
It was made for the tenth anniversary of the Ju-On films, and Takashi Shimizu, who directed the films, directed the game too. Xseed Games called it a "haunted house simulator" when it showed the game at E3 2009. You point the Wii Remote to aim a flashlight, and you have to keep finding batteries to keep it lit. The game measures how much the Remote moves, and the more you flinch, the worse you do. A second player can hold another Remote and trigger scares on you. That alone might be worth $70 to some households.


4. Silent Hill: Shattered Memories (2009)


Loose discs of Silent Hill: Shattered Memories sold for a typical $80 across 30 sales between January and August 2025, and boxed copies went for a typical $89 across 30 sales. That is the cheap version. On the PlayStation 2 the same game sold for a typical $290 loose across 30 sales between January and July 2026.
Climax Studios made it as a reimagining of the first Silent Hill. Harry Mason still searches a snowy town for his daughter Cheryl, but the cast and the plot have changed, and the game cuts away to Harry's sessions with a therapist. The Wii came first, in December 2009, with the PS2 and PSP ports in January 2010. On the Wii you aim the flashlight with the Remote, and phone calls in the game can play through the Remote's own speaker. There are five endings, and what you look at along the way helps decide which one you get.


3. Fire Emblem: Radiant Dawn (2007)


Loose discs of Fire Emblem: Radiant Dawn sold for a typical $85 across 27 sales between November 2025 and February 2026, and boxed copies went for a typical $121 across 30 sales. It is a first-party Nintendo game in a niche genre, the strategy RPG, with a strong following, and its price has crept up steadily from its retail price.
Intelligent Systems made it as the tenth Fire Emblem and a direct sequel to Path of Radiance on the GameCube, set three years later. Critics praised it and also knocked its brutal difficulty. It was the last main Fire Emblem on a Nintendo home console until Three Houses on the Switch in 2019. If you like slow, careful turn-based fights where every lost unit stays lost, this is a Wii game worth tracking down.


2. Metroid Prime: Trilogy (2009)


Loose discs of Metroid Prime: Trilogy sold for a typical $92 across 28 sales between October 2025 and February 2026, and boxed copies went for a typical $119 across 30 sales. It puts Metroid Prime, Metroid Prime 2: Echoes and Metroid Prime 3: Corruption on one disc, and the two GameCube games got the Wii Remote and Nunchuk controls of Corruption.
It came out in North America on August 24, 2009, in a steelbook case with an art booklet. By January 2010 Nintendo of America had stopped making and shipping it, and it told players to look for second-hand copies in game stores. It has gone up in value ever since. If you only want the first game, the GameCube Metroid Prime sold for a typical $18 loose across 30 sales in December 2025, with the original controller setup instead of pointer aiming.
1. Rhythm Heaven Fever (2011)


Loose discs of Rhythm Heaven Fever sold for a typical $113 across 30 sales between February and July 2026, and boxed copies went for a typical $147 across 30 sales. It is the third game in the Rhythm Heaven series and the first on the Wii, and it has no motion controls at all. You tap A to the beat, and now and then you press A and B together.
The minigames are as strange as ever. In one, see-saw testers bounce to a rock track. In another, you kick stray balls away from your date. Ringside, where a wrestler answers a reporter's "Wubadubaduba is that true?", was already a meme before the game came out in North America. Two players can match beats together in some games. The American release swaps the Manzai endless game for Mr. Upbeat, since its Japanese puns didn't translate.








